OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
179101671

Hallo und willkommen bei OSM.
bitte wirf einen Blick ins Wiki, wie Tiergehege üblicherweise getagged werden - oder vergleiche auch mit anderen Zoos.
osm.wiki/DE:Tag:tourism%3Dzoo

Generell müssen Dinge wie "Fläche" und "Umfang" nicht getaggt werden - das ergibt sich ganz einfach aus dem Objekt selbst.

178758499

Hi,
"horse:boarding" is a new tag. We do have amenity=animal_boarding
Could you check if this is applicable here?

179103285

Hi,
please check the fuel tags. It should be 'propane', not 'propame'.

179106345

Please don't just dump data from other sources into OSM!
If you want to import data, please read and follow our import guidelines:
osm.wiki/Import/Guidelines

179069933

Hi,
"name:zh_zhuyin" doesn't exist. The proper tag is "name:zh-Bopo" - which already exists on the objects you edited.

178650767

If it's not clear what the meaning of "sharp_disposal" is, then I say it shouldn't be imported into OSM at all.

178929802

Hi,
some just have a "area=yes", but not a building tag.
You can add some descriptions, but better use a common tag. Either "note", if it is information for mappers, or "description" if it might also be useful for others.
Some of the comments look like a bit too subjective to be of real use in OSM, but the real facts can for sure be there - and also deserve the proper tags like roof:material or building:colour.

178929802

Hi,
could you check the objects you uploaded? Some look like your field notes, but not like properly tagged objects in OSM, e.g.
way/1482125168

178989522

Hi,
you added the tag "canoe:oneway" - the common version would be "oneway:canoe", like on any street: The type of vehicle is usually added as a subkey.

178650767

Hi,
what is a "toilets:sharp_disposal"? This tag isn't used in any place

178932642

Hi,
could you check these golf areas? Some of them have strange tags like "name_Org2" or strange names.

Thanks!

178647904

Hi,
could you explain the meaning of 'hazmat:distance'? This tag isn't used in other places.

178499524

Hi,
"crossing:markings:colour:bicycle" is not used in other places.

What is in use on other "mixed" crossings are these tags:
cycleway:crossing:markings:colour
footway:crossing:markings:colour

Could you check that?

178785613

Please stop this import, provide a proper documentation as required by our import guidelines.

The geometries of many of these objects don't make sense and don't correspond to anything that can be seen in aerial images, e.g. here:
changeset/178785613#map=19/-6.915442/110.698092&layers=N

I guess all these imports should be reverted.

178769666

Hi,
please don't just dump data from some external sources into OSM. Any import has to follow our import guidelines:
osm.wiki/Import/Guidelines

I'm going to revert this for now so that you can start over with a clean import after clarifying all details such as tagging, sources and licenses.

178770977

Hi,
please don't add names to roads that don't have names in these languages. E.g. this road for sure doesn't have a name in Latin, Middle English, in a peculiar script used in Utah or some Jamaican language.

Also, please don't use link shorteners, but always add the direct link to images.

178384714

Hi,
could you explain what "lobby hours" and "ibanker hours" are?

178401497

Hi,
is this really "cql_location" and not "cqc_location"?

node/13542983926#map=19/50.714775/-3.544917&layers=N

178348172

Hi,
"diet:muslim-friendly" is not a common tag - what exactly does it mean? Does the cafe offer halal food?

178636477

Hi,
could you point us to the mandatory documentation of this import?
osm.wiki/Import/Guidelines

You also added ways with a huge amount of foreign tags which clearly shouldn't be in OSM.