OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
81323711 almost 6 years ago

Hello. In Solana Olde Town Station you've "named" a number of the apartment buildings as "Solana Olde Town Station". This would not be correct. The entire complex is Solana Olde Town Station and this is defined by the residential complex area that encircles the entire complex. Each individual building may have a name, such as "Building 1" or "Building A" etc., but the building names would not be "Solana Olde Town Station". Can you go back and correct this? If you have any questions, please feel free to ask. Thank you :)

81323711 almost 6 years ago

Hello again. In Solana Olde Town Station you've created a number of "recreation grounds" which should be tagged simply as grass. If you click on one of the areas you created here you will see the letter "i" next to the words, "recreation ground". You can click on the "i" in order to see parameters for using particular items in the OSM database. Can you return to Solana Olde Town Station and correct these edits? Thank you :)

81323711 almost 6 years ago

Hello. Welcome to openstreetmap and thank you for your additions. When you create a rectangular object, such as a building or a parking lot, can you please "square the corners"? You can do this by selecting the object and then pressing the "Q" button. Can you return to your edits in Solana Olde Town Station and correct this? Thank you :)

72076472 almost 6 years ago

Hello, thank you for your additions to OSM. Are you certain about this fire station? It does not align with satellite imagery and the buildings here seem very much like residential homes. Thank you

81137847 almost 6 years ago

Hello, thank you for your response. I cannot say I agree or disagree with your position as to whether your method adds or doesn't add information that was previously there. I simply follow OSM guidelines and I'm not aware of any OSM guidelines that agree with your position, although if they exist I would certainly be interested in reading them. I would be concerned that making changes to work that is already mapped correctly, according to the OSM Wiki, might lead to edit wars. As for me, even though I might have a mapping style that is at odds with what another mapper has mapped correctly before me, unless OSM guidelines clearly indicate my changes are an improvement, I refrain from making changes. That's just me. Otherwise, I would fully expect the previous mapper might take issue with my edits and change them back. Without a clearly stated position from the OSM Wiki, I wouldn't really have a leg to stand on. Thank you :)

71689202 almost 6 years ago

Hello. Thank you for your question. From my perspective, it is irrelevant whether Edgewater is mapped as a city or not. OSM does not have strict guidelines as to what defines a place as a city. However, OSM does have an "on the ground" rule. Edgewater officially refers to itself as a city, whether people outside the city consider the place a city or not. In addition, the state government of Colorado also considers Edgewater to be a city. Colorado state government has a list of metropolitan districts, towns and cities. In this list, Edgewater is listed as a city. So, using the OSM "on the ground" rule, and based on the definitions used by Edgewater and the state of Colorado, Edgewater is a city. https://www.cleargov.com/colorado https://www.edgewaterco.com

81137847 almost 6 years ago

Hello, thank you, but I think maybe you are missing the point of my question. My original question was, was there a compelling reason for removing the business information located in the node and adding the same information to the building outline? The node, created about six years ago, was mapped correctly. Why change this, correct, mapping method? Is this because you prefer your style over someone else's? Thank you :)

81137847 almost 6 years ago

Hello, thank you for your response. Whether the entire building is occupied solely by one entity isn't really the issue. It's equally correct to place a business node within the confines of the building outline or to add the business to the building outline. Neither method is preferred in OSM. The issue is that since neither method is preferred, there's no need to remove the work of other mappers, i.e., the node here did not need to be removed. Thank you again for your additions to the map :)

81137847 almost 6 years ago

Hello, welcome to OSM and thank you for your contributions. Re: the 7-11 at East 17th Avenue & Pearl Street. Was there a compelling reason for removing the business node and adding the business name to the building outline? Thank you

79482017 almost 6 years ago

Hello, thank you for your additions to the map. The address you added here pops up as an error because there is no "N. Uinta St." The street is named, "Uinta Street." Abbreviations are not used and "N" is not part of the street name. Thank you :)

80025469 almost 6 years ago

Hello. The number of a bus stop should be added via the tag, "local_ref". You can see the documentation below. Thank you. local_ref=*

72327740 about 6 years ago

Hello, thank you for going through a number of changeset comments and making repairs. If I see any other problems, I'll be in touch. Cheers :)

77799022 about 6 years ago

Hello, thank you for your additions to the map. Just so you're aware, whenever adding a website, the scheme http or https must be included. Can you go back and correct this? Thank you website=*#Best_practice

77799221 about 6 years ago

Hello, thank you for your additions to the map. Just so you're aware, whenever adding a website, the scheme http or https must be included. Can you go back and correct this? Thank you website=*#Best_practice

77799719 about 6 years ago

Hello, thank you for your additions to the map. Just so you're aware, whenever adding a website, the scheme http or https must be included. Can you go back and correct this? Thank you website=*#Best_practice

77849530 about 6 years ago

Hello, thank you for your additions to the map. Just so you're aware, whenever adding a website, the scheme http or https must be included. Can you go back and correct this? Thank you website=*#Best_practice

77151537 about 6 years ago

Hello. Why did you delete the 3D elements on this building? Thank you

77436473 about 6 years ago

Hello, are you certain about the footpath you created here? Is there a footpath tunnel underneath the light rail track? Thank you

77495226 about 6 years ago

Hello, welcome to OSM and thank you for your efforts. Have you read the wiki entry for the application of summit crosses? Summit crosses are used to mark peaks. man_made=cross

77551098 about 6 years ago

Hello, welcome to OSM and thank you for your efforts. Have you read the wiki entry for the application of summit crosses? Summit crosses are used to mark peaks. man_made=cross