SomeoneElse's Comments

Changeset	When	Comment
111670107	almost 5 years ago	(for the benefit of anyone else without access to the DWG ticket referred to above) This "revert of a revert" was indeed "discussed with Andy Townsend in the DWG in [Ticket#2021092510000174]", in as much as I asked repeatedly for the source of the data and got nothing but obfuscation in response. We're still waiting. Best Regards, Andy Townsend, on behalf of OSM's Data Working Group.
111668407	almost 5 years ago	@lockdownguy You yourself have been asked over and over again what the source is for this data is (by me, in response to the DWG ticket that you raised - Ticket#2021092510000174). So far you have refused to provide a source, giving only meaningless answers similar to "This is not an import, this is thier work as they draw in a big file". Please - answer the question - what is the source of the data? Without an answer we'll have to remove it from OSM as we've no idea whether the data source is compatible with OSM's licence. Best Regards, Andy Townsend, also from OSM's Data Working Group.
111668407	almost 5 years ago	> uploading a 10,000 nodes as a one changeset is not an evidence of an import, For the avoidance of doubt, uploading 10,000 nodes in one changeset is either evidence of an import or a _very_ broken working procedure that is likely to have the same problems (e.g. lack of conflation) as an undiscussed import.
105011189	almost 5 years ago	Hello, The Lachin Corridor seems to have changed shape again since this changeset. A week ago: https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1bvP Now: https://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1bvO Has there been any on the ground change that you're aware of? Best Regards, Andy
111689713	almost 5 years ago	OK - thanks.
111689713	almost 5 years ago	Ciao, Ho notato che non ci sono commenti su questo changeset. Chissà se è perché Vespucci è confuso sulle lingue? Il changeset dice che la "locale" di Vespucci è "en-XC" piuttosto che "it" o simili - forse mancano i prompt per "commento del changeset" e "sourceset del changeset"? Vespucci usa la lingua e "locale" del tuo telefono - mi chiedo se questo potrebbe essere cambiato? Distinti saluti, Andy
111689713	almost 5 years ago	Hello, I notice that there's no comment on this changeset. I wonder if that's because Vespucci's confused about languages? The changeset says that Vespucci's "locale" is "en-XC" rather than "it" or similar - maybe the prompts for "changeset comment" and "changeset source" are missing? Vespucci uses your phone's language and locale - I wonder if that could be changed? Best Regards, Andy
111562537	almost 5 years ago	Hello, On way/977813230/history (similar to the previous example I commented on) you've explicitly removed bicyle, foot and horse access - are you saying that you know that there isn't bicycle, foor and horse access here? If not, what is the path for? Best Regards, Andy
110939910	almost 5 years ago	Hello AlwynWellington, Andy from the Data Working Group here. Someone's mentioned to us that you've been deleting access tags here - see http://osm.mapki.com/history/way.php?id=722844462 as an example. By removing these tags are you saying that no-one knows what access is allowed here or even what sort of path it is? If highway=path is next to useless as a tag on its own; if it really is a shared access cycleway then highway=cycleway; foot=yes; bicycle=yes or similar would make sense. Best Regards, Andy
64097963	almost 5 years ago	Hello, Just wondered - is way/116686086/history (the cycleway) still there? It seems to be underneath way/47237323 . Best Regards, Andy
111331809	almost 5 years ago	Hello, What is a "bag update "? Best Regards, Andy
111529624	almost 5 years ago	Hello, You've deleted relation/8383304/history here (it was a no right turn that made no sense because the "from" way was one-way _away_ from the "via" node). It might be helpful to say in a bit more detail what you've changed (e.g. as well as "Fixed mapping of the road. Based on multiple drivers feedback and Mapillary. " also say what the multiple drivers' feedback actually was. Best Regards, Andy
111458675	almost 5 years ago	你好，你能解释一下为什么你在南极附近增加了一些公寓吗？此致，安迪
111458675	almost 5 years ago	Hello, Can you explain why you added some apartments near the South Pole? Best Regards, Andy
105577519	almost 5 years ago	270 / 5000 Translation results Ciao Marty5550, Il tuo sfogo nel tag "note" è stato progettato per gli sviluppatori di openstreetmap.org o dell'editor iD nel browser? Qualunque cosa fosse, posso garantire che non cercheranno attraverso i nodi di indirizzi nei dati OSM in cerca di feedback? Distinti saluti, Andy
105577519	almost 5 years ago	Hello Marty5550, Was your rant in the "note" tag designed for the developers of openstreetmap.org or of the iD in-browser editor? Whichever it was, I can guarantee that they don't go searching through address nodes in OSM data looking for feedback? Best Regards, Andy
111424432	almost 5 years ago	Merhaba, Lütfen OpenStreetMap'e sahte veri eklemeyin. Saygılarımla, Andy Townsend, OSM'nin Veri Çalışma Grubu adına.
111424432	almost 5 years ago	Hello, Please don't add fake data to OpenStreetMap. Best Regards, Andy Townsend, on behalf of OSM's Data Working Group.
111394483	almost 5 years ago	Hello, Looking at way/984800021 here and comparing it with different imagery sources it's clear that the shape that you have mapped does not match the building at all. If you use the Bing imagery things are clearer. Best Regards, Andy
111402443	almost 5 years ago	Also, the changeset comment here "#hotosm-project-11449 #mapbeks #UNMAPPEDPH #UNMAPPEDZDN #UNMAPPEDPH2021 #kcsredcross" doesn't explain anything about what you are doing - it is just hashtag gibberish. A changeset comment like "#hotosm-project-11412 #MedSeaFires2021 #AlgeriaFires2021 Mapping in response to fires in Algeria #kcsredcross" is much better since it does explain what you are actually doing.