dudone's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 188194206 | You have a better opinion of the wiki than I do. I shall continue to map as I do for better or worse. Regards Dudley |
|
| 188194206 | The documentation has moved on quite a bit from when I last looked at it. There was no mention of using ways back in the day. I tend to stick to the original general principle of "one feature, one osm element". With a node on the way with barrier=gate you are breaking this principle. The issue is really is one for those producing routers to resolve if you stick to the original OSM principle which is fairly sound to me. Wiki changes are often made with the involvement of very few people. Often changes like this can go totally un-noticed with no real consideration of whether is should be in the wiki or not. It may change in the future given it breaks the general OSM principle!! If you want to put the node, back feel free but it will be a problem for anyone producing a map as they will have to deal with two gates. Personally I would keep to the general principle and let those producing routers sort this out!! Dudley
|
|
| 177114058 | History and mapping style I guess. I tend to use path where I'm not sure what the access is or it is multi access. i.e. bicycle use. The wiki on footway and path has moved on a lot from when I started mapping but. Path didn't exist at this time. There are however still UK exceptions and their use is not very clear cut in practice, as the wiki points out. If you want to change it to footway, I would suggest adding access tags for bicycles etc if relevant. Dudley |
|
| 180649192 | Many thanks for spotting this error. It should now be fixed.
|
|
| 166691136 | Many thanks for spotting this error. JOSM auto fill gets the better of me sometimes. Should not be fixed. |
|
| 82527120 | Hi John. Good to see you yesterday. There is a node on this public footpath with a highway=bridleway tag. It seems unlikely given there are stile as each end. Is this a mistake? Dudley |
|
| 143909688 | Hi Jerry I've changed it to residential. Regards Dudley |
|
| 133103215 | Hi. Many thanks for pointing this out. I have changed to "gate". Dudley |
|
| 148833850 | Hi Andy
|
|
| 141434642 | Yes. I have added the tag.
|
|
| 114000922 | Deleted this tag. It was probably for the car park to the north but not sure what happened. I now try and put on "default" if there is not height barrier now. It should help with eventually searching to see which car parks have been tagged/surveyed for height barriers.
|
|
| 132982889 | Hi Many thanks for spotting this. Must have had this still selected when tagging another building. Now fixed.
|
|
| 133374717 | Apologies. No idea how I managed to delete this. Also, no idea how I would have put it back. Many Thanks Dudley |
|
| 128305068 | Hi Yes it wasn't intended. I'd put a number of nodes in for trees and then used a JOSM search for nodes without tags and not part of a way. I don't know why these were selected. Presumably a note tag isn't considered to be a tag. If they look like a mine entrance then surely it would be an idea to add historic=mine to these.
|
|
| 117958478 | Sorry. Can you tell me what I'm looking for as I have been using the JOSM search to find the stile=?? having downloaded the area highlighted.
|
|
| 38271857 | Changed to stepover. I think that is the last. Unfortunately JOSM doesn't highlight these types of typos and there is just too much basic stuff to map. I do take lots of pictures. 20K short of 1M on file. No good for Mapillary as I'd need to check everyone. Someday, I will find time to produce my on map of images.
Dudley |
|
| 33698494 | Deleted as no evidence. |
|
| 54037027 | Deleted as this is a gate. |
|
| 36922365 | Changed to squeezer. |
|
| 36093523 | Changed to stepover. |