Hi,

Could you please verify whether the gate and service road have actually been removed? It appears that your source is Esri imagery, and the most recent capture for this area is from 30 April 2025.

My drone imagery, captured in late 2025, shows both a gate and a service road: https://ibb.co/pjpYF3V8

Thanks.

@rajdhani Can you explain your comment? I don't get it.

Masalahnya tidak semua tower adalah tower seluler. Ada beberapa yang saya tambahkan sengaja tidak diberi tag pelengkap seperti `communication:*` karena memang masih tanda tanya.

Sementara untuk value `tower:construction` itu sebelumnya sudah disurvey dan tidak semua BTS itu lattice.

Sumber data? Bagaimana Anda tau semua tower berikut adalah mobile phone dan semua konstruksinya berupa lattice?

Bisa konfirmasi bangunan mana yang saat ini digunakan oleh Akbid dan SMA Taman Siswa? Edit ini menyebabkan data menjadi duplikat/redundant, dan memunculkan warnings baru.

Berdasarkan survey saya tahun lalu, keduanya masih berbagi bangunan, sehingga sebelumnya dipetakan sebagai node, bukan closed way/area.

Terkait penamaan, mohon tidak menggunakan huruf kapital seluruhnya kecuali memang merupakan nama resmi (misalnya “PLN”), sesuai pedoman: osm.wiki/Names#Capitalisation

Catatan: Bing Maps Aerial tidak direkomendasikan untuk area Cirebon karena citra satelit terakhir tahun 2022. Silakan gunakan Esri.

The links you provided weren’t my edits, though. I just checked this particular changeset, and I can confirm that the buildings have tiny gaps between them, even though they appear connected in Carto.

Thanks for the tip, by the way.

I thought I had already added gaps to all the building polygons, maybe about 0.2 m. Could you be specific about which ways were an issue so I can evaluate?

Could you provide the source for this change?

Last time I surveyed it about two months ago, the road access you modified was indeed no-car access, although cars can physically get through in certain situations, for example, during events when the chain barriers on the open parking area are temporarily removed.

Also, the bar barrier at the entrance doesn’t cover the full width of the road because it’s meant to let motorcycles pass to the parking area; it’s there to warn cars from entering. With your change, motorcycles wouldn’t be able to reach the parking area anymore.

I’d appreciate your clarification.

@user_5359 Whoops, sorry... That was an oversight on my part. It was a placeholder; I should’ve removed it before uploading.

Fixed now: changeset/174231564