Changeset When Comment
187378660

Hi, thanks for your contribution! This is helpful, but in the future could you please not put descriptions of objects in their name or operator fields? If OrganicMaps doesn't have a good way to express the information you're trying to add, there's a "Note to OpenStreetMap volunteers" box at the bottom of the form, please use that. Thanks again!
---
#REVIEWED_BAD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/187378660

186613904

Regarding the change made to node/13011584769, Memorial Day is not May 25 every year, nor is Labor Day always September 7. I updated it to "May Mo[-1] -2 days-Sep Mo[1]". (-2 days because the business's website actually says it opens "Memorial day weekend" not "Memorial day".) If there are any other places you recall making a similar mistake it would be good to correct those too, it's hard for me to check.

178362135

Hi, could you clarify what that Menards next to the airport hangar is for? If that really exists it could use a `description=*` or `note=*` tag with some further explanation, otherwise it just looks like a mapping mistake... I left a note note/5425341

185664580

Note I chose to interpret "Memorial day weekend" as including that Monday. Also not 100% on whether other holidays before the 2nd weekend of June should be included but since it says weekends I'm assuming yes.

185069367

I believe Alshowaiey is saying that when possible you should avoid making changes in multiple countries/continents at once. (E.g. As a made-up example, if you want to change something in India and something in Mexico, you would make the change in India, save it, then make a change in Mexico, and save that.) Otherwise if you make both those changes at once, when people look in the change history they see a giant box spanning half the globe instead of two tiny boxes in Mexico and India.

125451866

I'd feel kind of awkward uploading pictures of a random swing set in a small town to the Wikimedia commons but yeah it does seem like they're okay with it. Not nearly as convenient as what StreetComplete offers but maybe I'll give it a shot...

125451866

Thanks, that's pretty unfortunate, but understandable why they wouldn't want to host thousands of images for free on a permanent basis.

Still, I kind of wish there were a better place to host photos of features. Google Maps makes it so easy to contribute photos of places, and they're often really useful information.

138305639

Thanks, I'll fix the spelling.

The relations though I'm not sure about. How else should I represent that these holes all belong to the same course? I don't think an area makes sense since this course doesn't really have defined boundaries, it's just part of the park. See also osm.wiki/Disc_golf#The_use_of_a_relation