Changeset When Comment
61762371

Hello Zaman Nazari,
You've changed "surface=unpaved" to "surface=Earthen" on way/520617964/history . When adding more detail to surface tags, it helps to look at https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/surface#values to see what other values other mappers and data consumers will expect - I'm sure that there's a better synonym for "Earthen" (which another mapper has since changed to "earth") higher up the list.
Best Regards,
Andy

60924399

Hello Ajmal Takhnikyar,
You've changed "surface=unpaved" to "surface=Earthen" on way/580896441/history here. When adding more detail to surface tags, it helps to look at https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/surface#values to see what other values other mappers and data consumers will expect - I'm sure that there's a better synonym for "Earthen" (which another mapper has since changed to "earth") higher up the list.
Best Regards,
Andy

112330205

Normally this would have been done from the SomeoneElse_Revert account.

102690314

لقد قمت بإزالتها لأنها ليست مواقع تخييم عامة.

115435313

مرحبا،
من الواضح أن node/9370620925 (والذي يُترجم كـ "منزل") ليس موقعًا للمخيم. الرجاء عدم إضافة محددات شخصية مثل البيانات إلى OpenStreetMap. إذا كنت ترغب في إضافة إشارات مرجعية في MAPS.ME ، يرجى القيام بذلك.

115435313

Hello,
node/9370620925 (which translates as "house") is clearly not a camp site. Please don’t add personal markers like as data to OpenStreetMap. If you want to add bookmarks in MAPS.ME, please do that.

114412123

way/965042783/history is another one that does not connect to anything and has been reported to us as probably not existing. What was the source?

114412123

Does way/967666499/history really exist? It has been suggested to us that it doesn't. It doesn't connect to anything. What was the source?

115345174

... and one small gap in the Kintyre Way in Cambeltown. Nothing in between.

115345007

I've used https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1eup (the relation from 2016) to fill in some gaps here.

113567023

Hello, I've joined way/1000817343/history to the north to fix a gap in the Fife Coastal Path here. Presumably "foot=designated" means that there is a public right of way here. subject to https://www.mygov.scot/scottish-outdoor-access-code ?

115028369

It seems odd that way/1006304014#map=15/49.0992/25.1083 is residential? It doesn't look like residential on the imagery.

113316313

@grin - Andy from OpenSrteetMap's Data Working Group here. We've received a complaint about this, and other similar changes by you.
For the avoidance of doubt:
1) If you don't review each case it _is_ a mechanical edit and _does_ need to be discussed beforehand.
2) Removing an obviously invalid surface tag from e.g. way/988283137/history does _not_ improve data quality in OSM, it degrades it.
"invalid" data is easily ignored by routers and renders but is really useful to other mappers and people doing QA. For example, "surface=u" is surely just a misspelling of something, and a simple email to the original mapper of that tag would find out what that something was. Removing the tag makes it impossible to fix the data.
We'll need to review and revert this series of changesets.
Best Regards,
Andy

114919569

Also - just to be clear - you've removed lots of tags from node/8916227214/history . Can you explain why?

115293484

Hello,
Can you please explain why you've re-added Walgreens in capital letters here?
It used to be mapper in more detail until one of your colleagues deleted it: node/7782203196/history .
Best Regards,
Andy

115274282

This merges relation/10717039 into relation/3131984 .

106592172

Just for info, I notice that this name got changed again in changeset/107523997 . I've no idea if it's correct or not (although isn't Doire Cholmcille the adjectival form rather than the noun?)

115258018

لأي شخص آخر يعتقد أن اللغة المستخدمة في علامة "الاسم" هنا ليست هي الأفضل للاستخدام ، يرجى المناقشة في رابط المنتدى المشار إليه في تعليق مجموعة التغييرات قبل أي تغييرات.

115258018

לכל מי שחושב שהשפה שבה נעשה שימוש בתג "שם" כאן אינה הטובה ביותר לשימוש, נא לדון בקישור הפורום שצוין בתגובת השינויים לפני כל שינוי.

115258018

To anyone else who thinks that the language used in the "name" tag here is not the best one to use, please discuss at the forum link noted in the changeset comment before any changes.