Hi MxxCon,

Thank you for pointing this out. The changeset has been reverted. changeset/151947133

Hi MxxCon, thank you for your feedback and suggesting the fix! I re-read the wiki regarding the segregated tag and I think you are 100% correct. The segregated=yes tag would apply if the footway and cycleway were captured in one way feature. However, in this case, they are separately digitized, so segregated=no would be more appropriate. Please let me know if I'm understanding it correctly. I have made the changes to the tag as well. Thank you!

Hello rskedgell, thank you for your feedback. After uploading the initial changesets, I realized that I had to update the parent street as well and made the necessary corrections before seeing your comment. I went back and added the relevant tag updates to the parent streets for as many sidewalks as possible based on my recollection. If you notice any that I might have missed, please do let me know. Thank you again for your input!

Jarek Piórkowski, I apologize for misinterpreting this feature edit. I made my edits based on aerial imagery and missed your changeset comment. Thank you for restoring the correct changeset.

Sincerely,
Jesspher

Hi anddriu44, thank you for the feedback. I have reverted my changeset to the previous version. changeset/141120000

Testing changeset comment.

Hi Ismaeldiarria,

Thanks for trying out RapiD! Most of the digitized roads from your changesets look great :) However, I noticed from this and other changesets that some of the roads were left disconnected/ incomplete. When tracing highways, ensure you are zoomed in sufficiently. As a starting guide set the scale to about 20 meters, and trace the road so that your tracing has sufficient points in it to keep it on, or very close to, the road you can see in your satellite imagery. The RapiD editor also comes equipped with a validator which gives warnings about potential errors. While AI is a great assistant that starts us off with the geometry of the roads, the normal rules of OSM still apply and we encourage users to validate things like connections. Love your continued support of OSM! Let us know if you have any questions.

Thanks for your time,
Jesspher

Hi JanetChapman,

Thanks for trying out RapiD! Most of the digitized roads from your changesets look great :) However, we noticed from this and other changesets that some of the roads were left disconnected/ incomplete. When tracing highways, ensure you are zoomed in sufficiently. As a starting guide set the scale to about 20 meters, and trace the road so that your tracing has sufficient points in it to keep it on, or very close to, the road you can see in your satellite imagery. The RapiD editor also comes equipped with a validator which gives warnings about potential errors. While AI is a great assistant that starts us off with the geometry of the roads, the normal rules of OSM still apply and we encourage users to validate things like connections. Love your continued support of OSM! Let us know if you have any questions.

Thanks for your time,
Jesspher

Hi sis651,

Thank you for your feedback! The issues you’re experiencing could be due to the RapiD shortcut keys being mixed up with JOSM. For example, the “S” key by default is “Select objects” in JOSM while the “S” key in RapiD is to “Straighten a line or points”. This happened to me as well since I’ve mainly used JOSM and switching over to RapiD editor may require a bit of getting used to. If you continue to experience this, please let us know and we can look into it further!

Thank you!

Hi hebolz,

Thanks for trying out RapiD! Most of the digitized roads from your changesets look great :) However, we noticed from this and other changesets that some of the roads were left disconnected/ incomplete.. When tracing roads, ensure you are zoomed in sufficiently. As a starting guide set the scale to about 20 meters, and trace the road so that your tracing has sufficient points in it to keep it on, or very close to, the road you can see in your satellite imagery. The RapiD editor also comes equipped with a validator which gives warnings about potential errors. While AI is a great assistant that starts us off with the geometry of the roads, the normal rules of OSM still apply and we encourage users to validate things like connections. Love your continued support of OSM! Let us know if you have any questions.

Thanks for your time,
Jesspher

Hi sis651,

Thanks for trying out RapiD! Most of the digitized roads from your changesets look great :) However, we noticed from this and other changesets that some of the roads were disconnected/ incomplete as well as road heirarchy errors. When tracing highways, ensure you are zoomed in sufficiently. As a starting guide set the scale to about 20 meters, and trace the highway so that your tracing has sufficient points in it to keep it on, or very close to, the road you can see in your satellite imagery. The RapiD editor also comes equipped with a validator which gives warnings about potential errors. While AI is a great assistant that starts us off with the geometry of the roads, the normal rules of OSM still apply and we encourage users to validate things like connections. Love your continued support of OSM! Let us know if you have any questions.

Thanks for your time,

Hi 58zarali,

Thanks for trying out RapiD! Most of the digitized roads from your changesets look great :) However, we noticed from this and other changesets that some of the roads were disconnected/ incomplete. When tracing highways, ensure you are zoomed in sufficiently. As a starting guide set the scale to about 20 meters, and trace the highway so that your tracing has sufficient points in it to keep it on, or very close to, the road you can see in your satellite imagery. The RapiD editor also comes equipped with a validator which gives warnings about potential errors. While AI is a great assistant that starts us off with the geometry of the roads, the normal rules of OSM still apply and we encourage users to validate things like connections. Love your continued support of OSM! Let us know if you have any questions.

Thanks for your time,
Jesspher

Hi sthome,

Thanks for trying out RapiD! Most of the digitized roads look great :) However, we noticed from your changesets that some of the roads were disconnected/ incomplete. When tracing highways, ensure you are zoomed in sufficiently. As a starting guide set the scale to about 20 meters, and trace the highway so that your tracing has sufficient points in it to keep it on, or very close to, the road you can see in your satellite imagery. The editor also comes equipped with a validator which gives warnings about potential errors. While AI is a great assistant that starts us off with the geometry of the roads, the normal rules of OSM still apply and we encourage users to validate things like connections. Love your continued support of OSM! Let us know if you have any questions.

Thanks for your time,
Jesspher

Hi nlagrone,

Thanks for trying out RapiD! Most of the digitized roads look great :) However, we noticed from your changesets that some of the roads were disconnected and one had a dragged node. When tracing highways, ensure you are zoomed in sufficiently. As a starting guide set the scale to about 20 meters, and trace the highway so that your tracing has sufficient points in it to keep it on, or very close to, the road you can see in your satellite imagery. The editor also comes equipped with a validator which gives warnings about potential errors. While AI is a great assistant that starts us off with the geometry of the roads, the normal rules of OSM still apply and we encourage users to validate things like connections. Love your continued support of OSM! Let us know if you have any questions.

Thanks for your time,
Jesspher

Hi dmcglone,

Thanks for trying out RapiD! Most of the digitized roads look great :) However, we noticed from your changesets that some of the roads were disconnected/ incomplete. When tracing highways, ensure you are zoomed in sufficiently. As a starting guide set the scale to about 20 meters, and trace the highway so that your tracing has sufficient points in it to keep it on, or very close to, the road you can see in your satellite imagery. While AI is a great assistant that starts us off with the geometry of the roads, the normal rules of OSM still apply and we encourage users to validate things like connections. Love your continued support of OSM! Let us know if you have any questions.

Thanks for your time,
Jesspher

Hi eneedham,

Thanks for trying out RapiD! We noticed from your changesets that some of the roads were disconnected and some with inaccurate tagging. Most of the digitized roads look great however a few of them overlapped and some were left disconnected. RapiD shows this with a slightly larger and darker colored dot at the junction. I also noticed an overuse of unclassified roads. I think that some of these roads can be tagged as track per the highway tagging wiki: highway=*. While AI is a great assistant that starts us off with the geometry of the roads, the normal rules of OSM still apply and we encourage users to validate things like connections. Love your continued support of OSM! Let us know if you have any questions.

Thanks for your time,
Jesspher

Hi Øukasz,

Thanks for trying out RapiD! We currently have data available in Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Indonesia, Mexico, Nigeria, Tanzania, and Uganda and we are working on adding more data in other countries. For more information, please visit https://mapwith.ai/#13/36.70335/67.07788/0/55. Love your continued support of OSM! Thanks for your time!

Regards,
-Jesspher

Hi Øukasz,

Thanks for trying out RapiD! We currently have data available in Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Indonesia, Mexico, Nigeria, Tanzania, and Uganda and we are working on adding more data in other countries. For more information, please refer to https://mapwith.ai/#13/36.70335/67.07788/0/55. Love your continued support of OSM! Thanks for your time!

Regards,
-Jesspher

Hi mdei,

Thanks for trying out RapiD! We noticed from the changeset/72862591 that a square block of landuse=residential was digitized. It was a great idea to digitize the residential area. Residential boundaries are used for many purposes in OpenStreetMap. One of the simplest use is to be able to see residential areas at higher zoom levels so it is preferred that we trace the outbound of the residential area to avoid weird square shapes. Please refer to: https://learnosm.org/en/coordination/remote-tracing/ and osm.wiki/Landuse for preferred techniques with mapping landuses. Love your continued support of OSM! Let us know if you have any questions.

Thanks for your time,
-Jesspher

Hi Nesim,

Thanks for trying out RapiD! We noticed from your changesets using the RapID Editor included some unconnected roads. It seems like some of the AI generated roads were accepted and left as is. Roads generated by AI are often not perfect and we highly encourage users to adjust and validate these roads before submission. Some of these issues can be caught using the built in the new validation panel in iD which we encourage you to check out. Thanks for your time!

-Jesspher