Created:
Duration:
0 hours
Status:
Ended .
Reason for block:

Dear user Nix_Nada,

you have deleted a driveway from OpenStreetMap because it is a private road.

(This driveway was, by the way, imported into OSM from an official US Government “TIGER” data set - it’s not like we invented it.)

The correct action in regard to private roads in OSM is to mark them as “private” in our database. This will still leave a faint line on the map, but anyone asking their navigation system how to get from A to B will be routed around. The reasons why we do this are explained on osm.wiki/Why_we_won%27t_delete_roads_on_private_property. We have no interest in sending our map users onto dangerous and private roads - but we have an interest in letting everyone know that there is a dangerous and private road there!

Another mapper has fixed your mistake by re-instating the deleted driveway and correctly marking it as private.

You have once again deleted this data from OSM, and threatened legal action.

Please understand that we are doing nothing wrong by saying “there is a private driveway there”; we are merely recording facts. No judge in the United States will allow you to suppress our freedom to publicly state facts.

By deleting correct data from OpenStreetMap, you are committing vandalism against our database. Don’t do that. I have once again restored the information you have deleted, and should you delete it again, your account will be permanently suspended.

Best regards
Frederik Ramm
OSMF Data Working Group
Ticket#2026102010000055