impiaaa's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 187822661 | I don't know what you mean by "problems for the database." As long as you ensure consistent tagging, applied objects can be found easily with a query tool such as Overpass (osm.wiki/Overpass_API ). Although, if your goal is to make a web map, you may want to consider a tool such as uMap (osm.wiki/UMap ) that keeps data in a separate overlay, so that your display needs won't have the chance to conflict with OSM tagging requirements. |
|
| 187822661 | Hello, please read: osm.wiki/Relations_are_not_categories - Collecting these trees into a relation is an inappropriate use of a relation. Consider using an established tag, like operator= or osm.wiki/Tag:network=, or documenting the collection on a separate website. |
|
| 187840155 | A name on a map by the city don't justify breaking OSM naming conventions. We do the same with streets, anyway--the "official" name of those are always abbreviated, but we expand the abbreviations anyway. |
|
| 187701329 | Welcome to OpenStreetMap, and thanks for contributing! Please use the changeset description to describe what you changed and why; for example, "Added a fence around a house by tracing from aerial imagery." See more examples here: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments |
|
| 187565224 | Welcome to OpenStreetMap, and thanks for contributing! A few points of feedback:
|
|
| 187606370 | Welcome to OpenStreetMap and thanks for contributing! When you're drawing buildings, you can use the "Square" operation (shortcut "Q") to make sure a building is perfectly square. It would also be helpful to use the changeset description to describe exactly what you changed - for example, "Added an address to a house and traced an outbuilding" |
|
| 187371481 | Welcome to OpenStreetMap, and thanks for contributing! Please use the changeset description to describe what you changed and why. For example, "Added sidewalks around a parking garage, from aerial imagery." You can find more examples here: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments |
|
| 187379663 | Welcome to OpenStreetMap, and thanks for contributing! Please use the changeset description to describe what you changed and why. For example, "Tagged pedestrian crossing nodes as having signals, known from local knowledge." You can find more examples here: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments |
|
| 161991185 | I might recommend asking in the community forum for tagging opinions. If they are navigable, something under highway= would be appropriate. highway=track and highway=service are sometimes used for land access roads. amenity=bench is certainly not right, even if the OSM tag is a similar word to what you call it. |
|
| 161991185 | Hello, this changeset includes many linear ways tagged with "amenity=bench". What do these lines represent? Benches are normally small enough to be plotted with a point only. These look more like paths, but they don't connect to anything and don't appear obvious in aerial imagery. |
|
| 187210070 | Welcome to OpenStreetmap and thanks for contributing! I'd appreciate it if you wrote more detail into changeset comments, describing what you changed and why. For example, "Added house addresses from local knowledge, and improve geometry using aerial imagery" Read more here: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments |
|
| 187209987 | Welcome to OpenStreetmap and thanks for contributing! Please note that OSM is a public map used by many apps and websites. As such, we shouldn't map private information, such as the names of the inhabitants of a house. Read more here: osm.wiki/Mapping_private_information |
|
| 186942344 | Note that mapping a business as a separate point from the building is a valid way to map it. Combining them is fine too but separating them is helpful in cases like when the building itself has a name, or the building houses multiple businesses, or just as a way to make sure the address stays. |
|
| 186901779 | Welcome to OpenStreetMap, and thanks for contributing! Street names and addresses in OSM should always use their full, un-abbreviated form, see osm.wiki/Abbreviations |
|
| 186658896 | Welcome to OpenStreetMap, and thanks for contributing! Please note that OSM highway classification is not always the same as California or US federal road classification, so they shouldn't be used as a primary source. See here: osm.wiki/United_States/2021_Highway_Classification_Guidance Also, while I believe copying data from Caltrans is fine since it's a government entity of California, which makes their data public domain, generally copying from copyrighted sources into OSM is illegal. See osm.wiki/Copyright#Proprietary_data |
|
| 186372191 | Hello! Please use the changeset description to describe what you changed and why. For example, "Added a crossing and fixed crossing:markings using aerial imagery." You can find more examples here: osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments Thank you! |
|
| 184628282 | Ah, sorry for not getting back to you sooner. I see you figured it out already, thanks for fixing it! |
|
| 185173969 | Discussion here: https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/deprecate-the-use-of-stars-tag-for-hotels-in-us/106799 |
|
| 184929707 | Please do not use them at all! |
|
| 184929707 | Welcome to OpenStreetMap! OpenStreetMap documents only verifiable facts about the real world. Please do not use gemini or ChatGPT to guess the heights of buildings! 欢迎来到OpenStreetMap! OpenStreetMap 仅记录有关现实世界的可验证事实。请勿使用 gemini 或 ChatGPT 来猜测建筑物的高度! |