Changeset When Comment
190045186

splendid!

190045186

Hi, thanks for adding these details... wonder about deleting the height tag from the building way, was that intentional?

191658745

Hi abstractmach, thanks for all your survey work!

Just a point about "terrace" as a building type -- that tag is supposed to be used when a whole row of attached houses is mapped as a single building way. Unfortunately the StreetComplete interface doesn't make this very clear!

The individual buildings you've tagged as building=terrace should probably be building=house (if they're single-family dwellings) or building=apartments (if they contain apartments) ... and building=residential is a good fallback when it's unclear.

Thanks, jmapb

185500696

Hi ElijahKensler, welcome to OSM! I noticed you added some private access tags in this changeset, what's the source for that info? Thanks, jmapb

191516877

reverted in changeset/191519558

191518302

Reverted in changeset/191519302

191298588

I don't remember a vote? I know it's election day, but this isn't an election. Either you have a verifiable source for your data -- so decisive that it overrides a thorough 2-day-old ground survey -- or you don't.

191298588

Indeed I've walked it all. And those parts of the Long Path a mile north or south of Piermont are on land with different owners. Their restrictions don't carry over to other parts of the route.

191298588

There is, in fact no signage -- confirmed by survey on 10/29.

191298588

Piermont mayor: "Bikes do use it, but he’s not sure they are officially allowed."
Piermont highway superintendent: "They could probably walk the bikes up the hill."

"Not sure if allowed" does not mean "likely not allowed." This sounds like textbook permissive access to me. I'm not suggesting bicycle=permissive be tagged, but there's no evidence from the village that bicycle=no is warranted.

And I'm still unclear as to what you're citing as your data source for these restriction tags. Can you clarify?

Also, if you're in contact with Andy about this, maybe see what he has to say about the Trail Conference publishing a non-copyrighted list of Long Path sections. There was some controversy about your changing the Long Path to a superrelation in changeset/184016299, in particular @quincylvania doubted that the sources of section info you're using are compatible with OSM's license.

191298588

One thing Andy Garrison, @matthewfecica and I agree on: Evidence of bicycle use does not mean bicycles are legally permitted. I certainly wouldn't consider this a valid data source for removing a *verifiable* bicycle=no restriction.

I'm not surprised to hear that Andy (aka Mr Long Path, he's basically in charge) sees usage restrictions on the Long Path as I do: There are no top-down regulations imposed by the Trail Conference. The route's many various roads/trails follow whatever restrictions are imposed by the local land owners and managers, some public and some private.

According to Kevin's discussion with the village clerk, the local government (who's also the landowner) has a permissive attitude towards bikes here, but defers to the Trail Conference on the matter. The Trail Conference imposes no restrictions of its own, but instead follows the landowner's regulations. There are no signed restrictions on the path, or nearby. Access restrictions are not implied by being in the route relation, as we've discussed elsewhere.

@matthewfecica, since there is no source given for these tags, and none that could be discovered, would you please remove them?

191390325

Thanks for taking care of these... I reported this account to the Data Working Group for vandalism last week but they chose not to block. If you haven't reported them yet, that might help.

191298588

If such signs appear, please let me know! Meanwhile, you understand that it's correct by OSM standards to remove these access restriction tags from the way, right?

191298588

Also... mostly irrelevant but slightly amusing, I was nearly hit by a southbound mountain bike while on this path on the 29th. That certainly doesn't mean this particular cyclist was operating legally of course ;)

I wonder what he did when he got to the stairs at the bottom? I didn't check. Reminds me of a gang of cyclists I had to keep dodging on the West Highland Way in Scotland. They all ended up in a pile at the bottom of a slippery slope. (They were fine.)

Anyway, at least I didn't get trampled to death by a horse. But surveying for OSM would be a satisfying way to perish. Just let me hit the upload button before it all goes dark!

191298588

I'm glad you like the staircase I added ;) It doesn't constitute a legal access restriction for the path it connects to, though. Access tags aren't for describing the character of a way; they're for verifiable legal restrictions.

You're thinking about verifiability backwards: the "signage, official documentation, or other verifiable evidence" is a standard we use when *adding* tags. If no such evidence is available, the tags should not be added. It's not reasonable to expect someone to prove that something isn't regulated. That's the default assumption, and membership in a hiking route relation doesn't change that.

Nonetheless, giving the benefit of the doubt, I traveled to this path and took time searching for *any* sign that biking and horseback riding are restricted -- by the state, the county, the town, the village or the NYNJTC. There are plenty of signs around, but not those. Without a verifiable data source, the bicycle=no and horse=no tags don't belong in OSM.

191298588

There was no such consensus. The changes I made in changeset/191298331 were from a fresh survey on October 29th. There's absolutely no evidence of these restrictions on the ground -- I have pictures if you want to see them.

In the meantime, please don't engage in edit warring. If you have issues or questions regarding one of my changesets, it's courteous to leave a changeset comment (as I did on changeset/190762514) rather than simply reverting without discussion.

190425583

Hi ashley9405, I see you've been changing tags on several objects to indicate certain things are in Nassau County instead of Queens, though the area you're working in is entirely in Queens County. Can you explain these changes?

Thanks, jmapb

191246375

Hi onethreethreeone,

The correct housenumber for this building is 54-15. 54-17 is one building to the south,
way/280276202

I've fixed the addresses on these two buildings. Meanwhile I also see you've been changing tags on several objects to indicate certain things are in Nassau County instead of Queens, though the area you're working in is entirely in Queens County. Can you explain these changes?

Thanks, jmapb

190762514

πŸŽƒ Happy Halloween mappers! I have surveyed & retagged way/56453952... just in time for the headless horseman and the psycho cyclist to haunt the path (at least until they reach the top of the stairway.)

This comment thread is already overflowing with tricks and treats so please head over to changeset/191298331 if you want to say booooooo! πŸ‘»

191037311

Thanks, missed that one -- reverted