extraordinarymachine's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 189069959 | Hi, the map you linked as your source appears to be under copyright. Apologies if this was discussed elsewhere, but did you get permission to use it for OSM? |
|
| 182854927 | Moving this discussion to comments so local mappers can weigh in if they want. As explained in DMs, I don't think a temporary farmers market stall is a consistent enough presence to add to the map. The market's online directory is a better source for vendor information as it's so changeable. This isn't the business's usual location anyway, and the address added here isn't their address. I think the proper course of action is to delete this node. You'll notice that none of the other farmers market shops have been placed along the street here either. We could possibly consider them a street vendor if you learn that their location and schedule are consistent every week (see street_vendor=yes), but I would again look at the fact that none of the other shops have been added that way, so that doesn't seem consistent with local mapping conventions. We only outline the area where the market gets set up. The vast majority of the time, those areas are functional streets or parks, and it wouldn't make sense to add shops all over them, especially if their presence and location are subject to change from week to week. |
|
| 182854927 | Hi, what was your secondary source that a shop exists at this location? I see that you listed Square and a link that is also sourcing Square, which says that you should be confirming with another source before adding it to the map. |
|
| 188337543 | Thanks for clarifying. That's an interesting building. Since it's technically one structure, I've gone ahead and redrawn the outline from the aerial imagery. Generally with retail tenants, we're just adding or modifying a node for the business. Since the nodes are tagged with the shop names and addresses, it's ok if they're placed within the same building. It might take a while to update in various places, but the shops will soon show up on the map with the info you added. Thanks for contributing. |
|
| 188337543 | Hi, thanks for adding those businesses. It looks like you also deleted the old building and added two new ones. Was that area renovated recently? |