OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
162283764 10 months ago

Probably the boundary=place relations using their own way members instead of reusing the ones from the administrative boundary.

158216555 about 1 year ago

admin_level=11 wordt niet meer gebruikt in Nederland.

Woonplaatsen (admin_level=10) zijn de kleinste administratieve eenheid.

De juiste tags voor plaatsen (wijken, buurten, dorpen, etc) die binnen een woonplaats van vallen zijn:

boundary=place
place=*

67018832 almost 2 years ago

Ik onderhou alleen de woonplaatsgrenzen en de gemeente/provincie grenzen die dezelfde boundary ways gebruiken.

100905652 over 2 years ago

The polygon was broken two years ago (the geometry was not a valid polygon).

No need to contact me about these changes, just update the data to reflect the current on the ground truth.

The areas project is no longer active, not is the website for it. For some background information, see:

https://github.com/osmlab/fixing-polygons-in-osm/issues/15

135474647 over 2 years ago

Grenscorrecties dienen eerst bij de relevante (lokale) overheden aangekaart te worden, daarna worden de grenzen in OSM bijgewerkt mbv de officiele geodata wanneer de wijzigingen daarin verwerkt zijn.

Dankzij Schengen is het deel van de kamping in Nederland overigens geen probleem.

135474647 over 2 years ago

De boundary way is al hersteld:

changeset/135478508

135474647 over 2 years ago

De grens is correct, het is daar een rechte lijn, zowel volgens Nederland als Belgie:

https://app.pdok.nl/viewer/#x=193890.15588053412&y=307563.68101496215&z=11.84&background=BRT-A%20standaard&layers=01d4dab6-03ad-4e82-b719-4daf8b96ea14;AU.AdministrativeBoundary
https://topomapviewer.ngi.be/?l=en&baselayer=crossborder.topo&x=760749.36&y=661896.69&zoom=10

47356122 over 2 years ago

The tags moved the relation the way was an outer member of: relation/110752

That's how proper multipolyons as structured, see: osm.wiki/Relation:multipolygon

100979525 about 3 years ago

Ideally get authoritative data from a national geo agency under a license that can be used in OSM and use that to correct the border.

100979525 about 3 years ago

Google maps is not a source that can be used in OpenStreetMap.

This changeset just fixed broken polygons, the accuracy of geometries is out of scope.

101586376 about 3 years ago

Then go and delete the building. This changeset fixes broken polygons as noted in the comment, whether or not the features actually exist is out of scope.

119512465 over 3 years ago

Should be fixed with the changes in:

changeset/119515523
changeset/119515586

119512465 over 3 years ago

This changeset triggered conflicts that couldn't be resolved easily, every resolution caused more conflicts.

The changeset couldn't be closed earlier.

117619025 almost 4 years ago

Woonplaats-, gemeente-, en provinciegrenzen zijn ten alle tijden relaties.

osm.wiki/Relation:boundary

Ook als het maar een member heeft.

Consistentie is een groot goed.

117619025 almost 4 years ago

Deleting boundary relations is not a fix!

117215221 almost 4 years ago

Adres node ligt de change in 117256190 weer in de verkeerde woonplaats.

115601367 almost 4 years ago

The start_date for BAG boundaries also contains the timestamp, you should not remove it.

114182497 about 4 years ago

Bedankt voor de building correctie, bij het downloaden van de adress node waren de gerelateerde ways niet mee gekomen.

111707765 about 4 years ago

"
Note that before May 2017, some multipolygons also had their tags on the outer way (if there was only one such way or all ways had the same tags) while keeping the respective multipolygon-relation untagged. But when consuming older OSM data excerpts, it is necessary to handle such old style multipolygons, too. See old style multipolygons for historic notes.
"
osm.wiki/Relation:multipolygon
osm.wiki/Old_style_multipolygons

The dataset from the areas project also includes relations with only type=multipolygon and no tags on the outer way.

http://area.jochentopf.com/

104263410 over 4 years ago

Thanks for your DWG work. The scope of my work on this building was limited to invalid geometries.