@wwwindow
mein changset ist 10 Jehre her. Ich kannmich nicht erinnern dort gewesen zu sein. Ich nur den memorial tag gesetzt. Die Luftbilder sind jetzt wahrscheinlich noch besser. Wenn du die Position geprüft hast, kann das fixme auch raus.

Hallo EWERK VC,
in diesem Changeset ist einiges kaputt gegangen. Im Bereich "Am Vorwerk" und im "Grünen Bogen Paunsdorf" sind Wege und Straßen verschoben wurden. Ich würde das Changeset gerne rückgängig machen. Der Punkt EWERK Gruppe DDS C01 (640025739) würde erhalten bleiben. Was meinst du?

Grüße

Rob

Hallo Bryant Curto.
The deleted way is the "outline" of the building and of the used type=building multipolygon. type=building is used for 3D mapping in OSM. All regular informations should be tagged on the building way. I suggest to revert the changes.

greetings

Rob

I agree.Thanks for this great conversation. Happy mapping.

Some fire stations in Brooklyn are also tagged FDNY. We should unify the operator tag as well. FDNY or "New York Fire Department"? I prefere the second.

Hi jmapb,
thank you for the list.
I searched for existing amenity=fire_station in OSM database and tried to unify. I also added the details of existing nodes to buildings, if existing, I deleted spaces (_/_ --> /) and added "operator=New York City Fire Department". Maybe FDNY in name is not really necessary. I can delete it if we agree.

Don't know if I understand you correct. The building 666 Fifth Avenue is additionally tagged in 3D. It consists of five ways. The ways are grouped in a building relation. Maximum height an level information is in the highest building part. All tags are given according: osm.wiki/Simple_3D_buildings. You can see a sample rendering here: http://demo.f4map.com/#lat=40.7608648&lon=-73.9764972&zoom=18&camera.theta=33.541&camera.phi=3.151
I tagged hundreds of buildings in manhattan the same way in the last years. Please specify your objections.

I agree.
Best Regards,
robgeb

Multipolygon Type=building is not in common use and in special use for 3D mapping. To not mix 2D and 3D I want to revert this changeset. Additonally, the ESB is not shown on Standardmaps anymore.

changset reverted

reverted
-robgeb

@SomeoneElse - Looks OK again.Thank you very much.

Please stop adding old data.

Why you deleted the whole World Trade Center Site and created a status from 2001???

Wenn du das Wissen hast, trage es doch bitte auch ein. Unter osm.wiki/DE:Historical_Objects/Karteneigenschaften#Monument gibt es Vorschläge zum tagen historischer Objekte. Oder wenigstens eine kurze Beschreibung als note= oder osm.wiki/Tag:description=.

Ich räume grade die historischen Monumente in Deutschland auf. Um was handelt es sich bei diesen Knoten genau? Denkmäler, Grenzsteine, Bäume...?

I did a lot of changes in this area. Lots of informations are deleted now. If the creator of the changset will not respond, I will try to restore it.

There are only 10 ways, in a large area of course. Only deleted ways or nodes with redundant informations via Maproulette challenge. Will be more careful next time.