Hello.
There are some mistakes in your edits.
You tagged some buildings as starbucks/paris baguette/subway, etc. That would be correct if those businesses occupied whole buildings. However, that is not the case. They occupy only the first floor(or even part of it) and above are residential or office spaces. In situations like this, the building should be tagged with its primary purpose (apartments/office) and retail on the first floor should be tagged with a separate POI node.
Please make these changes or let me know if you need help. 👍

You are doing an awesome job mapping those malls. 👍

Hello.
leisure=garden is not a correct way to mark those parking lot dividers. They should be tagged as landuse=grass. Please see landuse=grass
"A tag for a smaller areas of mown and managed grass for example in the middle of a roundabout, verges beside a road or in the middle of a dual-carriageway. "

Hello.
Could you please elaborate why did you create and then deleted all these beach nodes?

Hello.
Please be aware that you CAN NOT under any circumstances use Google Maps, Google Earth, Google Streetview for mapping in OpenStreetMap! It is a copyright violation! You can not use it for reference, for verification, for validation, for confirmation. Please see osm.wiki/FAQ#Why_don.27t_you_just_use_Google_Maps.2Fwhoever_for_your_data.3F

Hello. Could you please elaborate what are you deleting in these over 1100 nodes? It seems to be spread out over nyc and nj areas..

My quote is directly from the linked article. Here's the screenshot of it https://imgur.com/a/k3iV1Dr
How am I supposed to know who you talked? I did not see any explicit documentation on this matter from the Mayor's office or BetaNYC(whatever that is) so I'm mapping based on my best understanding of the published official wiki page.

Hello. Per osm.wiki/Sidewalks. "It is recommended to represent the sidewalk as a separate way, if the sidewalk is not just attached with a curb but separated by a road verge or other barriers, to prevent routers from assuming free crossing". Most sidewalks in NYC are attached to roads by curbs and runs parallel along the whole length, as such they shouldn't be mapped as a separate path, but rather tagged as a property of roads.

This is a good reason why it's good to keep changesets to smaller geographic regions and/or types of edits. :) Making each changeset roughly a neighborhood or town in size makes it easier for others to look at them and for you easier to describe what was done. Also if something were to happen to your browser session, potentially less of your work might be lost.

Hello.
"Tackle Cart, Lower Manhattan" is not a valid street name.
Is this node the location of your office/store? Or is this just where you want to put the marker for advertisement?

Hello.
Your changeset contains 231 creations, 129 modifications and 50 deletions. A comment such as "see changelog" is not very helpful when trying to understand what kind of changes you are making. It would be great if your comments contained relevant information to your edits. 👍
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/97070005

Hello. Per osm.wiki/Sidewalks "It is recommended to represent the sidewalk as a separate way, if the sidewalk is not just attached with a curb but separated by a road verge or other barriers, to prevent routers from assuming free crossing". In other words, this sidewalk is attached to a road by a curb and runs parallel to it along the whole length, as such it shouldn't be mapped as a separate path, but rather tagged as a property of the road.

Hello. Per osm.wiki/Sidewalks. "It is recommended to represent the sidewalk as a separate way, if the sidewalk is not just attached with a curb but separated by a road verge or other barriers, to prevent routers from assuming free crossing". Most sidewalks in NYC are attached to roads by curbs and runs parallel along the whole length, as such they shouldn't be mapped as a separate path, but rather tagged as a property of roads.

Hi.
It looks like you named a bunch of businesses with very generic names like "Dumpling Place" and "Grocery Store". Are those actual proper business names or just categories? Categories should not be in "name" tag.

Hello.
If you know where this organization moved to, perhaps you could update this POI with the new, correct information rather than deleting this? 👍
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/96833484

Hello.
Please undo this edit. It is based on a 6-year old bing imagery which is very outdated. There's now a residential building here. You can confirm it with mapbox, esri or maxar imagery
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/96782632

Hi. I understand that making the similar edits and writing comments for them over and over is a bit tedious. But "and again" doesn't really explain what you changed.. 🙃 Writing descriptive edit comments helps other people figure out what a given edit changed.

Hi. Why did you map cycle lanes as separate paths when they were already tagged on both 5th ave and broadway?
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/96493594

Hi. For nodes 8264549724 and 8264549721(and perhaps others) you indicated there's a bench. Looking from satellite imagery, i don't see benches. Am I missing it or did you use some other imagery that shows benches there?
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/96492513

Could you please clarify you deleted all the data from this node?
---

Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/96194223