Hello ABDULLAH AL WERFALLI,
Thank you for your contribution to improving the road network on OpenStreetMap.
I noticed in this changeset:
changeset/170590862
That you changed some roads to “operational”. I tried to double-check if these roads were officially opened, but I couldn’t find any confirmation in the news. The only source I came across is this one:
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DNAsJhxS9TF/
which says the project is still in its final construction stage.
Maybe you have another source that confirms the opening? If so, it would be great if you could share it with us.
Also, I saw that you updated a few links:
way/1413587390
way/172855266
way/1413587388
way/1413587386
from trunk_link to primary_link. Just to mention, according to OSM guidelines, the link classification should usually match the higher road type it connects to. Here’s the reference for more details:
osm.wiki/Link_roads_between_different_highways_types
Best regards.
salma_z

Hi Cyrille37,
Thank you for your effort in improving OpenStreetMap, and I appreciate your work in enhancing the quality of the Ref in Morocco.
Regards salma_z,

Hello Agadir_edits;
Thank you for contributing to OpenStreetMap in Morocco,
I noticed you Deleted the streets.
Link for deleted streets:
https://osmlab.github.io/osm-deep-history/#/way/1291288634
https://osmlab.github.io/osm-deep-history/#/way/91052910
I saw the latest satellite image the date is ( 2025-01-01) these streets
are still there and working, And you made some roads "Floating".
Link for Floating streets :
way/1290907334
Could you provide us with the source you used to Delete these streets?
Regards
salma_z

Hello, mkarau ;
Thank you for your comment, and happy mapping!

Hello, mkarau ;
I thank you for adding these barriers that exist in reality to improve the OSM map and apologize if the changes I made upset you but it’s better to place just one barrier on the road, which will serve the route, rather than placing them far from the road, as they would be considered floating and wouldn’t affect the route in any way
For example,
node/12218156441
node/12218156429
And here is the wiki page that explains how to place barriers on the road.
barrier=*
Before we deleted the remaining floating barriers in this changeset
https://osmcha.org/changesets/157407525
we made sure to check the Mapillary tracks to confirm whether these barriers exist or not.
For example,
https://www.mapillary.com/app/?lat=24.523371815731977&lng=54.43358188460479&z=19.9&focus=photo&dateFrom=2017-01-01&pKey=2909420236004972&x=0.49282946688680535&y=0.4797415233108498&zoom=0
Also, some of the barriers you added are not barriers, but rather traffic signal poles
For example,
node/7710055157
node/7710055156
And this was also verified using the Mapillary track.
https://www.mapillary.com/app/?lat=24.523303900068996&lng=54.43357200000003&z=19.9&focus=photo&dateFrom=2017-01-01&pKey=334833254678863&x=0.49553902361084423&y=0.6384033843866203&zoom=0
Could you please fix these issues? based on the open street map policy.
Regards
salma_z

Hello Mintusha98,
Thank you for reaching out,
We removed these links:
https://osmlab.github.io/osm-deep-history/#/way/46964225
https://osmlab.github.io/osm-deep-history/#/way/76371264
according to the latest satellite images
Maxar SecureWatch Imagery 2024-07-26
Regards;
salma_z

Hello Mintusha98,
I see you added, two links in this changeset. changeset/154395183
Like:-
way/1303764931
way/1303700706
and there are two other links next to them It is about 3 meters away in the same directions
Like:-
way/76371264
way/46964225
which I think is illogical Please can you provide us the source for the links you added
Regards;

Appreciate the source that you provided and I fixed it now on this changeset: changeset/153741201
Regards
salma_z

Hello TDH;
you can use this website:
https://imgbb.com
And upload the photo on it,
Regards

Hello "TDH"
Thank you for the response.
if it is possible send a picture of the signboard,
As for (Rezq Street) this name is from special data for us, if you don't have an official source We can rely on your knowledge of the place
Regards;

Hello "TDH"
I noticed you reverted my edit and changed the street name from Rezq Street to Metro Street
Examples:
way/99885187
also changed this street from Rezq Street to 23 Street
Examples:
way/1282030319
Can you please provide with us the source that you used to change this street?
Regards;

Hello IngénieurS;
I noticed you added "the number=24" and this key didn't match the WIki OSM, Could you please Check it and fix it?
Regards
salma_z

Hello Ahmad-0772;
Thank you for reaching out to me, I operational the roundabout and used the latest satellite image and I mentioned it in the changeset source.
Link for roundabout:
way/1172708989
Regards

Hello NadaEmad;
Please be aware that you removed "highway=residential" and added "indoor=wall" and this tag you added is used for building only,
Also, you moved some nodes by mistake, which made some streets overlap.
Link for the street:
way/689096866
Link for node:
https://osmlab.github.io/osm-deep-history/#/node/6765933124
I fixed this issue in this changeset:
changeset/138933426
Regards
salma_z

Hello, Anjli_sharma;
Please pay attention when editing on OpenStreetMap I noticed you made overlapping streets.
Examples:
way/952350619
way/715735162
Also, you can check your edit before you upload by Validation
Here is a Wiki Link showing how to use the validator :
osm.wiki/JOSM/Validator#Validations
Also, we sent a comment from one month on your work and you made the same issue and we fixed it.
changeset/136590622
We fixed this issue now.
Regards

Thank you I added access to the gate.

Thank you for your response,
In my opinion in this case the gate should have "access=permissive" to mark the road as accessible for some specific types of traffic. if you agree I can add that.
Regards
salma_z

Hello LockOnGuy;
Thank you for noticing that, I deleted it by mistake and updated this street from a single line double way road to a double line single way road to connect that to Airport Highway and reverted the gate as it was.
I will be grateful for your help if you are aware of this location are these gates for public users or private?
Regards
salma_z

Hello Jeben;
I noticed you changed some street classifications from "trunk" to "motorway" and didn't change the link associated with it and overall in this area, the "trunk" will be more suitable as it was.
Could you revert your edit and make the classification as it was?
Examples of streets"
way/149813618
way/150240253
Regards
salma_z

Hello gomhory
could you please provide me the street name source?