hi Kirbert, the comment on this changeset doesn't express what was done. relation/195845 now gets a "multipolygon is not closed" validation error. relation/119400 (also lookout mountain) seems okay. Can you take a look and correct?

hi Cffk! welcome to osm. I was mapping by the lake earlier this morning. Quick tip, if you press the Q key when you have the building selected, it will square the corners.

Hi 191, can you look at node/9414045410, it's a duplicate of node/9414045411

Maybe running josm validation after you make your atlaschecks fixes should be done as a double check for items like this.

Hi Ruf.
There are some problems with the golf course you've mapped. Can you look into fixing them?
here are some of the issues:
- relation/13659084 is a broken (unclosed rings) relation.
- rough is tagged as buildings. why?
- cart paths should be routable not areas
- generic things (like hazard) don't need labels
- there are several duplicate nodes - so things are not connected
- there are highways that have duplicate segments
- roads should not be connected to buildings
- there are intersecting highways without crossing nodes

Thanks for mapping the course, it's a good addition. And thanks for using the right imagery, and also feathering the fairways into the greens. Good work. Hopefully you can make the other corrections and use them in future golf course mapping! If you have any questions, send a message, or join discord/slack (there a plenty of other mappers willing to assist)

More information is in the wiki:
leisure=golf_course

hi Dru. your changeset comment isn't very helpful. did you mean to delete part of relation/13483621, or the whole thing? It's unclear, but it is currently broken. Please revisit.

hi WTrosky, welcome to OSM! Thanks for adding Riya Lane. Can you update Duff Road where it intersects Mount Nebo Road? The imagery is old, and has them connecting. Local knowledge is correct. Maybe look at noexit=*

Kev, adding way/1017472245 didn't include adding it to Ekland PA boundary relation. fixed it.

Hi flierfy, can you check the two relations for the islands (Chouteau and Gabaret)? I think your change took out a way from each. thx.

hi Keith! nice additions to the map, thanks. have fun, keep mapping. two things I noticed... Some buildings you added in the area had extra nodes or duplicated nodes. I removed them. The other item is changeset comments like 'A'. please read osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments

hi Ray, can you also look at cleaning up these two:
node/9355938273
node/9355938261
they cause crossing highways.

please read osm.wiki/Problematic_mapping/golf#The_Golf_Club_Games

hi Chronoshift, 'exit' should not be in the ref. I asked on slack:
"On the highway=motorway_junction: ref=139B
On the first way of the exit: junction:ref=139B
Either or both of those tags being present is correct.
There should be no Exit anywhere in there."

hi Stratos, i removed duplicate buildings, and some other corrections. Square/rectangular buildings only need 4 nodes in the corners. If you press the 'Q' key when the building is selected, it will square up the corners for you. Also read the wiki on golf tags and try to use them correctly leisure=golf_course

Hi TC,
Great job adding trails to the map, but this is a production system, not a test. if you want to check up on things, try adding a Note, and then resolve the note when you (or someone else) surveys. Also, try and use better changeset comments. "Update" as a changeset comment is not informative. You or someone else may look at comments to find maintenance on a specific trail, for example. One last thing, the name "(Does this exist?)" is not good practice. Here are some links for you to review: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments osm.wiki/Notes osm.wiki/Names

if you are interested, there is a slack with #trails and #bicycle channels

peace, way/1014432288 is still dup'd

hi Rienux, there isn't a pool here, it's a lake. maybe sport=swimming?

hi peace, this change broke the industrial relation, relation/11033109.
Can you look at it? Is industrial really correct, maybe commercial would be better?

hi simonah,
I do not think adding way/1014350907 was the correct fix. I think the correct fix is to select
way/49276354
and then click Tools|Update multipoligon Ctrl+Shift+B

hi simonah, can you check your fix? I think you dragged a node and doubled over a boundary forming a self-intersection.

hi VLD083! your relation cleanup broke relation/13533288. Please correct, and remember to load incomplete members before running validator.