OpenStreetMap

d1g has commented on the following diary entries

Post When Comment
Der JOSM-Relations-Editor 10 days ago

German translation of http://josm.openstreetmap.de/wiki/Help/Dialog/RelationEditor is missing at the moment.

"Crisis of anarchy" 20 days ago

@BushmanK, I can understand your style/implication and criticism clearly.

Still, could I ask you a favour:

  1. Don't overstate "everywhere", "always", "they"
  2. "nobody": I care about civil and well argument discussions. I'm pro open conflicts. I'm against sock-puppeteers and passive-aggressive communication.
  3. Third comment here is full of shit and insecurity; second one is half-provocative. Drop "you have created".
  4. I understand that you and many of our users were simply pissed off by behaviour of some people, but could you still lower number of strictly personal comments please?

Try to support good ideas more frequently, It will help you to switch to the right and fresh state quicker. Ex, I love to watch what Mapbox does (or any other open company, really).

"Crisis of anarchy" 20 days ago

@salmin, @SomeoneElse, @BushmanK

Thank you for civil and well argumented discussion.

http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Etiquette

駕駛人校,如何分类? 22 days ago

Currently I usually tag the grounds as 'amenity=driving_school' and the track with 'highway=raceway'. However, this may not be correct, as the driving school may have its main office elsewhere.

We created E 2.0 to address exactly this case. http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Education_2.0

Consider using

  • education=exercise_area for site
  • education=courses + education_profile:driving=yes office
  • education_amenity:driving_snake=yes snakes

I agree that E2.0 tagging is not perfect and we should work better on E2.0 next time.

When you 'discover' a city that is not on OSM 22 days ago

An active Chinese mapper, what a wonder! :)

On a serious note, It can be that some mappers are not good at detecting roads-vs-paths in Chinese mountains using imagery, especially if this locality has no other sources.

Классификация мапперов на HDYC 23 days ago

Всё равно без разбора пакетов и осмотра местности не понять характер правок.

активность - полезная, но количество правок (даже в плюс) не говорит о полезности; добавляя можно навандалить точно так же

ОСМ вo все все все 23 days ago

Кому не шейпфайлы нужны, здесь другие форматы: http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Converting_map_data_between_formats

Townlands.ie supports historic names 26 days ago

Can I make that many queries to Wikidata?

When you enter data for 60K+ items you can query "all cities in country with property P1448". It should work, you can limit results if needed.

But I don't have the time now

when it's not going to provide any benefit

It won't harm you, you don't need to change anything yet. It can be that you will never switch to Wikidata API or WDQS, but you can contribute. You can donate data and wait when somebody will pick it up:

https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Wikidata:Data_donation#Why_add_data_to_Wikidata

Townlands.ie supports historic names 26 days ago

Thing that I can access data using SPARQL/CSV query without a line of code other than SPARQL. Not only it is perfect, it takes 4 minutes to do so and data will be up-to-date.

If you have interest, materials can be found here: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Wikidata:SPARQL_query_service/Wikidata_Query_Help

Townlands.ie supports historic names 27 days ago

Simplest way is to fetch results using

Database downloads and toolkits can be found here:

so I kept it all in OpenStreetMap

It is impossible to have qualifiers separate from properties in OSM: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Special:MyLanguage/Help:Qualifiers without parsing; furthermore, almost everything is multilingual.

Townlands.ie supports historic names 27 days ago

Impressive, but now I prefer Wikidata for this task, e.g. "Ленинград": https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q656#P1448 and https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q656#P17

Code in python would be slightly longer than 30L, but I appreciate how data is layouted in WD so that you don't need to unparse anything.

Newcomers are welcome, even Pokemon Go mappers 27 days ago

Some people don't like this swarm of newcomers

few users like Eternal September effect.

If they add real objects - fine, even if using suboptimal tags.

If they add imaginary pokemon parks and woods - no so much, right?

OSM value is not in "everyone can edit", but "actual, verifiable" data.

If they tag pokemon spawns using pokemons=here - then it's fine, but if they change woods to parks and vice versa...

Детектив 28 days ago

Влaдимир K Bлaдимиp К

copycats-аккаунты блокировать.

Единственное исключение людям забывший свой пароль называть учётки "Владимир К2".

Владимир, конкретно с участниками у которых месяц регистрации "вандализм" лучше вообще не вспоминать слово. Тоже самое про "бесполезные" правки.

Одно "правило" и один пример "неправильности".

Если человек идет на контакт и старается меньше делать ошибок, то можно оставить его.

ALOS Global Digital Surface Model "ALOS World 3D - 30m" (AW3D30) 2 months ago

True, thanks for other references as well.

ALOS Global Digital Surface Model "ALOS World 3D - 30m" (AW3D30) 2 months ago

Christoph Hormann then published his review of AW3D30 in August:

http://www.imagico.de/map/reviews_en.php

Finding the local experts 3 months ago

Mailing lists are dead, few use IRC regularly; the only way to spot local mappers is http://resultmaps.neis-one.org/oooc

And guess who forms a community and who is not. Some users may take a 1 year break in edits but can consult you anyway.

RIPL organized seminar on Building Information Modeling (BIM) and launched ARCHICAD in India 3 months ago

BIMcloud®, the world’s first real-time BIM collaboration environment

How many users can edit at once? What is the biggest instance confirmed by GRAPHISOFT?

(удалено) 3 months ago

PS; оформления акцента цветом, жирным и курсивом тут нет, приходилось капслоком пользоваться если кто не понял :-)

@mavl, смотрю запись удалена - я забыл сказать спасибо.

Статистику населения по странам можно здесь смотреть: http://data.un.org/Search.aspx?q=population

urban/rural учитывается у некоторых наборов

Time to cleanup the wikipedia:xx tags? 3 months ago

The problem is the inconsistency caused by having multiple keys from OSM to another database, when it could easily be eliminated.

Absolutely agree with @PlaneMad, we shouldn't have 2 keys at the same time:

  • wikipedia and wikidata
  • wikipedia:xx and wikidata
  • wikipedia:xx and wikipedia

It is simpler to update single wikidata tag, not multiple tags with unclear (undocumented) preference between each other.

Furthermore, it creates complexity (what key to trust/read/update first) when a single tag wikidata can be sufficient.

Time to cleanup the wikipedia:xx tags? 3 months ago

Glad to hear that everyone seem to agree that we need reference to Wikipedia/Wikidata in OpenStreetMap.

Dear all, please, use wikidata, not wikipedia and not wikipedia:xx.

@tbicr > Maybe better move wikipedia tags to wikidata? Yes

@escada > Perhaps it would be better to retag all the wikipedia=xx:... to wikipedia:xx=... ? :-)

name=* or name:ru=* or name:uk=* debate in Urkaine was horribly long, wikipedia:xx tags repeat mistakes of name:xx.

The best approach is not to rely on current languages in area of mapping and not to rely on users presence/local language in wikipedia=*.

There at least one objective reason for wikidata=* over wikipedia=*:

Wikidata IDs are more stable (they are not going to change it title of Wikipedia article will be changed from "A" to "A (in C)" or "A (geographical name)"

If you don't trust me in that, please listen to @pigsonthewing: https://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewtopic.php?pid=619459#p619459