brendan714's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 170576656 | This is not relevant for mountain scrambling routes which have little to no trail visibility. Completely removing the original source information makes it very difficult to trace back the source of the data, which can be very helpful in many circumstances. At the very least, keep the original source info in addition to whatever changes you want to make. |
|
| 170266479 | It is not appropriate to grade Canadian climbing routes with UIAA grades. We have no idea what UIAA grades or SAC scale grades mean. In Canada we use the Yosemite Decimal System (YDS) for grading. Rating this as UIAA grade 4 will likely be confused as a YDS class 4 route, which is VERY different and could lead some people into thinking this route is easier than it actually is. I suggest you either remove the UIAA grading or replace it with YDS grading. |
|
| 170576656 | Why did you change the source on this route?? Knowing the source is a helpful piece of information which can help people find more details online. |
|
| 29370103 | The location of the track is correct. It's a mountain scramble, not a bike route |
|
| 34936639 | No they're not, I literally named these. What I called Porcupine Tower is shown in the correct location. |
|
| 88540419 | The lake doesn't exist, it's always dry. It used to be a lake but now it's not. So yes, the route goes straight through the middle of the old lake. |
|
| 40274425 | This data is available to the public without restriction. See the disclaimer inside the ZIP file: http://www.albertaparks.ca/media/2941843/parks_and_protected_areas_alberta.zip |
|
| 39336928 | Would be helpful if you tagged these ways as needing repair before deleting them entirely. Refinding the data is sometimes very hard / impossible. We are working to fix all the raw tracks but would appreciate tagging of tracks we've missed. Thanks! |
|
| 39294832 | Would be helpful if you tagged these ways as needing repair before deleting them entirely. Refinding the data is sometimes very hard / impossible. We are working to fix all the raw tracks but would appreciate tagging of tracks we've missed. Thanks! |
|
| 37207338 | Would be helpful if you tagged these ways as needing repair before deleting them entirely. Refinding the data is sometimes very hard / impossible. We are working to fix all the raw tracks but would appreciate tagging of tracks we've missed. Thanks! |
|
| 35920439 | Would be helpful if you tagged these ways as needing repair before deleting them entirely. Refinding the data is sometimes very hard / impossible. We are working to fix all the raw tracks but would appreciate tagging of tracks we've missed. Thanks! |
|
| 36310516 | Would be helpful if you tagged these ways as needing repair before deleting them entirely. Refinding the data is sometimes very hard / impossible. We are working to fix all the raw tracks but would appreciate tagging of tracks we've missed. Thanks! |
|
| 36362165 | Would be helpful if you tagged these ways as needing repair before deleting them entirely. Refinding the data is sometimes very hard / impossible. We are working to fix all the raw tracks but would appreciate tagging of tracks we've missed. Thanks! |