So the concern was that I uploaded entrances in a church in my hometown, whilst living abroad, not something with how I did it? Okay. Thank you for checking and keeping OSM free from spam and other nefarious things.
---
#REVIEWED_GOOD #OSMCHA
Published using OSMCha: https://osmcha.org/changesets/173887792

Dear Frans,

Thanks for the updates. I see the residential you deleted and the shift from ground to unpaved. I see under the guidelines here: osm.wiki/Highway_Tag_Africa#Typology_of_Road_Network_in_African_countries that ground is acceptable.

RE issues reported by iDeditor, I don't always fix them if they weren't initially caused by me. If I have time to fix other people's issues, I do, but not always given the scale of what needs doing. If it was caused by me and I didn't fix it, I'm sorry and will be more diligent going forward.

I just cleared two errors on one track but then two other prexisting ones popped up involving that feature and some waterways, and will now be attributed to me though I didn't cause them.

Thank you for checking my work and I hope it improves in the future. Please keep commenting on my work and I'll try to keep the quality up.

Best,

Walker

Can you please confirm which roads are problematic? I see residential roads only in the village/town there, and unclassified roads outside the town, as they should be.

Indeed. This option was selected because area=border_control does not exist. And government=Customs also requires a building tag. This was added at the request of the then-government so they could do an inventory. There are other places with the border control tag that also don’t have buildings because they did the border controls with people from vehicles. Afghanistan, like so many places, does not always lend itself to neat tagging. If you really want to have a heart attack, check out all the roads that are also rivers, which is correct or the schools. Thank you for keeping the map as accurate as it can be.

If you have a better tagging combination, do tell and I’m happy to make it so.

Hi Nordpfeil, I hope you're doing well. Thank you so much for your work. I wanted to bring to your attention that some of your roads have "unclassified" being misspelled, which means they don't render and cannot be used for routing. Would you mind fixing them? in case it helps, here is the Overpass turbo link: http://overpass-turbo.eu/s/1cOf

If you want to build the query yourself, the tag is: “highway=Unclasisified”

Respectfully yours,

Walker

Hi! Your edits look great! Thank you for putting in so much work on Afghanistan. I see you use ID editor a lot, have you ever looked at using RapID to quickly add even more roads? If you're interested check out mapwith.ai it's Facebook's computer vision extraction efforts. Happy Mapping!

Dear Hassanpoor sb,

Is this part of an organized mapping effort?

Best,

Walker KB

Dear Rohullah,

just like the other changesets, please stop making building overlapping buildings. The buildings you are putting in are not visible on any imagery source and your comments don't imply a ground survey or other source of data. Please confirm source?

Best,

Walker

Dear Rohullah,

Thanks for contributing to the map in Afghanistan. I see you're putting in a lot of Buildings overlapping buildings. This topological issue reduces the usability of OSM, and is incorrect.

Here are some materials on the digitization of buildings: https://learnosm.org/fa/coordination/remote-tracing/

I'm happy to hold a mapathon and work with you and your friends and colleagues on this.

Best,

Walker

Hi Andrew,

Thank you for contributing to OSM Afghanistan. I just wanted ot reach out and let you know that the Maxar Imagery is a little newer than Bing in Afghanistan. Thanks!

Happy Mapping,

Best,

Walkre

Dear Rohullah,

Thank you for contributing to OSM. I'm confused by the tags you have used here. Building=household is not one of the accepted tags by OSM. Maybe you mean place=plot? place=plot

Here are the generally accepted building options: osm.wiki/Buildings#Building

Could you please correct your tags? Thanks!

Best,

Walker

Thank you so much for cleaning up the roads data in Afghanistan. We really appreciate it!

Best,

Walker

Dear Taha,

Thank you for improving the map of Afghanistan! I'm writing to you today to say that the "maxar premium" imagery layer is newer than "Bing" and often a little clearer. Take care and happy mapping!

Best,

Walker

Hi there. Like the ones in Iran, are you using Maxar Premium? It is the newest imagery in Afghanistant.

Best,

Walker

Hi there. Thank you for contributing to OpenStreetMap! I'm trying to find the roads that you placed, but i do not see them on imagery anywhere. Can you please tell me which imagery you are using? Maxar Premium layer is usually the most up to date. Are these new roads?

Best,

Walker

Dear Ratrun,

I see your imagery source is Bing. Bing imagery for Afghanistan is very very old. You may want to check Maxar Premium for the newest imagery.

Best,

Walker

Dear Mohaqeq,

Thank you so much for your work! These look great! If you want to check out some additional resources, check out https://mapwith.ai/

Using that we can add many many roads to the map quickly.

Thank you for helping make the map of Afghanistan the best it can be!

Warm regards,

Walker

Dear Hassanpoor sb,

Thank you so much for contributing to the map of Afghanistan! I see you’re using the ESRI imagery. You may want to use Maxar imagery, I think it’s a little newer! Happy mapping! If you want any help please let me know. Maybe you want to join the Facebook group OpenStreetMap Afghanistan.

Best,

Walker

Dear Mohaqeq sb,

Thank you so much for adding so much to map of Afghanistan. I noticed that many of the buildings are not actually "buildings" but are compounds, some of which include orchards and other agricultural goods. Perhaps these could be changed to "residential" land use instead of buildings? If you go that route, it might be much easier and faster to tag the whole area rather than the individual compounds. If you haven't already, please join the Afghanistan OpenStreetMap group so we can all chat more and coordinate.

Likewise the actual buildings (not the whole land use areas) don't have square corners. In OpenStreetMap, we prefer to have the buildings have nice square corners, in ID editor and JOSM this is done through the "Q" button, but the overall polygon is selected. When you get a chance, if you could go back and start retagging the areas with area features, and only the physical structure as a "building".

Thank you for your contributions and for making the OSM for Afghanistan the most accurate it can be. Slowly slowly we will build the whole map!

Kind regards,

Walker

Dear Jafary sb,

Thank you so much for making the map of Afghanistan the best it can be. I have two points of feedback for you. The first is that Bing Imagery is very old, you may want to use Maxar Premium, it is much newer! The second, is that when you make buildings, after you add the building select the building and press "Q", to make the building with nice corners. Here is a "cheat sheet" for JOSM: osm.wiki/w/images/9/99/JOSM_Keyboard_shortcuts_cheat_sheet.png

Happy Mapping!!

Best,

Walker