OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
150503600

Indeed, thanks! Fixed!

171036840

Thanks for referencing official information!

But why can't a National Highway be a primary? The above referenced wiki page (for Vietnam) says that primaries are "National Highways", while trunks are "High-quality National Highways that are not expressways. Usually divided and with partial grade separation." (which is not the case for 40B at the moment).

Do I understand right that 40B is planned to be upgraded to become higher quality till 2030? After that it would make more sense to tag it as trunk indeed.

154041452

Thanks for the clarification!

154041452

Hello!
There are a few points/questions about the classification:

1. If they're suburbs then of which town/city?

2. E.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Candolim says its a "census town" which in Indian terms means a well-developed village with a population > 5000. It doesn't say Candolim is a suburb of a bigger urban entity.

3. So they should be either towns or villages?

4. There seems to be no hard min of population for a town i OSM. osm.wiki/Tag%3Aplace%3Dtown says its varies between the countries and As of mid-2019, 34% of place=town have a population=* tag, and
"the median (average) value in the database varies by country, from as low as 3000 to as high as 35,000. But 95% of place=town have a population=* value between 1000 and 70,000. "

So seems like place=town is fitting, no?

Please clarify! Thanks!

158265220

a reply

158265220

test cs dicsussions

156371105

Я поменял на Валке-ярви, т.к. так его называли в сообществе трейл-раннеров Dикие, а "Плевок" звучит очень уж сленгово по-народному и больше подходит в alt_name.
Спасибо за историческую справку, переименуйте как надо, пожалуйста!