OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
142418415 about 2 years ago

Hello AssisFS, Thank you for your local investigation into this link road. Given that you have access to this region I will defer to your local knowledge. If this way is no longer in use, it would be best set to disused:highway=primary_link (disused:*=*) to retain history and prevent access. You can upload the images you took to Mapillary (see https://help.mapillary.com/hc/en-us/articles/115001472029-Different-upload-methods) for the benefit of all of OSM. Have a nice day.

Tradução automática
Olá AssisFS, Obrigado pela sua investigação local sobre esta estrada de ligação. Dado que você tem acesso a esta região, recorrerei ao seu conhecimento local. Se esta forma não estiver mais em uso, seria melhor configurá-la para disused:highway=primary_link (disused:*=*) para reter o histórico e impedir o acesso. Você pode enviar as imagens que você tirou para o Mapillary (veja https://help.mapillary.com/hc/en-us/articles/115001472029-Different-upload-methods) para o benefício de todo o OSM. Tenha um bom dia.

142797763 about 2 years ago

Hello carlosnasci, thanks for reaching out! My intention when reclassifying Rua Doutor Jorge Tibirça was to unify the classification gap between the primary roads entering and exiting the city at way/418642307 and way/418642307. According to global highway classification policy primary roads “often link larger towns” (highway=*), and it is generally considered best practice to connect the higher road network together, rather than segment it.

For example: way/169164813 travels through the town of Lindoia and does not drop in classification. Is there a resource you could direct me to that indicates this is a secondary road? I look forward to hearing back from you.

142418415 about 2 years ago

Hi AssisFS, thanks for reaching out! According to this article (https://boavista.rr.gov.br/noticias/2023/9/tres-canteiros-centrais-serao-fechados-a-partir-desta-terca-feira-26-no-bairro-sao-francisco), the road appears to be closed for construction and not removed entirely. Can you confirm whether this is a removal of the road or a temporary closure? If it’s a removal, I would recommend tagging it as disused:highway=primary_link to preserve the history of the link road while preventing access. However, if it’s a temporary closure, I suggest tagging it with access=no to prevent future misunderstandings regarding the status of this road. I look forward to hearing back from you!

128664850 about 3 years ago

Hello Alessandro, rab is correct, I did not add the name tags to these highways. My edits pertained to the geometry of these highways. It looks like the edit that added the name came from this project: https://tasks.hotosm.org/projects/13457
I hope that helps, happy mapping!