OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
60480254

Is there a sign anywhere? Maybe there's something visible from the path?
way/731794606 is another one that's "oddly named", but I haven't had a chance to check that yet.

60480254

I'm guessing that way/605408743 is misspelt?

151668196

Was the original data import discussed anywhere?

151632480

เอ้ย มี "natural=peak" เยอะที่นี่เหรอ?
ทั้งหมดนี้อยู่บนยอดเขาจริงๆ หรือบางส่วนเป็นเพียงความสูงที่มองเห็นได้?
หากบางแท็ก "เหมือนยอดเขามากกว่าแท็กอื่นๆ" แท็กอื่นๆ เช่น "โดดเด่น", "natural=hill" หรือ "peak=hill" จะใช้งานได้หรือไม่
ขอแสดงความนับถืออย่างสูง,
แอนดี้

151632480

Gosh, there are a lot of "natural=peak" here?
Are these all really peaks, or are some of them just spot heights?
If some are "more like peaks than others", would some other tags such as "prominence", "natural=hill" or "peak=hill" work?
Best Regards,
Andy

151668196

How do you know, in each of the 3545 cases here, that the data that "AllThePlaces" has scraped is more up to date than the data that had previously been surveyed?

151571627

I've reverted this since from the comments above it was clearly questionable. Where there have been interim changes (6 examples) I've not touched those.

It may be that a case can be made for some of these addresses being wrong. Please make that case at https://community.openstreetmap.org/c/communities/us/78 .

Please follow osm.wiki/Automated_Edits_code_of_conduct for all changes like this.

151556832

If this is agricultural pasture then "landuse=farmland; farmland=pasture" might be the best option, or maybe "landuse=meadow; meadow=agricultural".

151556491

The "landuse=grassland" was my typo - see relation/13011741/history for the original value.
It's a patch of river bank, so "grassland" is perhaps a bit of a stretch. I didn't see any grazing on it when I was there but if used for that then maybe "landuse=farmland; farmland=pasture" might make more sense.

151555871

Is landuse=meadow really correct for way/992478432/history ?
From the available aerial imagery it definitely looks like some sort of farmland.
The changeset comment is "farmland=grass -> landuse=meadow ", but this (and other examples here) weren't previously "farmland=grass".

151555979

I've also reverted the others of this tag that were changed such as way/795506947/history . There's likely a better tag, though.

151556182

I've reverted this, for the same reason as changeset/151555979 . "farmland=grassland" is an unusual value, but it's surely less incorrect that "natural=grassland", which isn't farmland at all.
If you're familiar with the area, perhaps have a look at https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/keys/farmland#values and see what specific value (not counting generic stuff like "field") best describes the nature of the farmland here?

151582527

Thanks!

151555979

Thanks!

151571627

If you have "local knowledge" of the address of every Starbucks in the USA, I'm impressed!

151555979

Is the change to way/999575898 correct?
If this is farmland, I'd expect it to be tagged as pasture or something, like way/999575890 just to the south.

151429883

@clegeard yes, other people have reported that, see https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/the-osm-standard-tile-layer-looks-wrong-white-lines-abusive-comments-etc/111583/185 . Please mention in that thread that the CDN is also showing incorrect tiles for you in that location.

151567210

Thanks - some other changes by @noun%20allaoua also look like a problem - are you going to fix those too?
(just checking before I do)

151386260

Thanks. About the segregated cycleway vs footpath routing, that's an excellent point - I bet there are other sections although the way through Barry / Cardiff that could probably do to be moved from one to the other.

62358787

Thanks!