Thanks for the good quality highways in this area ! Thanks to this, I can draw the woods without having to redraw all the highways ! Good job 💪

Hi, could would explain what did you change in this changeset ?

"NK" doesn't really help...

Have you read this wiki page : osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments ?

Have a good day

Hello, I saw your contribution in North Korea, thanks for contributing on this country, but I don't see any helpful comments in your changesets, it's always just "NK".
The problem is that this prevents me and other mappers from knowing what you've done when I look at the changeset.

Please could you read this OSM page: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments and make sure to have good comment on your future changesets ?

Thanks

Aurais-tu le lien du sujet du forum international ?

@PèreForez, oui j'ai été en difficulté avec tous ses éléments, j'ai mis une image pour que justement, quelqu'un qui comprenne mieux que moi puisse mettre tout d'équerre, je veux bien que tu fasse les corrections que tu juge nécessaire !

@trial Okay, mais selon quels conventions ? Il y a t'il des discussions auxquels je peux me référer pour comprendre la pertinence de cette préférence ?

Bonne cartographie à vous deux 🙂 !

Hi R_A, I saw that you've added a lot of objects in North Korea, thanks for this, but in your changeset I don't see the imagery that you've used.

What imagery did you used ?
In the future, can you specify that every time ?

And also can you use better changeset comment ? "NK" is really not useful...
Instead you can check this OSM wiki page : osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments

Good mapping.

"fire_hydrant:position=green" ça veux dire "hydrant dans une zone d'herbe".

Ça ne signifie pas que l'hydrant est de couleur verte !

Hum, mais comment ça "un PEI vert", c'est un hydrant de couleur rouge, qui sert pour les pompiers. Je suis pas sur d'avoir compris le problème ? C'est correctement tagger nan ?

J'ai fais une modification, en changeant les ``building:part=roof`` en ``building:part=yes``.

Le problème c'est qu'il n'y a pas de moyen simple pour indiquer qu'uniquement un pan de bâtiment est sans mur. Tu me diras ce que tu en pense de ma modification.

Ça reste entre nous alors ;)

Effectivement, au début je recopiais ce qu'il y avait dans l'élément Wikidata mais j'ai oublié de rajouter une majuscule. Merci pour la correction, effectivement c'est un nom descriptif mais que je croyais en vigueur du fait de l'élément Wikidata.

Thank you for your quick and detailed response! Okay, that's fine with me then, good work!

However, next time, could you please specify the source of your information? For example in you changeset ‘census of Turkmenistan 2022’. This will allow anyone looking at the changeset to understand where it comes from, which is particularly useful in the case of disputed figures.

Or even better, specify it with a "source:population" tag, as I did here some time ago: relation/7117363/history/12 (with a "Wikidata" mention on my changeset source)

Hello Saamat,

Where did you find thoses figures ?

Have a good mapping

Message from ljc in Telegram :

Checked their history and made sure that it was BigKev's machine translated road names with obvious translation errors caused by North Korean latin transcription method which differs from that of the south (k t p being used in place of ㅋ ㅌ ㅍ as they would be in the south, confusion of ㅗ from ㅓ due to ŏ being written as o with no breve, etc) and streets literally called [name] 스트리트

Hello ljc_jlyb,

I saw this changeset that changed a lot of names on Pyongyang Street. What is your source for this ?

Have a good mapping !

Hi, I've just see you edits.

Where did you find the english name for "곰도" ("곰섬") way/16380436 ?

The US NGA (National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency) absolutely don't use this one : https://www.geonames.org/1867345/kom-do.html (nor the old map from the US Army Map Service : https://maps.lib.utexas.edu/maps/ams/korea_50k/txu-pclmaps-oclc-6612107-sonam-dong-6132-4.jpg, which use "Ung-do").

Did you speak korean ? Did you master romanization ? (McCune-Reischauer Romanization, Revised Romanization of Korean, Yale Romanization, or better Romanization of Korean ?)

Thanks in advance for you answers

Hello! Where did you find this data (especialy for -ri) ? Is it accurate? Thank you, have good mapping!

It was a mistake I made when adding a tag too quickly with Alt+A on JOSM, I've just fixed it.

Are there any other buildings with this kind of error ? Is there an Osmose error related to this issue?

Bonjour, pourriez-vous m'éclairer ?

Je n'ai pas compris ce que signifie le tag "games=tabletop" que vous avez rajouté ?

Merci et bonne contribution

Hello, thanks for contributing in OSM in North Korea. What is the source that helps you add these shops and POI?