אולי אני מפספס משהו, אבל לא הוספתי כבר יחס לשבילים האלו?

מסומנים בהחלט

Hi Zeev,
I recently visited Amirim, GPS-recorded many of its trails and would like to add them to the map.
I'm wondering about the appropriate trail relation to use. In this changeset, you added a separate relationship to each of the trails (the blue and the yellow one). I would like to propose to use a single relationship, called "Amirim Trails" (Shvilei Amirim); with each member trail in it tagged with its own colour and possibly a name. I think this would simplify things, and match the situation on the ground more closely - as all of these trails are universally signed as part of the overall Amirim Trails (a typical sign says "Shvilei Amirim - X to Y"). What do you say?

Hi BMM,
I noticed you made some strange edits in this changeset. For example, you deleted the western end of Simtat Livne (way/24539732) (it most definitely connects to the road there), and you moved the water tower (node/266545822) away from its correct location in the middle of the roundabout. Can you clarify?

Hi Dov,
I noticed that you added a spring in the middle of Hod Hasharon's park, with useful information and description.
I think it will be better to move this info to the park polygon itself (way/586683882), both because of OSM's "one-feature-one-OSM-element" best practice, and because there is no actual spring located at that point.
What do you think?

Hi FuxDror,
I noticed you changed way way/240240094 from a "military area" into a "sidewalk".
If this was a mistake, could you please change it back? I believe it is misleading and potentially dangerous for map users.
If this was an intentional change (in the spirit of censorship?), I invite you to discuss your reasoning at the Israeli OSM forum (https://forum.openstreetmap.org/viewforum.php?id=33).
Thanks.

It seems that you changed the name of a convenience store from "Amnon Groceries" to "Mini Market" in this changeset (node/2324656797)
Can you explain why do you think this change was needed?
I was under the impression that name=* should reflect the given name and not the feature itself, which is described by shop=* or amenity=*, etc.

I don't think it was a tagging mistake. I distinctly remember the guide post on the ground. It is possible it was removed after I mapped it.

היי ירון,
שמתי לב שעשית מספר שינויים לאחרונה שבהם אתה משנה גרשיים לגרשיים תחתונות. אני לא בטוח שזה סטנדרטי ורצוי.
מציע לפתוח דיון על זה בפורום.

Hi Tamerdab,
I noticed you added some individual trees in Park HaYarkon. According to natural=tree , you should probably use species=* and not name=* for the "populus...", since the trees don't have an individual name.

Hi, are you sure this should be mapped? I visited the area today and it seems to be just a wheat field with no ruins in sight.

Hi,

I'm not sure it's a good idea to tag this whole area as "grass". If you've been there on the ground, you must have seen that it's mostly sand and bushes (which we usually tag as "meadow"). Also I'm not sure this whole area should be called Hadera river park; the park itself seems to be only in the north part of this area.
Please consider changing your edits.
Thank you.

Hi,
There is a way in this changeset (73554110) that I think is a mistake. It appears to be a copy of existing ways but is offset just a little bit left and down. Its west connection to the road doesn't match the situation on the ground (only one track connects to the paved road, not two).
I did note you apparently used GPS. Are you absolutely sure it's not a duplicate of existing ways?

Hi,

I noticed that this changeset copied name:en (Gishron Cliffs) to name:he and name (destroying the original hebrew name - צוקי גשרון).

I assume this was part of an automated process. Perhaps other nodes were affected as well.

Hi Mr_Israel,
Can you clarify what is the writing "Ad Nishmar" in the middle of Yavneel that you added here (Way: 268940818 etc)? Is it a real physical feature?

Hey,
You added a bunch of name=traffic_sign in this changeset. As it is, it has no meaning that I can see for the OSM map. Perhaps you meant traffic_sign=* ?

Hi WiktorN,
regarding the cycleway you added here (way/362379290)

1. Should it really be one-way?
2. Shouldn't it connect to all the roads and paths it crosses along the way? And the roundabout near its north end? There is no routing in its current state.

Thanks.

Hi zstadler,
Today I walked the "blue" track from Mihmoret to Givat Olga, which you created in this changeset. I did not see any blue markings on the ground, not once. Are you sure this track should really be "blue"?