Yes, you're right. Unfortunately, access tagging on gate nodes in OSM is often incomplete. Not necessarily in this particular case, but in general it frequently fails to capture exemptions for pedestrians and cyclists. Because of that, we're constantly struggling with how to make use of gate access tags when they are mapped correctly, while avoiding incorrect routing where the tagging is incomplete or misleading.

To be honest, my edit at this location was more an act of desperation than a particularly smart solution. 🙂 It's not something we would normally do, and we're still looking for a better way to handle these situations.

Ciao,
hai ragione: la duplicazione dell'ultimo tratto nella relazione era un mio errore. L'ho appena corretta e ho rimosso il segmento duplicato.
Per quanto riguarda l'esistenza del percorso, la segnalazione proveniva da un utente della nostra mappa, che aveva allegato una fotografia della traccia. Nella foto si vedevano delle catene e una marcatura rossa su una roccia, per cui ho ritenuto plausibile che il sentiero esistesse e l'ho inserito almeno in questa forma.
Probabilmente sono stato troppo fiducioso. Secondo te sarebbe meglio rimuovere del tutto la relazione finché non ci saranno verifiche sul posto o ulteriori elementi a supporto?
Grazie per il controllo.
Jan

Look at: osm.wiki/w/index.php?title=Pl:Key:addr:*&uselang=pl#Adresy

> addr:street - Nazwa ulicy highway=* lub placu place=square do której przypisany jest obiekt.

I think it's ok.

Look at: osm.wiki/w/index.php?title=Pl:Key:addr:*&uselang=pl#Adresy

> addr:street - Nazwa ulicy highway=* lub placu place=square do której przypisany jest obiekt.

I think it's ok.

Look at: osm.wiki/w/index.php?title=Pl:Key:addr:*&uselang=pl#Adresy

> addr:street - Nazwa ulicy highway=* lub placu place=square do której przypisany jest obiekt.

I think it's ok.

There is not highway with name=Plac Sławika i Antalla , but there is place=square with this name
way/589006526

And addr:street should be used for place=square as well. See osm.wiki/Pl:Key:addr:*
> addr:street - Nazwa ulicy highway=* lub placu place=square do której przypisany jest obiekt.
> addr:place - Część adresu, który nie jest związany z ulicą, ale z pewnym obszarem terytorialnym, obiektem liniowym, węzłem lub jakimś abstrakcyjnym obiektem.

There is not highway with name=Plac Wojciecha Kilara , but there is place=square with this name
way/286055032

And addr:street should be used for place=square as well. See osm.wiki/Pl:Key:addr:*
> addr:street - Nazwa ulicy highway=* lub placu place=square do której przypisany jest obiekt.
> addr:place - Część adresu, który nie jest związany z ulicą, ale z pewnym obszarem terytorialnym, obiektem liniowym, węzłem lub jakimś abstrakcyjnym obiektem.

@Penegal This relation relation/17178561 is unclosed now. Are you able to fix it?

Hi. I think that if there is some tactile_model information=tactile_model in Musei Civici di Monza it should be mapped as node at the correct position.
Your combination of tourism=museum and information=tactile_model is confusing.
Have a nice day!

Dzień dobry.
Na mapy.cz používáme OSM jako źródło danych do map poza Czechami.
Użytkownik napisał nam o tym obiekcie node/11428745242 , który stworzyłeś na OSM: "Nie ma żadnych widocznych śladów". Jeśli to prawda, uważam, że obiekt nie powinien być mapowany na OSM.
Miłego dnia,
Jan Fukátko

Už si po 4 letech moc nepamatuju. Ale z historie je vidět, že ty tagy už na OSM existovaly u node od jiného usera a jen jsem je přenesl k budově.

I think that most of the objects you created in this changeset are duplicates od existing objects. Not a very trustworthy edit...

Hi.
Ok. Feel free to rename it to BOTSCHAFT DER REGENWÄLDER again. I was there but
I can't remember after months. Thanks! Jan

Hello. You changed the name of this place node/8754913188/history from 凤河营村 to 3 before 5 months. I guess it was unintentional mistake. Could you correct it?

Hello. You changed the name of this place node/8754958495/history from 伍各庄村 to 33 before 10 months. I guess it was unintentional mistake. Could you correct it?

Nejsem si jistý, zda name odmazávat. Může to být název i pro cestu v tunelu i pro tunel samotný.