OpenStreetMap

OSMCha has this great feature of watching edits around your neighborhood using the bounding box (bbox) filter. Today, I reviewed several edits using the combination of bbox and the new mapper flag.

screen shot 2017-04-10 at 16 07 54 </br>New mappers in the Philippines in the last couple of days

Note: Being a new mapper does not mean making bad edits per se, but by being new, we can commit errors because of unfamiliarity with the best practices of editing. Admit it old mappers, we made mistakes before. ;)

As I review each changeset, I often fix common errors based on my familiarity with the area. After fixing, I usually add a comment to the user’s changeset explaining my edits and encouraging them to continue contributing to the project.

screen shot 2017-04-10 at 16 16 46 </br>My changeset comments

While re-reading my comments, I realized I’m doing something wrong! My comments were peppered with OSM technical jargon new mappers may not even know of. I’m imagining this new user’s reaction 🤔 to my comment.

  • What is a changeset?
  • What do you mean by tags? Amenity, shop, building; what’s the difference?
  • How can I go back to my edits and correct them?

Next time, I’ll try to simplify my comments and avoid hard to understand terminologies. It is challenging to simplify without losing the substance of the comment, but, it is equally important to engage new users as first step in engaging in a conversation.

How do you welcome new users in your neighborhood?

Discussion

Comment from Dr Kludge on 10 April 2017 at 18:37

@manings I think that there are problems here that you are not thinking of. * Change set comments and OSMCha become mapper death squad tools, if we only show up when a new mapper does something bad. * How about using thank you for your contribution even if it is not the most stellar edit? * You come off creepy, when you follow new mappers around changing their edits. * I don’t think that you not engage most new mappers in a conversation with this type of workflow. Think about it. A new person joins up and makes an edit. Big brother shows up and the other shoe falls. If the mapper is timid, then they may become embarrassed that they made a mistake. OSM may never see another edit from that mapper again.

Comment from manings on 11 April 2017 at 09:17

Hi Dr Kludge,

How about using thank you for your contribution even if it is not the most stellar edit?

Yes I also do that.

Big brother shows up and the other shoe falls. If the mapper is timid, then they may become embarrassed that they made a mistake.

This is a possibility, but from my previous interactions, they do appreciate the feedback.

Log in to leave a comment