dgmapping's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 149785058 | 12 days ago | I checked that on April 2024, when this building was imported, it did exist in MaRu ETAK dataset. On December 2024 it was removed from there. Currently it's still active in ADS: https://xgis.maaamet.ee/adsavalik/EE03962033 In ehitisregister, it's listed as "Olemas" while the name is "Ajutine moodullinnak": https://livekluster.ehr.ee/ui/ehr/v1/building/121366310 I suppose this moodullinnak does not exist anymore and should be removed from OSM. |
| 174815712 | 24 days ago | Partial revert to restore this building |
| 174815712 | 25 days ago | Hello! The building you removed is not visible in MaRu main orthophoto imagery but it is visible in kiirortofoto: https://fotoladu.maaamet.ee/?basemap=kiirortofoto&zlevel=15,26.38170,58.74667&fotoarhiiv&overlay=tyhi
|
| 172971985 | 2 months ago | Updated the building outline based on MaRu ADS data. I hope you don't mind it fghj753 :) |
| 172915694 | 2 months ago | As requested, I reverted it |
| 163061538 | 10 months ago | Saunahoone on ikkagi hoone ning sellel peaks olema building silt:
|
| 161816657 | 10 months ago | Kusjuures olen ise ka seda meelt, et suvalistel kuuridel ei peaks OSMis aadressi küljes olema. Enda uuenduste puhul olen lähtunud sellest, et olemasolevate hoonete aadressid võiksid olla ajakohased ning seetõttu uuendatakse automaatselt kõiki poolikuid/vigaseid aadresse, olenemata unikaalaadressi nõudest. Aga kui hoonel pole ei unikaalaadressi nõuet ega ka aadressi silte küljes, siis neid ei uuendata. ETAK kood - see võib aja jooksul muutuda ning seetõttu uuendatakse seda koodi koos aadressitega. Kui väga vaja, saaks seda loogikat muidugi muuta. ETAK kood üksi väga suurt lisandväärtust ei lisa, seega minu poolest võid küll "suvalistelt" hoonetelt kõik addr:* sildid ja ETAK koodid eemaldada. Võimalusel koos source:addr sildiga. Kui sul on aga ettepanekuid suuremateks/massilisteks muudatuseks, siis kuulaks neid hea meelega. Samas mulle endale tundub, et kõikidelt hoonetelt automaatselt aadressite eemaldamine pole ka kõige parem mõte, kui unikaalaadressi nõue hoonel puudub. |
| 161816657 | 10 months ago | Hei! Märkasin, et paljudel juhtudel oled hoonetelt eemaldanud addr:housename sildid - saan aru, et loogika on selles, et vastavad hoone nimetused peaksid olema vaid krundil oleval peamisel hoonel, mitte abihoonetel? Hetkel jooksutan kord kuus automaatset scripti, mis uuendab hoonete aadresse vastavalt ADSi järgi: https://xgis.maaamet.ee/adsavalik/ Kui soovid, et automaatse uuendamise käigus ei lisata ebavajalikke addr silte, siis hetkel on see isegi võimalik, sest uuendust ei toimu, kui kõik järgmised nõuded on täidetud:
2) OSMi hoonel puuduvad addr:* sildid (country, city, place, street, housename, housenumber või postcode) 3) OSM hoonel puudub maaamet:ETAK silt |
| 162093242 | 10 months ago | Tere! Mitteeksteerivate hoonete kustutamine ja olemasolevate hoonete geomeetria parandamine on väga tänuväärne tegevus, aga mis eesmärkidel sa osadelt hoonetelt silte eemaldad? Siin üks näide: https://osm.mapki.com/history/way/244478142 maaamet:ETAK silt viitab Eesti topograafia andmekogus olevale hoonele, mis võimaldab erinevaid andmestike lihtsamini võrrelda. Kui see ETAK kood just vale pole, võiks seda OSMis hoida. source:addr silt "Maa- ja Ruumiamet 2025" näitas seda, et hoone aadress oli jaanuari seisuga OSMis endiselt õige. Kas see on tõesti ebavajalik info? |
| 161754641 | 11 months ago | Hello and welcome to OSM! When adding tags, please make sure you don't accidentally delete existing ones that are still relevant. Currently you removed building tag from the kindergarten building:
In addition, if this building was specifically built to be a kindergarten, then you can use: building=kindergarten |
| 160789590 | 12 months ago | way/26898804 - if a tower can be defined as building in OSM terms, then would it be better to keep building tag along with man_made? Especially when it has tags like building:levels and building:material |
| 160539151 | 12 months ago | Hi! It appears that official addresses for these buildings doesn't contain street name: https://xgis.maaamet.ee/adsavalik/ME00861079 I run a monthly script that updates Estonian building addresses and it will probably remove these addr:street tags. Hope that's ok. |
| 159770987 | about 1 year ago | Changed it back to trunk: changeset/160037463 |
| 159770987 | about 1 year ago | I agree with Piske and qqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqq - only official "kiirtee" as defined by liiklusseadus should be mapped as highway=motorway. To revert all EE motorways back to trunk means reverting 14 changesets. These also include other changes as well. I assume it might be better to change 699 individual way elements back to highway=truck? If there are no objections I can do this myself quite easily. |
| 159770987 | about 1 year ago | Hi! Looks like this is the first changeset where highway=motorway tag is used in Estonia:
Should this change be discussed first? |
| 159368104 | about 1 year ago | Hi! It appears that official address for this building doesn't contain street name: https://xgis.maaamet.ee/adsavalik/ads?ads_oid=EE03782478 I run a monthly script that updates Estonian building addresses and it will probably move "Nihu tee" to tag old_addr:street as before: https://osm.mapki.com/history/way/249641518 I hope that's ok. |
| 158581035 | about 1 year ago | I reverted the changesets, since address data was invalid as well:
|
| 158581035 | about 1 year ago | Hello! If you want to update existing house please add all the details to relevant way element: way/220610761 Currently you created 3 additional nodes for the same building. All these should be removed: |
| 157668206 | about 1 year ago | FYI qqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqq - it should be possible to do partial revert with https://revert.monicz.dev/ First check with overpass what is the scope of this: https://overpass-turbo.eu/?Q=way[highway%3Dtertiary_link](user%3ATTK_liikuvus)%3B%0Aout+geom%3B&R&C In the Changesets section you can add multiple values. There should be a least 10 changesets: 157659403,157661485,157663381,157663731,157664102,157665791,157666324,157667788,157668009,157668206 and in the Overpass filter add: way[highway=tertiary_link] After the revert check the original Overpass query again. |
| 156652351 | about 1 year ago | Fixed accidental node move |