ralley's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 191669428 | Why did you change way/1043631564 from steps? That appears correct: https://www.mapillary.com/app/?lat=-36.91305727844087&lng=174.9074687178893&z=18.575360348671403&pKey=602237969404642&focus=photo&x=0.7894516985627483&y=0.5597321566057835&zoom=1.216520650813517 Also why did you change way xxx from a footway to a path, footway appears correct, see: https://www.mapillary.com/app/?lat=-36.91969611479999&lng=174.90134261000003&z=17&pKey=1381876466062865&x=0.3689643754965941&y=0.6872357219377963&zoom=0.47617536221023476&focus=photo |
|
| 191539451 | Please use descriptive changeset comments
|
|
| 191540173 | Of course, you should always be using all available sources. |
|
| 191540105 | Why did you downgrade the crossing? There are signals here, see Mapillary
|
|
| 191540173 | There is no crossing here, see Mapillary imagery |
|
| 186681162 | Wrongly changed name of The Breakfast Club cafe |
|
| 191486846 | ||
| 191491476 | Why did you down grade this from traffic signals to marked? The signals are visible in the LINZ aerial imagery and the use of lines as the markings indicate it is a signalised crossing |
|
| 190782250 | These appear to be driveways and not residential streets. What was the source for the name? Why is the way tagged layer=1, it does not appear to be above anything. The road way you added also connects to the street lamp which appears to be wrong, additionally you have a dangling end to the way past Ash Street
|
|
| 190373459 | The crossings you have added in this changeset have the following problems:
Also once again you did not use a descriptive changeset coimment |
|
| 190675479 | You have created two "Lewis Mortimer" POIs within a very small distance
|
|
| 190670665 | You have changed the name of node/6211947921 without changing the website or other contact details, are these still correct?
|
|
| 190672516 | Why did you change node/4706086955 from a traffic table? According to the LINZ Aerial Imagery (which you list as the source) it appears to be a table |
|
| 190342340 | All of your edits look to be an attempt to record locations of personal events. OSM is for recording public, verifiable geographic data. |
|
| 182097941 | Because there is literally no crossing here but the footpath links to the road. There is no loss of information but a correction. This was confirmed by a visit to the location on 29 July. I use various OSM routers for foot based routing a lot and the proliferation of non existant crossings makes for exceedingly misleading directions |
|
| 189034516 | Please note that OSM is an international project, I doubt shop=dairy has the meaning you intended, see osm.wiki/Tag:shop%3Ddairy
|
|
| 189085290 | You have changed the tags of a footpath and land use area which is not correct. Was this a mistake or a bad case of SEO spam vandalism?
|
|
| 184893729 | This changeset has created a series of POIs with names "Level 1 - *". Is this the actual name as on the ground or an attempt to indicate the POI is on level 1? If the later "Level 1 - " should be removed form the name and level=1 tagged instead. See osm.wiki/Key:level |
|
| 187909528 | What is your source for this? To the best of my knowledge flock does not operate in NZ
|
|
| 186958834 | Review as requested: Looks good apart from a couple of minor issues:
|