seav's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 191259081 | I already explained in my comment on your changeset: changeset/190634336 To repeat, the Robinsons Galleria complex is split between QC and Pasig, among other things. |
|
| 190634336 | Please do not edit "messy" boundaries without additional confirmation. By all indications, the QC–Pasig boundary does pass through the Robinsons Galleria complex. For example, Holiday Inn Galleria's address is in Pasig: https://www.ihg.com/holidayinn/hotels/us/en/pasig-city/mnlgl/hoteldetail And this was in Pasig based on the old boundary that you had modified. Now the hotel is wrongly inside QC’s boundary. |
|
| 189793548 | Is it possible that the district was first named Peñaplata per the original 1998 city charter of Samal (RA 8471), but has since reverted back to the name of its original Samal municipality? Based on Timmy's link, the city government does seem to refer to the district as Samal, and a few barangays' seals also refer to the district as Samal. This could be resolved by using alt_name and/or old_name (and maybe official_name) tags and leaving the main name tag with what residents actually use. |
|
| 178988596 | Hi! You added a Lawson in ATC, but this already duplicates an existing Lawson. I deleted the one you added. Please do check if there are existing POIs that you can just update instead of adding another one. |
|
| 189859280 | Oops. Forgot the #31DayOSMChallenge and #Maptober hashtags |
|
| 186916281 | Hi! May I know what is your source for these barangay boundaries you are adding? If I'm not mistaken, these are derived from the PSA dataset and these aren't allowed to be imported into OSM per PSA's direction. |
|
| 187260131 | Hi! I reverted your change to the Manila–Pasay border at CCP Complex. The border looks weird but it is actually correct. As documented in various places including in this 2005 Manila Times article, the border passes through Folk Arts Theater: "demarcation line cuts right through the Folk Arts Theatre". https://www.manilatimes.net/2005/04/26/business/columnists-business/stanley-ho-floats-back/691512 You can even verify for yourself by going to the shops at Harbour Square and see that they are registered with Manila and not Pasay. |
|
| 171004943 | Aside from these weird tags which have been imported without change from the source dataset, OSM doesn't actually have permission to use this dataset (originally from the Philippine Statistics Authority, then cleaned up via the Technical Working Group of the Office of Civil Defense, then distributed via UN OCHA) so these boundary additions may need to be reverted. |
|
| 170188872 | Wrong comment. It should be; fix amenity name |
|
| 169122360 | Hi! Can you also update the boundary relations? |
|
| 162171252 | Maybe a better tag for CMC is faculty=communication instead of amenity=college? The latter tag implies an independent educational institution, but UPD colleges are integral parts of the university. |
|
| 155051918 | Hi, why did you modify the QC–Pasig boundary here? The boundary actually cuts through Robinsons Galleria because the boundary predates the creation of the mall and its adjacent buildings. As evidence, Crowne Plaza's website states it is in QC, while Holiday Inn Galleria's website states it is in Pasig: https://www.ihg.com/crowneplaza/hotels/us/en/quezon-city/mnlcp/hoteldetail https://www.ihg.com/holidayinn/hotels/us/en/pasig-city/mnlgl/hoteldetail So the boundary as you have mapped it is incorrect because Holiday Inn was put inside QC instead of Pasig. |
|
| 148779918 | Hi! May I know why the polygon for Plaza de Roma was deleted in this changeset? |
|
| 148488873 | Hi! Is the Strava heatmap more accurate than the DATUM drone imagery? I see that you realigned a few buildings that are now misaligned to the drone imagery. |
|
| 136703888 | I apologize. I missed the news that the church had been declared a minor basilica in 2021. Sorry! |
|
| 136703888 | Hi! You mistagged the wrong Immaculate Concepcion church in Bulacan as a minor basilica. It is the church in Malolos that is the minor basilica (already tagged), not the one in Santa Maria. |
|
| 144035222 | Hi! May I know why you tagged the Quiapo Church grounds as a boundary=national_park? This tag is only used for actual natural parks usually enjoyed for outdoor activities and environmental preservation and not cultural/religious heritage. |
|
| 144173755 | Hi Alexis! Did you actually intend to mark the *whole* island as landuse=forest? This seems wrong to me because the beaches and the residential area to the south doesn't really fit a forest land use. |
|
| 88212948 | @Anim, can you provide an official source for the boundaries? I added the boundaries based on Caloocan City government's own maps (although the maps were from 2006). See here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1EygqEz_uLk3wsdDzxBcBrrH8aJTveyCV/view?usp=sharing |
|
| 129821199 | FYI: I deleted the whole relation for the Manila-Quezon Expressway and adjacent structures such as exits. I looked at the project and this seems to be in just the proposed stage and is far from being actually realized. So mapping the route as if the alignment is already fixed and the exits ramps are already planned is very premature. |