Analysis of usage of similar tags over timePosted by Math1985 on 31 August 2016 in English (English).
Recently, a new tool was created by Martin Raifer (@tyrasd) to generate graphs of the usage of tags over time. This is a great tool that gives us more insight in what drives the choice of tags by mappers. In this diary, I compare the usage of some related tags.
amenity=public_building versus office=government versus office=administrative
We can see that amenity=public_building was added to the map features page wiki in March 2006, before it even was used once in the wild. The tag started being used later that year, and usage increased rapidly from there on. No increase in usage could be detected when JOSM or Potlatch added support for the tag. Growth in usage slowed down in 2013, and in 2014 even a decrease started. I wonder if anybody has a hypothesis for the cause of this decrease.
office=government was added to the wiki in May 2010, when two objects were tagged as such. After the features was documented on the wiki, usage immediately increased. The tag office=administrative was added to the wiki in September 2011, when about 180 objects with this tag were in use. The increase of the usage of office=government and office=administrative sped up when iD added support in October 2013.
- 2006-03-24 wiki: amenity=public_building added to map features
- 2007-10-16 JOSM: amenity=public_building added
- 2008-02-21 wiki: amenity=public_building page created
- 2010-05-25 wiki: amenity=public_building marked as ‘do not use’
- 2010-05-25 wiki: office=government created
- 2010-07-09 Potlatch 2: amenity=public_building supported
- 2011-09-06 wiki: office=administrative created
- 2013-02-18 wiki: amenity=public_building marked deprecated in map features
- 2013-10-30 iD: office=administrative, office=government added
- 2015-11-15 JOSM: office=administrative, office=government added
- 2016-03-02 wiki: office=administrative and amenity=public_building deprecated
- 2016-04-01 JOSM: amenity=public_building dropped and deprecation warning added
shop=seafood versus shop=fishmonger
Usage for both tags was around 15 shops until voting and documentation started. Potlatch 2 added a preset for seafood despite fishmonger winning a vote. When Potlatch 2 added the preset, the tagging of seafood strongly increased (despite the vote and documentation supporting fishmonger). When JOSM added seafood half a year later, usage of this tag rapidly grew too, causing two similar tags to exist in parallel. A deprecation warning for fishmonger on the wiki had little effect. In 2013, iD added fishmonger, but moved to seafood a year later. When iD moved to fishmonger, the number of newly tagged fishmongers dropped rapidly, and later even the total number of fishmongers decreased, allowing seafood to become significantly more popular. When JOSM added a deprecation warning for fishmonger, the drop intensified.
This is a clear case where the choice of tag is driven by the editor of the user (see the increase of seafood and fishmonger when Potlatch 2 and JOSM added their preset).
- 2010-06-06 voting: seafood shop accepted (and fishmonger rejected)
- 2010-06-06 wiki: seafood page created
- 2010-07-09 Potlatch 2: fishmonger added
- 2010-07-29 wiki: seafood added to map features
- 2010-10-16 JOSM: seafood added
- 2013-03-20 iD: fishmonger added
- 2013-09-14 wiki: fishmonger page created and marked as deprecated
- 2014-04-08 iD: fishmonger dropped, seafood added
- 2014-07-22 openstreetmap-carto: seafood and fishmonger rendered as dot
- 2015-07-31 openstreetmap-carto: fishmonger and seafood rendered as fish
- 2015-12-26 JOSM: deprecation warning for fishmonger added
amenity=swimming_pool versus leisure=swimming_pool
When documentation started in 2009, amenity and leisure had both about 100 instances. This slowly increased until in 2011, suddenly the use of amenity exploded. It is not clear to me why, does anybody have an explanation? After a vote for leisure, a change of the wiki and a deprecation warning in JOSM, usage of amenity decreased.
- 2009-12-27 wiki: leisure page created (as redirect to key:leisure)
- 2010-10-11 wiki: leisure added to map features
- 2010-12-01 wiki: amenity page created (including mention of a proposal to merge with leisure)
- 2010-12-23 Potlatch 2: leisure added
- 2011-02-20 wiki: content added to leisure page
- 2011-10-27 JOSM: leisure added
- 2013-03-18 iD: leisure and amenity added (amenity as non-searchable)
- 2016-01-22 voting: amenity discouraged
- 2016-01-22 wiki: amenity page marked as discouraged
- 2016-01-23 JOSM: deprecation warning for amenity added
shop=musical_instrument versus shop=musical_instruments
Initially the plural was more popular. However, the singular started being used more and more when a wiki page was created and when JOSM added support for the singular, overtaking the plural in 2011. A mechanical edit in 2014 removed the remaining tags.
- 2010-07-27 wiki: singular page added to map features
- 2010-07-28 wiki: singular page created
- 2010-10-16 JOSM: singular added
- 2013-09-15 wiki: plural page created
- 2013-10-19 voting: plural marked as discouraged
- 2013-10-21 wiki: plural page marked as discouraged
- 2014-01-01 wiki: plural page removed
- 2014-01-01 mechanical edit: changed all plural into singular
- 2014-07-22 openstreetmap-carto: add seafood and fishmonger as dot
- 2014-08-26 iD: singular added
shop=bookmaker versus shop=betting
When documentation started in 2013, about 400 shops of each type were created. Increase of both tags was about equal, until bookmaker was approved by a vote, the wiki was adapted, and iD added a preset for bookmaker. Then the use of bookmaker exploded, but since these three events were so close in time, it cannot be determined which of them was responsible for this. Usage of the tag grew rapidly after iD and JOSM support was added.
- 2013-09-12 wiki: bookmaker and betting pages created
- 2014-01-19 voting: bookmaker approved, betting
- 2014-01-19 wiki: betting page marked as discouraged
- 2014-02-16 iD: bookmaker added
- 2014-02-17 JOSM: bookmaker added
- 2014-07-22 openstreetmap-carto: bookmaker and betting added as dot
- 2015-10-02 openstreetmap-carto: betting dropped
- 2015-12-26 JOSM: deprecation warning for betting added
For those who want to run their own analysis, the tool can be found at http://taghistory.raifer.tech/, and the source at https://github.com/tyrasd/taghistory.
Comment from BushmanK on 31 August 2016 at 21:56
That’s just super-cool thing. Here is the comparison of tags from old and new leaf property schemes, clearly demonstrating that argument about re-tagging being a bad idea is wrong:
Comment from SomeoneElse on 1 September 2016 at 11:03
@BushmanK retagging from “wood=deciduous” to “leaf_type=broadleaved” (which was what some people were doing) was wrong!
Comment from BushmanK on 1 September 2016 at 14:40
wood=deciduousshould be re-tagged into
leaf_cylcle=deciduouswithout any automatic global assumptions about
But if there were people who can’t read, it’s a separate issue from changing old scheme into a new one. They are equally capable of adding any other wrong tags.
My point here is that there were traditional arguments like “new scheme is too complicated”, “nobody will use that”, and so on.
Comment from Klumbumbus on 1 September 2016 at 21:56
Great blog post and great tool :)
Comment from Hakuch on 3 September 2016 at 13:44
simple great tool, would have helped a lot during the discussion about name_1: