Changeset When Comment
191752253

Thanks.

Regarding connecting the lines, In OSM, it is preferred to map things as they exist in real life, rather than as they are "intended" to exist. This is opposite to many maps. For example, rather than creating a line which corresponds to the idea of a "mountain bike trail," it is preferred to create a line which corresponds to the physical path as it is cut on the ground. Then, we use segments or routes to create the idea of the "mountain bike trail"

In this case, I'd recommend connecting the north and south ways together. Then, when the trails are officially named, separate MTB route relations can be made for the idea of the "mountain bike trails."

Basically, if it's possible to travel along the path, from one segment to the other, they should be connected because that is reality.

191752253

Great! Would you consider adding a few more useful tags? These are the names in the iD editor:
- expected opening date
- surface (dirt probably)
- type (path)

And is there any reason these paths should stay separated from the existing paths-under-construction to the south? They're separated right now. (Two white dots in the iD editor, instead of a single gray dot).

191871972

Thanks for doing this. I agree that it doesn't make sense to add the route relation until the trail is open and signposted. We can add that MTB relation back when the trail is officially open.

191752253

Are the new paths made from your own GPS recordings?

191752253

Cool. Thanks for contributing. It sounds like you know more than I do.

The limit for adding these trails so far is lack of a data source. A survey or the Strava heatmap is the only way I know to add the trails.

Do you have more information about these trails?

191752253

OK—This is great. I am a local cyclist, but I haven't seen the recent changes in the north part of the park yet. I added the Monarch & Backwater trails from Strava data and my own surveys.

It looks like you've already removed the ways, trailheads, and guideposts for Who Hash and Bad Juju. That's good.

I also noticed that the paths had "Unnamed" in their name originally. It's preferred to leave the name blank for anything in OpenStreetMap, rather than "make up" a name. You may have noticed that someone removed the "Unnamed" it pretty fast.

Are you a new contributor to OpenStreetMap? There's several things I could share about adding a new mountain bike trail, but maybe you already know all about it.

191750167

Hi. A local mapper here. These new paths intersect many times with existing paths on the map. It seems unlikely that both of these paths exist as mapped currently. Was this added from a GPS recording? The new paths might be a copy of the paths already there, just less precise. GPS is usually not precise enough to create a path on the map from a single recording.

We can use a Strava heatmap overlay to see the average of many GPS recordings. This is much more accurate than using a single GPS recording, unless the trail is brand new. There wouldn't be any Strava data for a new trail. (osm.wiki/Strava)

It looks like the warnings in the iD editor (osm.org/edit ) were resolved by connecting the new paths to the existing paths. If the new paths and the old paths both exist, then this is correct.

Do you think there are new paths, separate from what was already mapped?

191752253

Great to see mappers in Searcy! Thanks for adding this. Looks like this path was added from GPX. That's great, but it is overlapping with an existing path already on the map. The existing path is marked as "under construction", but it is also a path. It has very similar tags.

Judging from the lack of name on the path and the status on the city's website, this trail is still under construction. https://www.cityofsearcy.org/trails-update

Can you extend the old path with your updates, instead of duplicating the existing one?

184798847

I converted the Tiger-imported ways from highway into maybe:highway.

133258828

I’m a local mapper. Thank you for adding POIs in Searcy. Regarding the smaller building housing Knightfire Barbecue—you mapped the building correctly. It is a separate building which shares a wall with the electronics repair store to the north.

On the other head, Knightfire Barbecue has moved locations. I separated the restaurant tags into a node in the new location in changeset #168377963.

149629464

monkeyruler90,

I'm working on adding trails from the Strava heatmap in the wooded area north of Saddleridge Drive.

Is there a sign or other official designation naming this path segment "Trail Trial 1"? If the name is not official, please remove the name tag.

Additionally, from aerial imagery, this way appears to just be a dirt path. Offroad trails are typically tagged highway=path, not highway=footway. What do you think about changing this way to highway=path?

Thanks!

156908224

I added tourism=artwork to the node. Thanks.

156908224

Thank you. Great. But according to the wiki, artwork_type=graffiti requires tourism=artwork too, doesn't it?

156908224

Thank you for converting the artwork node into a ruins node. The feature is inherently a ruined bridge support.

However, I'd like to see the artwork tags preserved, either on this node or another node.

Maybe the ruins can be converted into an area, and the artwork can be added back as a node on the area? When I surveyed the bridge support, it was rectangular, wider on the north/south sides than the east/west sides. The graffiti was on on the longer, southern face.

148968149

In the future, you may have more luck changing the type of a road by clicking the large "Feature Type" button and searching for the new type.

The smaller dropdown only allows changing between sub-types of the same "Feature Type".

148968149

Sure!

I changed it in Changeset #156575887. changeset/156575887

148968149

Cool—Let me know if I can help.

Once again, great to have you mapping in Searcy!

148968149

Hi Elenfoxx! I see from your [profile](@Elenfoxx) that you've started mapping this year. Glad to have you mapping in Searcy!

I would like to propose that we change the roads in the Parkside Apartments complex from highway=living_street to highway=driveway or highway=parking_aisle.

Living Streets in OpenStreetMap have a specific meaning. From the [Wiki for the highway=living_street tag](osm.wiki/Tag:highway%3Dliving_street), "A general feature of living streets is that the legislation grants pedestrians higher or equal right of way over other road users."

What do you think?

150815413

Understood. Thank you for your diligence in removing vandalism!

150815413

There is a small beach made of pebbles on the bank of Deener Creek. It is real. It's a place where people access the creek for recreation, though informally.

What is the appropriate tag, if natural=beach is inaccurate?