OpenStreetMap

Diary Entries in English

Recent diary entries

The eTrex 20x

Years ago when searching for a viewpoint from an old photo where I wanted to do rail photography I managed to locate the exact cliffside overlook and discovered a somewhat hidden gem of trail network in the process.

Though there is an official dirt road in the canyon below and a few desire paths offshooting from it the hills above remained relatively unmapped not showing up in the otherwise void of an area.

With the understatement of the local forecast for the afternoon/evening I packed my beloved eTrex 20x in the camera bag along with my trusty Nikon D700 planning to take in some of the views while there in between tracing runs expecting no more than some cloudiness and a light sprinkling.

The Overlook

I had originally planned to do some averaging as well to mark down 3 of my favorite spots on the cliff to photograph the scenery below but just as I reached the overlook the light rain that had accompanied me on most of my journey up started to thicken and become slanted. Just as I positioned myself on the side of the ledge for my first point reading spot the wind had picked up considerably to near constant 70kph gusts. The eTrex wobbled fiercely atop the perching rock and I had to scrap my plans of more photos just to hold it still for fear it may fall to it’s death below as my other hand clinged to the rockface hoping to avoid a similar fate.

After 5 minutes to allow a good average I quickly hit save and climbed back up to grab my gear bag and make my way back down the path for the second tracing run in the opposite direction to help iron out anomalies when mapping from the trace. As I set off the steadily increasing rainfall now started to turn to almost sideways hail from every direction as the many rockfaces perturbed the wind. Though hectic as it may seem the eTrex managed to maintain it’s nice 8 foot accuracy throughout most of the trip and likewise I was similarly high spirits.

In an almost serene state of mind while walking the trails my attention drew to the contrast between the dramatic weather and environment and the life which springs forth from otherwise dead plains because of it. Many cacti once shriveled from the dry winter were now stuffed with water, their beautiful flowers blooming brightly pink which would soon bear fruit. The normally tan plains dead with brush now teeming with fluorescent wildflowers of all colors in every direction. In that moment I remembered who I was when escaping here 11 years ago, hurt and tired of the chaos and sterility of the urban design seeking to hide from the world and in the process discovering a new one all to myself.

All in a day's mapping

It’s these things the fuel my passion for exploring and desire to document what’s around me, the eTrex always at my side as a faithful companion for so long now. The amount of memories and many long adventure it holds being priceless to me.

Posted by FargoColdYa on 26 April 2024 in English.

Summary: What if AI creates the Changeset Comments? We could send locations, tag types, and quantities to get an output. AI would have to be run locally with small models for cost and be validated by the user.

Problem 1: Time I assume that 1,000 users create 2 changes in 1 day. We assume that each change set takes 3.5 seconds. 1000 users *2 changes * 3.5 seconds per change = 7000 seconds. OSM Users spend about 1.9 hours per day.

Problem 2: Skill Outsourcing Users should spend time on the things AI can’t do.

Problem 3: Server Side Peer Review We have human generated changeset comments. We could create AI generated changeset comments. We could ask the AI, “are these 2 changeset comments so different that it looks malicious”?

General AI Inputs: 1. Location: Where did the user map? 2. Feature Types: What tags did the user use?

AI Prompt: “You are an AI system. A user made edits in OpenStreetMap, a collaborative mapping project. They mapped locations[Mappleville, MN, USA; Bobville, MN, USA] with tags[50xSidewalks, 20xMarkedCrossings, & 10xReligous Areas]. You will create a changeset comment that concisely tells human reviewers what this changeset was about in 3 sentences or less. Exact numbers are not important. Changesets describe changes, so don’t request anything. Don’t mention anything that is common across all changesets.”

AI Response (https://www.meta.ai/): “Added sidewalks, marked crossings, and religious areas in Mappleville and Bobville, MN. Improved pedestrian and accessibility mapping. Enhanced local community information.”

Specific AI Inputs for Locations: 1. Cities[1 to 5], States[1 to 5], Countries[1 to 5]. 2. Is this a place with unclear boundaries? (What if somebody maps the ocean) 3. What is the size of the bounding box for this edit in KM?

Specific AI Inputs for Feature Types: Tags[1 to 6] & corresponding Quantities

Algorithms: 1. Sort the following tags by how frequently each was used in descending order and a limit of 5. 2. For each city, how often was each tag used? Create a table unless the table is huge.

Complexities of the process: 1. Disputed Boundaries: This was the changeset that changed the boarder. 2. Large Edits: Do not run this edit over changesets larger than 500 edits. 3. Malicious Inputs: Somebody named a building tag after a war crime. The AI received that as an input. What does the AI say? 4. Resource Allocation: Developer Time could be better spent doing something else. 5. Irregular Edits: I will use every tag in OSM only once. I will map an area the size of a continent.

Complexities of AI in general: 1. Uncommon Languages: Are these things only good at the 5 biggest languages? 2. Edit Safety: The user mapped religious areas in 2 different nations that share a disputed boarder and are in a war. 3. Money: Laptops with TPU’s are not common in 2024 (but will be in 2030). Mobile Editors with TPU’s are not common in 2024 (but will be on high end phones in 2030). Running AI costs money. Who will pay for it?

Solutions: 1. AI runs locally on a TPU. 2. If you use the outputs of an AI for changeset comments, you are responsible for safety.

Disclaimers: 1. I don’t work in AI. 2. I describe what I don’t have the resources to build. 3. I assume that developer resources should focus on high priority tasks.

Expected Development Difficulty: 1. Web to TPU is hard: Graphics have standard libraries (OpenGL). AI TPU’s are not common and don’t have standard libraries. 2. This can create giant tables if you are not careful.

The benefits of manual changesets: 1. Spam is harder to create in bulk. 2. Self reflection is encouraged. 3. Individuality is good to see. 4. Changesets are the alternative to the Change Approval Board (CAB meetings). It is supposed to take effort.

TLDR: OpenStreetMap (OSM) edits could be aided with AI-generated changeset comments, potentially saving users 1.9 hours daily. AI could analyze edit locations and feature types to generate concise comments, freeing users to focus on tasks that require human expertise. However, implementing AI-generated comments requires addressing complexities like disputed boundaries, TPU libraries, and malicious inputs.

Location: Rose Creek, Fargo, Cass County, North Dakota, United States

There are some object categories in OSM whose exact classification is often a matter of contention and edit wars. Main highways are one of the most prominent examples. There was a small edit war in Poland which resulted in no less than 4 blocks, but I did not let that crisis go to waste:

Behold road-watcher, a quick Python project that regurarly queries Overpass API for highway=secondary and above within a specified boundary and then detects any classification changes, sending them to a Discord channel (though it’s trivial to substitute it with another means of notification).

obraz.png

The SMCoSE YouthMappers Chapter, renowned as one of Tanzania’s largest mapping communities, hosted a transformative mapathon on April 14, 2024, at the esteemed Sokoine University of Agriculture. This event marked a pivotal moment of collaboration, extending invitations to other YouthMappers chapters in Morogoro, thus amplifying the inclusivity and impact of the initiative. Central to the mapathon’s objective was the concerted effort to contribute to Project #15530 within the HOT Tasking Manager, focusing on mapping cities across the Eastern and Southern Africa Region. By leveraging the power of open data, participants aimed to craft detailed base maps crucial for diverse applications, ranging from urban planning to efficient disaster response strategies.

Amidst an atmosphere described as “fantastic,” the event witnessed a remarkable accomplishment, the successful mapping of approximately 25,000 buildings. This feat not only underscores the collective dedication of the participants but also showcases the tangible outcomes of community-driven endeavors. Moreover, the mapathon served as a platform for new mappers to acquaint themselves with essential mapping tools such as ID Editors and JOSM, empowering them to contribute meaningfully to the OpenStreetMap ecosystem.

Special recognition is duly owed to the Open Mapping Hub Eastern and Southern Africa (OMHESA) for their unwavering support, notably through the prestigious Spatial People Award. This acknowledgment not only highlights the significance of collaborative partnerships but also accentuates the pivotal role of organizations in facilitating impactful mapathons and community initiatives. In essence, the event epitomized the ethos of collaboration, learning, and contribution inherent within the mapping community, further advancing the cause of open data dissemination and spatial awareness in the region.

In conclusion, the SMCoSE YouthMappers Chapter’s mapathon stands as a testament to the transformative potential of collective action in harnessing the power of mapping for societal benefit. It exemplifies how collaborative efforts can foster tangible change, driving forward the agenda of open data accessibility and spatial literacy within Tanzania and beyond. “We don’t just build maps, we build Mappers”

Location: Mazimbu Darajani, Morogoro Municipal, Morogoro Region, Coastal Zone, 67000, Tanzania

Theatro da Paz, Belém/Pará - Brasil

O Theatro da Paz foi fundado em 15 de fevereiro de 1878, durante o período áureo do Ciclo da Borracha, quando ocorreu um grande crescimento econômico na região amazônica. Belém foi considerada “A Capital da Borracha”. Mas, apesar desse progresso a cidade ainda não possuía um teatro de grande porte, capaz de receber espetáculos do gênero lírico. https://www.theatrodapaz.com.br/

Credito da Foto; Wikipedia, https://pt.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikip%C3%A9dia:Wiki_Loves_Par%C3%A1#/media/Ficheiro:Teatro_da_Paz_3.jpg Theatro da Paz, Belém/Pará - Brasil

Mais um ponto turístico da cidade de Belém atualizada na plataforma OpenStreetMap https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/150449820 através do projeto #MapeaiaBelem, https://projetomapeiabelem.my.canva.site/home que tem como objetivo disponibilizar dados atualizado para todos a comunidade local e também para aqueles que estarão presente aos grandes eventos que acontecerá entre 2024 e 2025, #SOTMLATAM #FOSS4G #COP30 sem contar que esses dados poderá ser utilizado por todos através de APPs como OsmAnd entre outros apps.

2024, SotM_Latam2024, FOSS4G 2024 , Belém, Cop30Belém

Projeto MapeaiaBelem,

Site do Projeto Mapeia Belém. https://projetomapeiabelem.my.canva.site/home Objeto mapeado no Openstreetmap, https://www.openstreetmap.org/changeset/150449820

esse é mas um projeto da UMBRAOSM - União dos Mapeadores Brasileiros do Openstreetmap

site: www.umbraosm.com.br

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/umbraosmbrasil/

E-mail: contato@umbraosm.com.br

Location: Campina, Belém, Região Geográfica Imediata de Belém, Região Geográfica Intermediária de Belém, Pará, North Region, Brazil

I am currently on a visit to Ireland 🇮🇪 and a lack of proper office space makes it difficult to stay productive. I will try to prepare something cool to show off this week. Sorry for keeping you waiting!

🍟

Location: Murphystown, Leopardstown Rise, Glencullen Electoral Division, Sandyford, Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown, County Dublin, Leinster, D18 CV48, Ireland
Posted by mpulve on 22 April 2024 in English. Last updated on 25 April 2024.

Why is OpenStreetMap ID not updated like OpenStreetMap ArcGIS? These are two different datasets that need to be linked/updated! Is ArcGIS taking over for OpenStreetMap and requiring a fee? ArcGIS needs to update OpenStreetMap ID if they participate! OpenStreetMap ArcGIS has not updated dataset in months! Please help with coordinating these two data set updates! Otherwise this in-browser edition will soon be obsolete! Use ArcGIS to compare your area with the link listed: ArcGIS OSM Are there any differences? Can anyone explain why? On the ArcGIS OSM there are more buildings that they imported from datasets. They should have updated the OSM ID data sets to match their information. Now there is a ArcGIS OSM version 2 that appears to be replacing ID OSM… ESRI

Location: Florence, Pinal County, Arizona, 85132, United States

Introduction

Car in action with Insta360 ONE

In this post, I will try to explain my process how to get best out of Insta360 ONE RS 1-inch camera and successfully upload images to Mapillary. It started out of my frustration of dealing with this camera and Mapillary and I hope you will not have to go through what I have been🙂. I will be focusing here more on software side (how to deal with data) rather than on hardware side (how to set up rig for image capture).

Let me first start with disclaimer that this is not easiest camera to work with Mapillary (hence this guide) and that not even Mapillary is recommending it. It definitively captures better images than GoPro 360, but everything with GoPro is more smooth over whole process, so be aware of this. Camera needs to record in video mode and it relies on additional GPS dongle you have to buy.

This guide assumes familiarity with Python and Linux. Most steps are optional, and you can treat everything as pure recommendation, and while you can always ping me to help you, beware that some technical knowledge (and determination🙂) is needed if you want to extract highest quality from this camera.

Capturing street view

First, you will need another hardware - “GPS Action Remote” with this. In theory, you don’t need it, as you can record with phone (or some other device), but in practice - you just turn on this remote and it works. With phone, you need to have Insta app turned on all the time, worry about display, whether app will get killed by battery optimizations, GPS reception inside car…. I decided to keep my sanity and use this little gadget. It will record GPS (poorly). Connect them and pair them and you can control camera through this remote. Once it show green, it means it is connected to camera and it acquired GPS signal.

GPS Action Remote in action

Mapillary is suggesting to capture images in timelapse mode. If you do this, you will not get any GPS data (that is - you will get first coordinate and that lat/long will be on all images, so unusable). With this camera, you have to record in video mode. This will result in larger files, more drained battery and prolonged post-processing, but hey - at least it will work. You can expect 1h 10 min of recording if you fully top up battery.

If you are using it outside of car, you can strap both GPS remote and additional battery altogether (watch for hot days and direct exposure of battery to the sun!), but I recommend to go out every 10-20 minutes and check if tripod is holding good. If you are like me and you want to be anonymous and don’t like to be captured by camera, every time you go out, do stop and start video recording again. If you just have one large video, it will be harder to remove yourself (but not impossible), so consider doing this. If you don’t care if your head is in video, then no need for this. This is example how our setup looked like:

Insta 360 in action

If you do not want to do video splitting, you will have to keep your video under 7-8 minutes! If you go over this time, you will have to cut them in post-processing as Mapillary cannot ingest video larger than 8 minutes.

Getting video and track

Once you go home, you will end up with .insv files. Download and open Insta360 Studio application. Import this .insv file. You can adjust quality of image if you want. I usually cut beginning and end of video to only parts where I am driving. If I went outside of car and were checking tripod, I also cut those parts (you cannot cut parts of video, but you can export same video multiple times with different start/end cut times). Once satisfied with cutting, export video. Important thing here is to check “Export GPX track”.

If you don’t want to deal with Linux and cutting video/gpx later, this is your time to cut video into 5-6 minutes segments. Anything larger than this increases probability that Mapillary processing will fail (anything above 8 minutes is impossible to be processed).

At the end of the process, you should end with one .mp4 video file and one .gpx track file. Let’s call them input.mp4 and input.gpx.

Fixing GPX track (optional)

GPX that is recorded with this “Action Remote” dongle is crime against all scientist, engineers, mechanics and everyone who worked hard to give us ability to know where we are using GPS. For this part, you will need to run Python program. If you can live with poor GPS, no need to fix anything, but I just couldn’t. Here is how it looks before (turquoise color) and after (blue color) processing:

And, no, it is not error in OSM geometry

What I did is I used Geoapify platform to do map matching of GPX for me. This is process where you snap GPX trace to closest road. It is really hard problem and I found that Geoapify do very good job converting this Insta360 mess of GPX and their free pricing is more than enough (not affiliated with them, just found them good and easy to work with). First go to their website, sign in and obtain API key (click “New Project”, type any name and on next dialog, just remember generated API key). Here is simple Python script that will take your input.gpx, send it to Geoapify for map matching and then update original .gpx to have new points (while keeping all other attributes like time the same):

import xml.etree.ElementTree as ET
import json
import requests

ET.register_namespace('', 'http://www.topografix.com/GPX/1/1')
ns = {'': 'http://www.topografix.com/GPX/1/1'}

def gpx_to_json(input_filename):
    converted_gpx = {'mode': 'drive', 'waypoints': []}
    tree = ET.parse(input_filename)
    root = tree.getroot()
    trksegs = root.findall('.//trkseg', ns)[0]
    for trkseg in trksegs:
        converted_gpx['waypoints'].append({
            'timestamp': trkseg.find('time', ns).text,
            'location': [float(trkseg.attrib['lon']), float(trkseg.attrib['lat'])]
        })
    return converted_gpx

def do_mapmatching(input_json):
    url = "https://api.geoapify.com/v1/mapmatching?apiKey=<YOUR_APIKEY>"
    headers = {"Content-Type": "application/json"}
    resp = requests.post(url, headers=headers, data=json.dumps(input_json))
    if resp.status_code != 200:
        raise resp
    return resp.json()

def adopt_gpx(input_gpx_filename, mapmatched_json, output_gpx_filename):
    # Load original GPX and segments
    tree = ET.parse(input_gpx_filename)
    root = tree.getroot()
    trksegs = root.findall('.//trkseg', ns)[0]

    # Load mapmatched segments
    waypoints = mapmatched_json['features'][0]['properties']['waypoints']

    assert len(waypoints) == len(trksegs)

    # Change location in original gpx and save it
    for waypoint, trkseg, i in zip(waypoints, trksegs, range(len(waypoints))):
        assert i == waypoint['original_index']
        trkseg.attrib['lon'] = str(waypoint['location'][0])
        trkseg.attrib['lat'] = str(waypoint['location'][1])
    tree.write(output_gpx_filename, default_namespace="")

if __name__ == '__main__':
    input_gpx_filename = 'input.gpx'
    input_gpx_as_json = gpx_to_json(input_gpx_filename)
    mapmatched_json = do_mapmatching(input_gpx_as_json)
    adopt_gpx(input_gpx_filename, mapmatched_json, 'output.gpx')

Save this code as “mapmatching.py”, change “YOUR_APIKEY” to value obtained from Geoapify, run it with python3 mapmatching.py with input.gpx in same directory. At the end of it, you should get output.gpx. Open this file in GPX editor of your choice and manually inspect it. Move any bogus points (it can happen, especially with hairpin roads) and save it - you can now use this .gpx instead of old one. I am using GpsPrune software (available for Linux too) to move points. Here is (rare) example where mapmatching can go wrong:

Splitting videos (optional)

If you ended with videos larges than 8 minutes, this is your time to cut them. I am using ffmpeg and exiftool command from Linux. This is command that will take input.mp4 and split it into out000.mp4, out001.mp4 … files, each up to 5 minutes in length. After that, I am using exiftool to bring back metadata from original video (just so it is nicer to play it in 360 mode in VLC, but I think it is not required for Mapillary):

ffmpeg -i input.mp4 -c copy -strict experimental -map 0:0 -segment_time 00:05:00 -f segment -reset_timestamps 1 out%03d.mp4
exiftool -api LargeFileSupport=1 -tagsFromFile input.mp4 -all:all out000.mp4 # repeat for other out*.mp4 files

Unfortunately, you will have to split .gpx manually (I could create Python script for this too if someone wants, but it was easier for me to just split it in text editor). That is - open .gpx in any text editor, observe time of first point, add 5 minutes to that value and remove all points that happened after exactly fifth minute. If you do this correctly and if you had video of 14 minutes and you cut it in 6 minute segments, you should end up with 3 video - 6 minutes, 6 minutes and 2 minutes as well as 3 .gpx traces - 6 minutes, another one with middle 6 minutes and another one with final 2 minutes. Do rename .mp4 and .gpx to have same names!

You are now ready to upload all these video using Mapillary Desktop Uploader. As long as names of .mp4 and .gpx are the same, you can just drag .mp4 file into Desktop Uploader app and it will show you trace and it will let you upload to Mapillary.

Producing images (optional)

In general, you don’t need this step. This is step if you want to convert video to bunch of images. Some of the reason you might want images:

  • You don’t like how Mapillary is handling videos (street view images too close to each other), or
  • you ended up with large videos that you cannot/don’t know how to split, or
  • you have part of video that you don’t want in Mapillary at all, and you don’t want to split it in Insta Studio app all the time
  • you don’t want to backup large videos, you would rather have images
  • you have poor internet connection to upload those giant video files

In these cases, you can try to generate bunch of images from your videos and upload these. For this, mapillary_tools can help you, but it is not easy to get proper arguments. What I found that works for me is this set of options:

mkdir tmp/
mapillary_tools video_process ./out000.mp4 ./tmp/ --geotag_source "gpx" --geotag_source_path ./out000.gpx --video_sample_distance -1 --video_sample_interval 1 --interpolation_use_gpx_start_time --overwrite_all_EXIF_tags --interpolate_directions

Conclusion

I hope this guide could help you with this camera, if you plan to use it for street view. Feel free to ping me if you need help in any of these steps or if you find that something is missing, or that Mapillary made some things easier in the meantime! Big thanks to friends BrackoNe and borovac who borrowed me this camera and who took these pictures (and whose car this is🙂).

We created a F-Droid repository for all Agroecology Map applications.

F-Droid is an open source app store and software repository for Android.

Agroecology Map is a Free Software, based on OpenStreetMap, citizen science platform that aims to assist in mapping and exchanging experiences in Agroecology.

  • How to add the Agroecology Map F-Droid repository?
  1. Settings
  2. Repositories
  3. Add (+) Repository (https://fdroid.agroecologymap.org/repo/)
  4. Scan QR Code or Enter repository URL manually

Step-by-step https://youtube.com/shorts/4Cw3jPzmS2I?si=zYxrgR1fHMfHEDq7

Posted by clay_c on 17 April 2024 in English. Last updated on 18 April 2024.

(work in progress; screenshots and visuals coming soon!)

Pipelines are notoriously tough to map. They lie mostly underground, often with little to no visible trace on aerial imagery. What may look like a pipeline route on the ground may actually be a tangled bundle of pipelines, and even if we can figure out an individual pipeline’s true route, imagery tells us nothing about its name, who operates it, or what substance it carries.

Fortunately, the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA), an agency of the U.S. Department of Transportation, publishes authoritative, open data on pipeline routes. The Public Viewer, however, presents this data as raster images and limits how far you can zoom in. Despite this, we can use it quite effectively to identify pipelines and trace their precise routes.

Workflow

Requirements: JOSM, with Expert Mode enabled.

Choose a county

There are over 3,000 county-equivalents in the United States. You may want to start with a place you’re familiar with, an unreviewed pipeline found on TIGERMap, or an area where you suspect data is missing from Open Infrastructure Map. Regardless, we’ll be focusing on mapping one county (or parish, borough, independent city, etc.) at a time.

Download the county’s pipelines

In JOSM, open the Download window (Ctrl+Shift+Down). Choose the “Download from Overpass API” tab along the top (if this is missing, open the Preferences window, make sure the “Expert Mode” box in the bottom left is checked, and try again). Paste the following into the query field:

{{geocodeArea:"Loving County, Texas"}};
way(area)[man_made=pipeline];
(._; >; <;);
out meta;

Replace Loving County, Texas with the county-equivalent of your choice, and hit Download. Don’t worry about selecting a bounding box on the map; it will be ignored.

Now that you have a canvas to work with, you’re ready to get started mapping.

Open the county in PHMSA’s Public Viewer

Open the Public Viewer and enter your state and county. You’ll find two layers enabled by default: Gas Transmission Pipelines and Hazardous Liquid Pipelines.

Right-click on a pipeline and select a layer in the Identify menu. The pipeline becomes highlighted in yellow, and a box pops up with details about the pipeline, including name, operator and commodity (see substance=*).

If your county has only a few pipelines, then this should be enough to work with. But if you encounter several pipelines tangled together, queries can help sort them out.

Untangle pipelines with queries

Click on Query Tools, then Query Pipelines. Pipelines can be queried based on various attributes, such as OPID (operator) or commodity. But for this exercise, we’ll be doing a spatial query. Near the bottom of the window, choose Draw an Area, and click the following button.

Find a cluster of pipelines, and click on the map to add corners of a polygon surrounding the bundle. Double-click to add your last point and finish.

Check the box for “Also display attributes in a table”, and hit OK. A new layer will appear on the map containing only the pipelines passing through the selected polygon, and a box will pop up with the details of each pipeline.

Select a row in the table, and then click the Highlight Selected Feature button below. The pipeline will show up yellow on the map.

Helpful Hints

  • Add as many imagery layers as possible in JOSM. Cycle through them with the backtick key (above Tab) as you map. You may find that one imagery source is good for a particular pipeline, but another source is better for a nearby pipeline (perhaps they were laid and photographed years apart).
  • It’s okay (and inevitable, really) to leave a pipeline unfinished. Just add fixme=continue to the node at the end.

English below / Português abaixo


Dans mon précédent post, mon propos visait à promouvoir la cartographie de terrain comme première activité concrète de cartographie OSM proposée à des débutants, plutôt que l’hégémonique cartographie des bâtiments, mais pas du tout à dénigrer la cartographie des bâtiments en tant que telle : alors que certaines personnes dans la communauté voient essentiellement OSM comme une base de données de navigation et jugent les bâtiments comme un objet secondaire voire assez inutile, pour ma part, je reconnais tout à fait leur importance pour divers aspects, comme par exemple, participer à représenter (notamment avec les barrières et les arbres) ce qu’on appelle en géographie le tissu urbain, ou servir comme approximation de l’effectif d’une population. J’ai d’ailleurs enseigné pendant quelques années InaSAFE pour QGIS, qui utilise notamment les bâtiments OSM comme données de vulnérabilités, ou coordonné la cartographie de tous les bâtiments dans les préfectures et sous-préfectures de la RCA pendant la crise de 2012 -2014.

Pour autant, je ne fais pas des bâtiments l’alpha et l’oméga de la carto OSM, et en fait, surtout pas l’alpha. En effet, ce n’est pas le premier objet que je ferais cartographier sur imagerie par des débutants :

  • Les bâtiments ne sont pas forcément des objets simples à cartographier et le sont en grande majorité avec iD, qui n’est pas conçu pour cela, ni n’a (malheureusement) jamais été modifié pour l’être.
  • En dehors des zones rurales où les bâtiments sont espacés les uns des autres, la cartographie correcte des bâtiments implique de savoir placer précisément les nœuds, voire aligner les bâtiments entre eux. Redresser les bâtiments tordus et mal alignés faits en ville par les débutants est une des tâches ingrates des contributeurs expérimentés.
  • Dans certains contextes urbains, avec un bâti serré et de plusieurs étages, leur cartographie est particulièrement complexe, même pour des cartographes expérimentés.
  • Sur certaines images, les bâtiments sont peu visibles et le résultat forcément limité en qualité. • Si le besoin en données n’est pas immédiat, il peut être préférable d’attendre une image de meilleure qualité, tant le « remapping » prendra du temps.

Je conseille plutôt de faire commencer les débutants par la cartographie des routes :

  • Le besoin de précision géométrique est moindre, on vectorise généralement à un niveau de zoom moins important.
  • L’expérience est nettement plus enrichissante, car elle permet d’aborder les notions d’intersection et connectivité, d’accrochage, de nœuds utiles et de sur-extraction, ou encore de classes d’attributs.
  • C’est également pour eux l’opportunité d’apprendre les notions de contrôle qualité et de complétude de la donnée, à travers l’importance de la connexité pur un réseau routier connexe, en travaillant par exemple sur les voies déconnectées du réseau principal, depuis Osmose ou Maproulette.
  • Une cartographie de routes de qualité moyenne est plus facile à corriger (mode W sur JOSM par exemple) que celle de bâtiments, et nettement plus plaisante !

In my previous diary post, my aim was to promote terrain mapping as the first concrete OSM mapping activity offered to beginners, rather than the hegemonic mapping of buildings, but not at all to denigrate the mapping of buildings as such: While some people in the community see OSM essentially as a navigation database and consider buildings to be a secondary or even fairly useless object, for my part, I fully recognise their importance for various aspects, such as helping to represent (particularly with fences and trees) what in geography is known as the urban fabric, or serving as an approximation of the size of a population. I also taught for a few years InaSAFE for QGIS, which uses OSM buildings as vulnerability data, or coordinated the mapping of all the buildings in the prefectures and sub-prefectures of the CAR during the 2012-2014 crisis.

However, I’m not making buildings the alpha and omega of OSM mapping, and in fact, especially not the alpha. In fact, it’s not the first object that I’d have mapped on imagery by beginners:

  • Buildings aren’t necessarily simple objects to map, and the vast majority of them are with iD, which wasn’t designed for this purpose, nor has it (unfortunately) ever been modified to be so.
  • Apart from rural areas where buildings are spaced far apart, correct mapping of buildings involves knowing how to place nodes precisely, and even align buildings with each other. Straightening out the twisted and misaligned buildings made in town by beginners is one of the thankless tasks of experienced contributors.
  • In certain urban contexts, with tightly-packed, multi-storey buildings, mapping them is particularly complex, even for experienced cartographers.
  • In some images, the buildings are not very visible and the result is inevitably limited in quality. if the need for data is not immediate, it may be preferable to wait for an image of better quality, as remapping will take time.

I recommend that beginners start with hisghway mapping (roads, streets, paths…):

  • There’s less need for geometric precision, and you generally vectorise at a lower zoom level.
  • It’s a much more rewarding experience, because it introduces them to the concepts of intersection and connectivity, snapping, useful nodes and over-extraction, and tag classes.
  • It’s also an opportunity for them to learn about the concepts of quality control and data completeness, through the importance of connectivity for a related road network, for example by working on roads disconnected from the main network, using Osmose or Maproulette.
  • Mapping roads or streets of average quality is easier to correct (W mode on JOSM, for example) than mapping buildings, and much more pleasant!

Translated with DeepL.com (free version)


No meu post anterior, o meu objetivo era promover o mapeamento do terreno como a primeira atividade concreta de mapeamento OSM oferecida aos principiantes, em vez do hegemónico mapeamento de edifícios, mas não pretendia de todo denegrir o mapeamento de edifícios enquanto tal: Enquanto algumas pessoas na comunidade vêem o OSM essencialmente como uma base de dados de navegação e consideram os edifícios como um objeto secundário ou mesmo bastante inútil, pela minha parte, reconheço plenamente a sua importância em vários aspectos, tais como ajudar a representar (particularmente com vedações e árvores) o que em geografia é conhecido como tecido urbano, ou servir como uma aproximação da dimensão de uma população. Também ensinei durante alguns anos o InaSAFE para o QGIS, que utiliza os edifícios do OSM como dados de vulnerabilidade, ou coordenei a cartografia de todos os edifícios das prefeituras e subprefeituras da RCA durante a crise de 2012-2014.

Por tudo isso, não estou a fazer dos edifícios o alfa e o ómega do mapeamento OSM e, na verdade, especialmente não o alfa. De facto, não é o primeiro objeto que eu mandaria mapear em imagens por principiantes:

  • Os edifícios não são necessariamente objectos simples de mapear, e a grande maioria deles são-no com o iD, que não foi concebido para isso, nem foi (infelizmente) alguma vez modificado para o ser.
  • Exceto nas zonas rurais, onde os edifícios estão muito espaçados, mapear corretamente os edifícios significa saber colocar os nós com precisão e até alinhar os edifícios uns com os outros. Endireitar os edifícios torcidos e desalinhados feitos na cidade por principiantes é uma das tarefas ingratas dos colaboradores experientes.
  • Em certos contextos urbanos, com edifícios de vários andares e muito compactos, a sua cartografia é particularmente complexa, mesmo para cartógrafos experientes.
  • Em algumas imagens, os edifícios não são muito visíveis e o resultado é inevitavelmente limitado em termos de qualidade. se a necessidade de dados não for imediata, pode ser preferível esperar por uma imagem de melhor qualidade, uma vez que o remapeamento levará tempo.

Recomendo que os principiantes comecem pela cartografia rodoviária (estradas ou ruas):

  • Há menos necessidade de precisão geométrica e, geralmente, a vectorização é feita com um nível de zoom inferior
  • É uma experiência muito mais gratificante, porque lhes dá a conhecer os conceitos de intersecção e conetividade, encaixe, nós úteis e sobre-extração, e classes de atributos.
  • É também uma oportunidade para aprenderem os conceitos de controlo de qualidade e exaustividade dos dados, através da importância da conetividade para uma rede rodoviária relacionada, por exemplo, trabalhando em estradas desligadas da rede principal, utilizando o Osmose ou o Maproulette.
  • Mapear estradas ou ruas de qualidade média é mais fácil de corrigir (modo W no JOSM, por exemplo) do que mapear edifícios, e muito mais agradável!

Traduzido com DeepL.com (versão gratuita)

Posted by GOwin on 17 April 2024 in English. Last updated on 20 April 2024.
image
It’s summer in the Philippines, and even at 08h, the sun’s already ablaze, and a friend with an umbrella is always welcome sight.

Our Tuesday morning in Tagbilaran started with a field mapping exercise with volunteers from the University of Bohol YouthMappers Club, gathering by the bandstand in Plaza Rizal for last minute rejoinders.

image

And so we got ready to head out to our assigned areas, to write down observations, sketching on FieldPapers, for fresh geodata we could use to update the neighborhood map. It’s also a practical exercise for the Geodetic Engineering students who participated, but not before a group photo, while everyone is still fresh-looking.

image

We also collected street-level imagery, which we also plan to use for a workshop. Panoramax , of course, was used for the initial batch of photos, because we want to use them immediately, a workshop right after the field work, but we plan to upload the collected images on Mapillary, as well.

image

We’ve had no issues using OpenCamera for capturing imagey , since almost everyone was using Android. We’d have recommended SkyFlow for iOS, but the outlier was a device with HarmonyOS, which uses “PetalMaps”, apparently a map service from Tomtom, but doesn’t appear to use any OSM data, nor Google Maps.

After a 90-minute dose of sunshine, we trotted back to the campus for the MapaTime workshop, a respite from the heat and then some hands-on mapping.

image

Each of the volunteers assigned to an area is given a theme to focus on, though they’re free to collect and take note of anything they find interesting:

  • Emergency/Lifeline features
  • Shops and Commercial Establishments
  • Mobility and Public Transport

The heat map below visually summarizes the editing efforts made by local community of mappers in Tagbilaran, hosted by the University of Bohol YouthMappers club. image

Their club is planning to run an initiative to improve the neighborhood map around their campus soon, and hope that the tools and techniques they picked-up from the workshop can be applied for that project.

Finally, a last group-fie with their college dean, and their “UB pose” – a perfect way to hide my double-chin! 😆 image

Location: Poblacion 3, Tagbilaran, Bohol, Central Visayas, 6390, Philippines

Welcome to my fifth OpenStreetMap NextGen development diary.
This week has been mostly focused on GPS Traces 🛰.

🔖 You can read my other development diaries here:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/user/NorthCrab/diary/

🐙 This project is open-source and publicly available:
https://github.com/Zaczero/openstreetmap-ng

GPS Traces Demo

It’s best to experience the refreshed traces in a video form, so I prepared a short demo (no audio):
⏯️ https://files.monicz.dev/osm/traces-demo.mp4

For comparison, here’s how the same trace looks on the current website:
https://www.openstreetmap.org/user/bielebog/traces/11326871

You will quickly notice the super-fast upload speed and the new trace animations. If there’s something wrong with the file you attached, you will receive instant feedback on the upload page. One new feature is possibility to edit trace name. Previously, this feature has been hidden behind API 0.6.

One more planned feature is rendering the map behind the trace animation. Now that the system works on individual coordinates, it will be fairly easy to implement. Traces without a human-understandable point of reference are not as useful as they could be.

Unified Traces URLs

Let’s start with discussing the current URL routes.

  • If you want to access a way, you visit /way/<ID>
  • If you want to access a note, you visit /note/<ID>
  • If you want to access a trace, you visit /user/<USER>/traces/<ID>

Which is not consistent. OpenStreetMap-NG unifies this experience by introducing a new URL route: /trace/<ID>. All existing URLs remain backwards compatible and are automatically redirected.

Short-Term Development Plan

There’s just a few things left before reaching the core feature parity with the existing website. Those are the things I want to finish before inviting new contributors ツ.

  • Elements sidebar (50% work in progress)
  • User Diaries
  • User Profiles
  • Applications (OAuth) settings

Contributor Benefits

Last week I hinted towards the announcement of a contributor benefit. Today, I will talk shortly on 1 of 2 currently planned ideas, that will help the project grow and stay strong.

Firstly, who are the “contributors”? Those are the people who help the OpenStreetMap-NG project. For example: by testing the website, donating, contributing code, helping with localization, graphics and interface design, etc.. The scope is broadly defined, as people can contribute in many different ways!

Contributors joining before the project is officially accepted as the main OpenStreetMap website, will be able to become a member of the NextGen Founders invite-only community and receive a small badge on their user profiles. This feature is a part of the original announcement (under the name “Community Profiles”).

This is a time-limited benefit, that provides a unique thank-you to all people that help (and will help) making this project a reality. The 2nd benefit will be announced in some time in the future.

Project Sponsors 🏅

Here’s my weekly appreciation to the current project patrons. Thank you for believing and helping me do what I love :-)

Currently, the project is sponsored by 11 people!
Five private and three public donors on Liberapay, and three public on GitHub Sponsors.

If you can, please consider supporting the NG development:

Donate using Liberapay

Disclaimer

This project is not affiliated with the OpenStreetMap Foundation.

Posted by richlv on 13 April 2024 in English.

Having both GoPro Hero11 and Max360, I was curious whether there would be any use from running both cameras at the same time. While Max 360 captures all around, would Hero 11 possibly have better resolution, which could be useful for streetview platforms like Mapillary and Panoramax, thus also providing additional detail for OSM mapping?

Here’s the same object - a surveillance camera - from both action cameras. Hero11 is even a little bit further away.

Max360: Max360

Hero11: Hero11

As can be seen, Hero11 does offer notably better resolution, which could be crucial with signs and other objects - thus it does make sense to collect imagery with two cameras like that at the same time.

Posted by tbibby on 13 April 2024 in English.

My first diary entry in thirteen years, and so much has changed on OSM. The editing tools have come on so much, and there is now an incredible level of detail, even in the rural town I’m living in now. I think I need to go back to the documentation to refresh my memory and look at adding all the things missing in my neighbourhood.

Location: Nenagh North, Nenagh West Urban, The Municipal District of Nenagh, County Tipperary, Munster, Ireland

On April 3, 2024, an earthquake happened outside the coast of Hualien, which caused serious roadblocks and human casualties. OpenStreetMap Taiwan has opened 3 projects for mapping affected areas, requesting worldwide mappers to map buildings, landuses, missing roads or waterways in Hualien.

We are talking if there is a possibility to donate the newest satellite image after the earthquake to map the after-earthquake situations. And the possibility of hosting mapping events on-site after the affected area returns to normal, helping locals by mapping the newest map data.

Location: Minyou, Chongde Village, Xiulin, Hualien County, 972, Taiwan
Posted by GOwin on 11 April 2024 in English. Last updated on 22 April 2024.

That’s the name of the workshops I facilitated last week, with the goal of introducing/promoting OpenStreetMap, along with introducing tools like FieldPaper, OpenAerialMap, Sketch-Map Tool and Umap, to meet the objectives of local DRR practitioners’ upcoming mapping initiative.

image

Last Friday I had conducted two workshop in Iloilo, one (unplanned) for Iloilo’s Provincial DRRMO (disaster agency), and another for Iloilo City own DRRMO. In the Philippines, city charters may provide them autonomy from the geographic province they’re part of. These Disaster Risk Reduction Management Offices (a tongue-full, I know) are the government agencies responsible for mitigating localized disaster risks, and planning for disaster prevention for their respective territories.

Last year, in a random visit in Iloilo, I met some folks from the City DRRMO team and since then, I found out that they’ve capturing community-based hazard risks and perceptions using FieldPapers. Unfortunately, FieldPapers uptime wasn’t as reliable as before, and eventually the built-in Bing imagery became unavailable, too.

I’ve kept in touch with the City’s DRRMO team, and when I told them of a planned (gustatory) visit, they asked if I could run another training workshop for them. The small workshop was planned for a dozen people, but the day before the workshop I was surprised to learn than they confirmed 28 participants, and couldn’t even accommodate my own guests.

Well, that’s how I ended up with two separate workshops, discussing the same topic, but interestingly, the engagement was different with one group being more technical, and familiar with geodata/GIS/maps, and the other are more focused on being able to collect local spatial knowledge.

Anyway, with the feedback about issues they’ve been encountering with FieldPapers, I ran into the updated Sketch-Map Tool which now has built-in ESRI Aerial Imagery included.

FieldPapers (FP)

One of the earliest Pen & Paper tools I’ve learned to like, especially when working with folks averse to “tech”. It’s cheap, and it (used to be quite) reliable.

Creating maps could be tedious, manually requiring people to manually define their area of interest. I think it’s been years since the search function last worked properly.

The participant’s favorite feature is FP’s ability to use external TMS endpoints, and in our case, I demonstrated how OpenAerialMap imagery taken from drones can be used to deploy fresh maps that can be used as background of maps they wish to deploy on the ground.

image

They participants also like how FP serves TMS tiles of the uploaded snapshot (marked-up) map, which they can use as a background layer on iD (or another editor) for digitizing on OpenStreetMap.

Maximum paper size is ISO A3, which isn’t probably big enough when you expect participants to work together as large groups. That size is more than sufficient for individual mappers though.

If the users aren’t conscious about it, they may inadvertently create atlases with snapshots that may reveal personal or private information, so that’s one thing users should really watch out for.

Sketch-Map Tool (SMT)

This recently revamped tool now comes with built-in satellite imagery from ESRI, but you’re limited to that or the Mapnik (OpenStreetMap’s default layer) background for your maps.

The interface for creating maps is more friendly, and the OHSOME map quality report helpful, but it becomes tedious when you need to create separate maps for a large area, which one has to to create one-by-one.

image

One of the favorite features for SMT is it’s built-in ability to digitize (properly) marked features and create GeoTIFF and GeoJSON files out of the marked-up map. The data is not stored in HEIGIT's servers, so the risk of accidental disclosure of private information is minimized. Update: 2024-04-22 According to mschaub’s comment, the data is actually stored in HeiGIT’s server, but becomes inaccessible after a day:

One small correction I would like to make (or maybe I misunderstood you): We do store the original sketch map and the uploaded sketch map with markings on them on our servers. The first one, we need to be able to do georeferencing of the sketch map after it was uploaded. The second one we store to be able to improve our machine learning models which are responsible for detecting the markings. We do point this out to the users (see text on the upload dialog). But it is not possible, even with the right URL, to download any of those files one day after they were created. So data is stored on our server, but the risk of accidental disclosure of private information is also minimized.

During the role-playing segment, we experienced how quick the process may be like, from map creation, to the mark-up/reporting process, and the automatic digitization, then visualizing the created GeoJSON files quickly, using Umap.

Over-all, everyone found the tools easy-enough to learn, and accessible for their capacity level.


At it is, these two tools are complementary and one could be more useful than the other, depending on the users’ priorities. To wit:

  FieldPapers Sketch-Map Tool
supported layer Mapnik, HOTOSM, TMS Mapnik, ESRI Imagery
interface functional, but search doesn’t work more user-friendly, works as expected
registration optional none
max. paper size ISO A3 ISO A1
geodata GeoTIFF GeoTIFF, GeoJSON
TMS of marked-up map yes no
multi-map support yes tedious
privacy risks moderate low

I’m excited by the initiatives being drawn-up by both DRRMOs, though they are still working independent of each other.

The search and rescue team, and the local fire department, were very enthusiastic about using Pen & Paper to help map location of water wells (parts of the city are experiencing drought), while the search and rescue intends to use them for mapping highways attributes (width and access) and missing footways and paths, to improve response times during emergencies.

I see a potential to make more use of OpenStreetMap data in their local communities, encouraging local contributors to keep the map updated and relevant for their own needs, and the participatory approach they are undertaking, in collecting local spatial knowledge and experience, which could lead to improved usability of gained results for local capacity assessments, and the role of the OSM ecosystem of data and tools serving as a bridge into their formal DRR process.

I would’ve loved to see more of the local active mappers participating in the event and planned activities, but unfortunately, we failed to receive any word from the folks we reached out to.

Below is a collage of some photos from the activity.

  • image
  • image
Location: Progreso Lapuz, Sinikway, Iloilo City, Lapuz, Western Visayas, 5000, Philippines

While commercial map providers like Google, provide map data in local Indian languages, the local language labels are usually transliterated from English, resulting in errors. OSM, Wikidata and Wikipedia platforms provide a way to improve the local language maps leveraging multilingual labels through Wikidata identifiers on OSM, through semi automated updates. For good quality maps on Wikipedia and OSM, the Wikidata location needs to be accurate and Wikidata identifier should be uniquely mapped to the actual OSM geometry. I worked on removing the mismatches for villages of a district in Andhra Pradesh. I have documented my experience as clearly as possible, so that even users with less programming and tools skills can contribute to the work. As an example, identifying and fixing errors in Wikidata location is given below.

Identifying and fixing error in locations on Wikidata pages

Error in Wikidata location, as the place name is not seen on the background OSM map, before the error is fixed The geodata is presented in Wikidata page and corresponding English Wikipedia article page using OSM as background map. If one notices that the marker is not near to the names identified on OSM map, then there is possibility of an error. Even if the name is identified on OSM background map, selecting different zoom levels allows checking whether the place is in the correct location.

Obtaining the correct geo location for Gurazala, Palnadu district, Andhra Pradesh using Bharatmaps The correct geolocation is obtained from Open Data compliant StateGIS portal run by Bharatmaps.

Wikipedia page with corrected Wikidata location shown on OSM map for Gurajala After Wikidata coordinate location is updated with the correct data, Wikidata page and the corresponding English wiki article show the correct map.

Full article covers how to identify more complex errors based on the geographical distance between Wikidata location and OSM node location and also when the Wikidata and OSM geometry that is associated are outside the area of interest. Sample Wikidata Sparql scripts leveraging Sophox interface to OSM, which can be easily edited are provided to help contributors with less programming and tool skills to contribute to these efforts.

For more information, check out Improving geodata accuracy on OSM and Wikidata (Full article on OSM wiki) and let me know your feedback.

Location: Jayanagar 4th Block, Bangalore South, Bengaluru Urban, Karnataka, India