Hi there. I don't understand why removing the public_transport=station railway=station station=subway and subway=yes from the station building (way/248971549) and then creating a new node (node/5444471176). It seems like there was a nice mapping of the station area but all that fine detail is now lost in favor of a single node. The documentation (osm.wiki/Railway_stations) mention "a node OR a polygon" but it seems like now both are mapped. Should we go back to having just the building as a station and delete that node?

Hi ZIV OSM,

May I know where you source this data from? I can't find anything about "Lantau Island Marine Reserve", and "Southwest Lantau Marine Park" seems to be only at proposal as of today. https://www.afcd.gov.hk/english/country/cou_vis/cou_vis_mar/cou_vis_mar_wha/gazette_doc.html

Thanks for your help,

Freayd

Replaced
operator="Hong Kong Post",
operator="Hongkong Post",
operator="香港郵政 Hong Kong Post" and
operator="香港郵政 Hong Kong Posttttt"
by
operator="香港郵政 Hongkong Post".

Hi Free gems 8,

It seems like you accidentally merge Unicorn Ridge together with Hong Kong. Sorry, I just reverted your edit to make sure that both features stay present on the map.

Please let me know if there's any problem with the revert.

Best,

Freayd

Hi,

Please tag service areas (服务区) with highway=services and not amenity=public_building building=yes. Rest areas (停车区) should be tagged with highway=rest_area

You can refer to the documentation for more information highway=services

Thank you.

Freayd

As per documentation, a service area "usually consist of, at minimum, a petrol station, parking facilities, a place to eat and some public toilets". Hansens Holz lacking the petrol station, I think it should be tagged as a rest area, IMHO.

highway=services

Hi manpro,

As per the wiki documentation, this is a service area. Rest areas offer no services and are generally no more than a parking place with toilets. On the other hand, service areas usually have some kind of restaurant, shop, petrol station and other varied amenities.

Raststätte Wetterau offer this kind of services and therefore, IMHO, should be tagged as a service area. Please let me know if you think otherwise. You can find more information on the documentation: osm.wiki/DE:Tag:highway%3Dservices

Cheers,

freayd

Perfect, thanks mate. No doubt you're doing a great job! No worries, we're all learning here. And sorry for the trouble.

Hey mate. Thanks for your comment. Please let's not engage into an edit war and discuss about this before any further modification. The main point of my changeset is that the data currently mapped is unusable. Routing software cannot find a way through the A1. I'm not able to verify the current situation by surveying on the ground, so I based my edit on the LPI NSW Base Map and the fact that the Kundabung to Kempsey project is not finished yet.

Whenever you leave a construction tag, such as construction=motorway combined with highway=trunk, the road won't be used by routing apps (at least some of them). Either use both construction=* and highway=construction if under construction or only highway=* if the construction is finished.

This is what the default routing engine does, diverting cars towards Crescent Head and through Port Macquarie: osm.org/directions?engine=osrm_car&route=-31.1228%2C152.8288%3B-31.4672%2C152.8195

Thanks for all your work by the way! Cheers.

Freayd

Hi Travo656. Sorry mate but I reverted the ways you changed to highway=trunk. As nevw mentioned, the rules for choosing a highway value are described on the wiki under Australian Tagging Guidelines. In Proserpine, only the A1 is a trunk. Apart from that, keep up the good work! Cheers.

Hi. Thanks for your comment, I already noticed the issue last time. I surveyed the ground once more. It should be fixed with the changeset/50582298.

Data from https://data.gov.au/dataset/qld-local-government-areas-psma-administrative-boundaries

Hi wdmanuel,

It seems that you are removing a lot of "name" tags in Hong Kong. Please leave them as per documentation features should have the three tags "name", "name:zh" and "name:en". Here are the documentation references coming with examples for Hong Kong and China:
- osm.wiki/Multilingual_names#Hong_Kong
- osm.wiki/Multilingual_names#China

Thanks for your help

Used Overpass query:

https://overpass-turbo.eu/?Q=node%5Bhighway%3Dbus_stop%5D%5Bname~%22%5B0-9%5D%7B5%7D%22%2Ci%5D(-43.6517%2C172.2831%2C-43.2790%2C172.8129)%3B%0Aout%20body%3B&R

Hi etajin, I reverted the Hiroshima node (1590291928) back in its central location as per documentation.

I based my opinion on this text "position a node at the recognized centre of the place, which may be location of the […] central square" from place=*#Nodes

My assumption might be false, I'll be happy to discuss about it. Freayd

Duplicated with way/237758276 and node/2456388751

Fixed locations:
- Hang Seng Bank (node/1298704529)

Fixed locations:
- Sheung Wan MTR Exit B (node/2555299651)
- Starbucks (node/3929690580)

Please discuss the issue instead of political debating and war editing. A discussion is (slowly) currently going on for both China/PRC and Taiwan/ROC, you're welcome to participate in it so we can all find an agreement : https://help.openstreetmap.org/questions/47439/china-and-taiwan-names

Hi,

Please don't add "m" at the end of the "ele" tag like described in the documentation ele=*#Example

Thank you for your contributions
谢谢