Changeset When Comment
187751366

Hi Mauls, could you please make sure not to attach the roads going under bridges to the bridge area. Thanks

190366230

Thanks!

190366230

Hi RyanBush, thanks for adding to the Shropshire area!

Can the bus station name tags be reverted to "Shrewsbury Bus Station" as I feel the NaPTAN import of just "Bus Station" is not very appropriate here?

example node/3120433625

186206390

Hi EJVibes, thanks for adding to the Shropshire area.

Just to let you know that I've replaced the service roads with bus parking spaces as highways should not be used when there is no physical separation changeset/190405754

176195557

I've noticed you've split a few buildings up that, as far as I can tell, aren't separate buildings. A building having multiple addresses is pretty common, especially in urban environments.

Wouldn't adding the tag to an address node or building:part be more appropriate? Thanks

175634083

Hi JackW25, thanks for the contributions in Telford!
Just a friendly FYI that when there is no physical separation its good practice to use the lane and turn:lane tags instead of mapping lanes as separate ways. I've updated these junctions to show this - you can read more about this here osm.wiki/Key:turn

Cheers

167726421

hi, I think the tag you were looking for is highway=corridor instead of highway=footway - I have made this change

Cheers

168989612

Hello, thanks for adding more details to this area!

Just a friendly note that we shouldn't use name tags to describe features that don't have names. I've removed some of the name="Tunnel" tags for the underpasses on the cart paths. See here for more examples:
osm.wiki/Key:name#When_not_to_use

Thanks :)

181947488

I agree they can over complicate things. I'll keep this in mind in the future.

Thanks for the nudge and doing the work!

153089126

Hi, do you have a source for the field names used here? A few of them don't seem to line up with the modern land parcels so I'm not sure how valid they are. Thanks

166914374

Hi, a fair question.

The details for Woodlands Outdoor Education Centre were duplicated on both the main building and the surrounding area. I removed the details from the building to keep to the "One feature, one OSM element" rule.

I can see you've re-added the address with the names for the individual buildings, which is a nice addition.

way/606025138
way/1129397943
osm.wiki/One_feature,_one_OSM_element

Thanks

187781081

Hello, the penny toll for pedestrians isn't gated so this change isn't a good fit. It's a box with a coin slot on the top. It's there mostly due to the bylaw and not policed.

I'm open to suggestions to other tags as I can see that toll_booth isn't a perfect fit

102285003

I've created a relation to try and group them. relation/20775577/
I think some work could be done to tidy this up and make it clearer where a feature belongs to more than one protected area e.g. Bulls Cross.

176723381

never mind, just found this :) https://www.linkedin.com/posts/shrewsbury-high-school-gdst_girlsschool-shrewsbury-shropshire-activity-7196925751252656128-ALGG/

176723381

Hi, thanks for your edit. Has the High School taken on the old Severnside greens?

177499078

hi there, thanks for trying to tidy up the paths around Machynlleth!

I've merged the way here as its duplicated with the track which has the relevant PRoW tags on it already. way/1468995135

In general OSM tries to map what is on the ground so its preferable if a PRoW deviates a bit from the official designated line set by the council or maps. If it deviates a lot then this can be reflected in the tags.

Another thing to note is that just because something is designated as a public footpath it doesn't necessarily mean that cycling or equestrian is not allowed, its up to whoever owns the land. Natural Resources Wales often permit cycle tracks etc in their woods.

Cheers

166915285

Thanks for the replies!

On reflection its mainly the addition of the postfixes that are giving me "this dataset should not be the name tag" vibes, especially with the "Pole Transformers" everywhere.

Looking at the "Open Infrastructure Map" project I'm getting the sense this is a case of mapping for render.

I appreciate could do with wider discussion so I'll hold fire changing the names already mapped.

166915285

Another thing I've noticed is that "Substation" or "Transformer" is prepended to most (all?) of the the nodes you've added - is this from the NG data source?

I have verified that some substations don't have this as part of their name
e.g. node/9974532958 is labelled as "Shelton Flds." [Sic] Adding "Substation" here would be descriptive and redundant thanks to the tags.

Sorry to be a bore, to be clear I generally think this information is useful, I'm just a bit cautious about imported datasets.

166915285

I had a look at a couple of pole transformers on my walk today and couldn't see anything visible on the grey box apart from a ref on the pole.

From the wiki:
"Do not use name=* if:
The feature is unnamed in the real world"

If its hit and miss perhaps "ref_name" would be more appropriate for the pole transformers?

166915285

Hi, could you please explain why?

My understanding is that these are descriptions given by National Grid and rarely (if ever) used in the real world. official_name gives this context.