broken is broken (not incomplete) and broken doesn't render correctly. You can use the link below to
to see the errors. Or, Maybe don't use id to fiddle with relations? I know, josm is a hard sell. Thanks for fixing!!
Keep editing!
https://tools.geofabrik.de/osmi/?view=areas&lon=-87.95000&lat=43.06819&zoom=17&baselayer=Geofabrik%20Standard&overlays=ring_not_closed

The six member ways of the relation don't form a continuous ring. Look at where the RR crosses West Center Street. There are 2 nodes that need to be combined. Grab the upper node and pull it aside, and you will see a triangle that doesn't let the two meet. Join them together and they will complete the ring.

Juggernaut, adding the roundabout broke the boundary relation/10364318, Savannah Village. Can you look at adjusting? Waunakee and Westport boundary relations were not impacted by the roundabout.

BPTT this changeset broke relation for Wurster's Subdivision. fixed in relation/15956293

BPTT, updating relations with iD can cause relations to become broken. relation/15867505 Center Street Marketplace for example is now missing members. Can you investigate and correct?

Aleksandar, fixing broken boundaries? The change broke relation/14011690.
Since you are using josm, you can select all the relations in the relation window, then right click and choose 'Download incomplete members'.
This will load all the relations fully. Then run the josm validator and see if your corrections broke any other relation. thx.

Stretch, park relation/15950598
broken. maybe simplify?

VLD272, can you relook at {Relation id=224848 version=3 VT [way/39941827, way/39941828]} MemberInfo{roles='outer', positions='1'}

relation is now broken. thx.

changed it to covered=yes, removed layer tags. changeset/136879620

fixed in changeset/136808689

also relation/206744

re_map, relation/206584, Vienna is now broken. Can you investigate?

covered=*

Nice additions, theman76... but fyi: The sidewalk accidently got an address. House at 617 missing street info.

RoadWarrier, was adjusting a spiked building and noticed that there were two houses with address number 9501 next door to each other, but with different road names (blooms farm way and spring hill farm way).
Looking at the nad, it has spring hill farm way, with numbers 9501, 9505, 9509, 9513, 9517, 9521.
You listed source as field survey, so can you reverify and adjust? thx.

fyi, Fairless hills Relation id=188050
seems to be broken now

adjusted a couple overlapping buildings found using josm validate

Dark,
I don't think the schilke lane section is signed 650 anymore. It's a dead end, residential.

fixed in changeset/134973871

WRobin, nice add, but is there a typo in the name? Semble vs Kemble?
Abbreviations can be confusing, so they should be spelled out. Mount vs Mt. see osm.wiki/Abbreviations