Thanks, I removed my island until I put all those pieces together. You're right, I may have to look harder at JOSM.
Thanks for all your help.

Very cool, we spend a lot of our summer at Chump. We run and ride these trails most weekends.
Just 2 quick questions for you if you don't mind. First, there's an cool looking island made on Little Johnson Lake (just south of Chump). I've been attempting the same thing for the little island in Chump but seem to only be able to get a lake within a lake. Do you know if this is something I can do with Potlach2? Second, my biggest concern with this is that it could all be accidentally deleted or overwritten. Is there a way to back this up or appeal to someone to revert if such an mishap were to occur?

Thanks for letting me know. Do the rest of the edits appear to be using the correct types? For example, I picked Roads | Track for all the trails. I could have picked Paths | Generic path. These are all primarily quad / dirtbike trails. I'm using Potlach2