Changeset When Comment
187036776

@FajrAl Apakah Anda memerlukan bantuan untuk melakukan pembatalan perubahan di sini?

Sebagai catatan tambahan, ini adalah jenis suntingan yang *seharusnya* didiskusikan terlebih dahulu dengan komunitas untuk mencegah kesalahpahaman.

187036776

@FajrAl Do you need help with a revert here?

For completeness, this is _exactly_ the sort of edit that should be discussed with the community first to prevent any misunderstanding.

187096654

Also, quoting "amenity=car_repair":
"Under no circumstances should you (semi-)automatically change “deprecated” tags to something else in the database on a large scale without conforming to the automated edits code of conduct. Any such change will be reverted."

187096654

You've tagfiddled "amenity=car_repair" to https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/search?q=service%3Dcar_repair . That's much rarer than https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/search?q=shop%3Dcar_repair . Any reason why?

187097338

Have you checked with any data consumers of the tags you are changing?

187038575

This looks very much like a mechanical edit. Did you go through osm.wiki/Automated_edits and discuss these changes with any consumers of these tags?

187253984

Also ts2784a to Stalybridge. Huddersfield Narrow Canal.

187094875

Following on from the questions in changeset/156807539 , does the driveway way/1505731276/history really have names in three languages? " 2nd Street's 3rd Dead End" sounds more like a description than a name.

156807539

@David Osipov Please answer the questions.
It is an entirely reasonable request to check whether some data added to OSM has some factual basis.

186639819

Re "There is no way the Three Forests way should be joining the road here as its a fast main road with no safe crossing point"; that sounds like something that someone would need to take up with Essex Ramblers according to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Forests_Way .
The key question would be where is it actually signed on the ground as going - if it's waymarked at relation/2173689#map=23/51.64164723/0.08373647&layers=S pointing west and south then that's how it should go in OSM; or if it is signed north, round and back then it should go that way instead.

186917397

(for info I'm just looking at http://ra.osmsurround.org/analyzeMap?relationId=11017 )

186917397

I'm guessing that the bridge at relation/11017#map=22/54.9897956/-3.4762995&layers=V might want removing from NCN7 as well?

186798420

Hello,
Is way/1526345700 really all one big building? I'm guessing that the old buildings such as way/185499592/history (Just Tyres) have long gone, and there's now a differently shaped building here?
Best Regards,
Andy

185347266

It's clearly not water either. See changeset/185316811 .

186639819

Hello,
Previously way/43082814/history#map=19/51.641481/0.083364 used to join the road (see https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/2ufR ). Now it doesn't, and there's a gap in the Three Forests Way at relation/2173689#map=19/51.641462/0.083930 . Presumably it does in reality join the road?
Best Regards,
Andy

186858339

Source was linked note, not survey.

171922553

I'm not sure what happened here but I've _really_ removed it just now (and added a few more tags)

186170535

It's not to do with this change at all; I just thought you might know whether that other bit was also part of the relation?

186290447

Note that some of the things changed may both have a valid `name:ca` and a valid `name:es`. Depending on what is in-use locally, it may be appropriate for some `name` tags to contain both languages (in either order).

This revert is a status-quo-ante revert of some bad-faith edits - see https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/usuarios-editando-en-espana-bajo-sospecha-vandalismo-malas-practicas-y-otros/2510/151 for detail.

An example of where both names appear to be in use is way/243330496/history (see unfortunately not-directly-usable photo at https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/usuarios-editando-en-espana-bajo-sospecha-vandalismo-malas-practicas-y-otros/2510/151 )

See also osm.org/user_blocks/21009 and numerous previous blocked sock-puppets by this user in Spain.

185937912

Re " You can see this on ... or Google Maps Street View, for example."

For the avoidance of doubt, you cannot use Google Maps Street View to update OSM. The licence is incompatible.