OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
182043350

Я по новостям свести не смог. Там вроде два заведения, но что какое не понял. Поэтому просто открыл заготовку

181926564

Добрый день. Ваша правка была откатана. Пожалуйста, не вешайте топонимы на landuse'ы

changeset/182006127

181616082

Good afternoon
Crystal is an licensed bank under Central Bank of Georgia, that's why amenity=bank. Your changes will be partially reverted

181464218

Добрый день
Так разве это не погодная станция по итогу?

162541529

I don't know how and why Every Door made it (it technically doesnt work with these type of features), but I extracted street light into the node

180858248

Reasonable

You can also leave a comment for resurveying. It will be easier to find it because the changeset will be drowned among other ones

180858248

Hello
node/13705971951
If it's the text on the board, it's better to use the inscription tag, not description

180765924

> Protected territory laws don't allow wandering off marked trails
> High possibility of unprepared tourists trying to storm the hill injuring themselves
We all have the head on our shoulders not only for eating; it's not the reason to remove data. For difficulties of routes, we have tags

> There are talks of renovating the infra and building a proper trail up
We don't have enough mappers to follow all possible events, and then without evidence - not the reason to remove, construction prefered

> admin would prefer to keep this path off the public map
Well, let's let them prefer anything they want. But if it has a place in reality, we shouldn't remove objects

179366753

Конечно, решение по дательному падежу принималось людьми, не пытавшимся ранее склонять иностранные имена в русском :)

178939518

Добрый день
Какого рода заведение вы хотели добавить?

178814484

Добрый день
Когда обрисовываете дома, отжимайте клавишу Q, чтобы редактор выправлял углы здания под прямым углом
И старайтесь в name не указывать описательные имена (только если это не буквальное имя объекта)

174992803

Ouch. I wanted to substitute amenity=school with landuse and missed the value, sorry. Moved on relation above fence (relation/20170945)

177789158

Hello sosomindiashvili,
Please, don't use a "name" tag in this case; it's better to use "ref"

177641567

Hello J4kee,
Don't torture yourself. I'll update the template later and make updates for the whole country

177661239

Можно ультануть, собрать абсолютный справочник сетевых точек через скрепинг с сайтов и потом проверить через аудитор. Но это будет театр одного вахтера, сомневаюсь, что кто-то подключится к инициативе

177661239

Они далеко не все точки сохранили. Ну и, увы, маперы не сильно заворачиваются на проверку disused объектов, создают новые. Поэтому и решил прибить больную скотину

177477049

We have a position about naming: "<not to use in name tag if> The feature is known by a generic term or description such as "toilet" or "basketball court". Use a feature tag to indicate the type in a language-neutral, machine-readable way. You can also use description=* or note=* if other tags do not quite express what distinguishes the feature from others of the same type." (name=*#When_not_to_use)
iD even can say about it (but not with Georgian names). But in general, shop=beauty === სილამაზის სალონი, and we prefer the shop tag first. მარკეტი, მაღაზია - the same point.

177472558

> Here’s another thought: the English name could just be Koniaki, while Koniaki Settlement and Koniakis Dasakhleba added as alternative names

Reasonable. And following this idea, it's better to review all "settlements" in Tbilisi. And crosslinks too. If this toponym is widespread, we should check it separately.
With "settlements" outside the city, you're opening a black hole (~50 places) in all of Georgia.

177472558

Understandable. But it's a bit tricky logic. Why shouldn't we translate Koniaki in this case? ;)

All this question about:
1) full translation,
or 2) partial,
or 3) none, transcription only

I can't follow all the changes that happen (especially with current problems of the German Overpass server), but I try to be more or less consistent in my own (I use the third option usually). The third one, because, well, I can't remember the existence of official translations and in an attempt to make a foreigner's life easier in case of searching the district (by eliminating "settlement" and using the original word).

What's your opinion after this bed sheet of text?

177472558

Otherwise, I plan to revert this changeset and this one (changeset/177474249)