davide84's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 160324393 | 4 months ago | I would also like to follow RFI and usually I check my other changes against ePIR, unfortunately their classification in rete fondamentale / rete complementare is a bit arbitrary and tied to their internal history and processes. A current example: Bressanone - San Candido is branch for RFI, San Candido - Lienz is main for OeBB. It does not make sense, so I think we should ask ourselves, what do we want to really represent in the map, because plainly reflecting the internal classifications of the different owners will not end well.
|
| 160324393 | 4 months ago | I see the point about it definitely not being a continental corridor, but I don't agree that rendering should be ignored in a mapping effort ;-) moreover, I believe the definition is intentionally vague to allow for considering the context: "higher traffic and higher speed ... longer than a branch line ... electrified" the RFI "dorsale" fulfills that for Sardinia compared to narrow gauge lines. I believe Cagliari-Olbia as "main" and the others as "branches" describes well the network of the island. |
| 160324393 | 4 months ago | Agree, that's why the RFI line in Sardinia is semi-officially called "backbone" :) I will restore the "main" tag on the Cagliari - Golfo Aranci line, leaving the ARST lines as branch lines. |
| 131652988 | 9 months ago | Ciao! ETCS (anche ERTMS/ETCS o solo ERTMS) è il nuovo sistema di segnalamento europeo in corso di installazione sulla rete ferroviaria nazionale. Il tag è preso da qui osm.wiki/OpenRailwayMap/Tagging#Train_protection_systems Ho controllato sulla documentazione di RFI e il sistema su questa linea non risulta ancora attivato, quindi il tag è giusto. Non so perchè su un segmento Osmose lo marca come "costruzione completata", io l'ho segnalato come "non un errore". |
| 160324393 | 9 months ago | Hi! Sorry for the late reply to this changeset... May I ask you what is the wiki definition? I had previously put the RFI tracks of Sardinia as "main", because otherwise in the maps Sardinia looks empty at too many zoom levels. Thanks! |
| 160906841 | 12 months ago | Learned to revert with JOSM plugins, reverted changeset/161779179 :-) Davide |
| 160906841 | 12 months ago | Hello. The linked document is 328 pages of stations whose layout I am not familiar with, excluding the language issue. My strategy here - copied from what I see happening - is to do my best and leave the details to the locals, there is no way I can precisely handle every single track/platform. And I think it's better to have a wrong changeover point than a whole line wrongly classified. So what I'm doing now is removing ERTMS from stations (Aarhus, Skanderborg, Vejle) to avoid the issue; as long as the result matches the official Banedanmark map that I linked as source we won't be too far from reality. |
| 160906841 | about 1 year ago | I try to link an official and publicly available source everytime I can; in this case the source is an official map from bane.dk - of course it does not match because of my mistake :) I read the instructions on how to revert a changeset and I found it simpler to just make another one correcting my error; please let me know if this is not appropriate! |
| 160906841 | about 1 year ago | Hello, you are right, I made a mistake while selecting in JOSM. I realized that after a few minutes and I already fixed it with another changeset changeset/160907172 |
| 135285976 | over 2 years ago | Fixed. I looked for the other example, can't find it, it must have been just an error from my side. Sorry! :-) |
| 135285976 | over 2 years ago | Yes, of course! I copied the tag from another line, I must have picked up the wrong example. I will fix this, and possibly the other as well. |