@CAI Salò

> No further communications will follow. Thank you. CAI Salò.

OpenStreetMap is a shared project, and we have to work together to create the best map. You (as a member of an organisation) don't get a veto on that - other members of that organisation may disagree.
Please do join the conversation at https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/alpinist-routes-marked-as-footpaths/117644 explaining your thoughts here - we'd love to get your side of the story.
Best Regards,
Andy

Are you sure about "sac_scale=alpine_hiking" for Giddy Edge? It is halfway up a cliff, but it's not _that_ difficult, surely?
Best Regards,
Andy

https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/alpinist-routes-marked-as-footpaths/117644/73

Hello,
Was this mechanical edit discussed anywhere?
Best Regards,
Andy

See https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/prosba-do-zarzadu-osm/117380/10 "Can’t be secondary because of road signs D-40 “living street” and D-41 “end of living street”:"

Sowerby Bridge to Brighouse, from survey 2/8/2024, ts1131a

Great - thanks.

Hello,
It looks like this has made way/103563702/history all one long bridge.
I'm guessing that this is not correct?
Best Regards,
Andy

Hello,
It looks like this edit has made way/98531456/history all one very long bridge.
I'm guessing that that is not correct?
Best Regards,
Andy

So should they still be there as "rcn"s, or are those already mapped as something else?

(and NCN265)

Hello,
You've deleted NCN266 here - is that no longer a thing?
Best Regards,
Andy

Hello tokyoo and welcome to OpenStreetMap!
I've removed the "park" here because it doesn't seem to match reality - it just looks like residential gardens.
If you've got any questions about what it is OK to add and what not, please don't hesitate to ask.
Best Regards,
Andy

Cala Homes (the "natural" value you deleted) is a housebuilding company.

At https://maproulette.org/browse/challenges/48596 under "get in touch" there's no reply from you (and of course you might not even have seen those comments).

Great - thanks for checking!

Ah - thanks for that link!

Thanks!

I'm not sure you can use that to reliably distinguish between what in OSM would be called a track or a service road. Compare https://map.atownsend.org.uk/maps/map/map.html#16/58.9754/-3.3498/2 and https://map.atownsend.org.uk/maps/map/map.html#16/58.9754/-3.3498/6 ,

The "service road" way/843077022/history was added by an Amazon mapper using their piss-poor "AI". As you can see from the imagery, that extra bit does not access a house but a field to the south of the farmyard. way/1192178580 looks like a (recent) residential property here; everything within way/952668378 farm buildings.