OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
181388939

Consistent with the "old" A1 road Farish - Rosoman and A2 road Rankovce - Kriva Palanka

180389488

Гледам веќе беа и вратени од adt и мислам така треба и да останат

180389488

Од каде да се водам ако не од официјален извор на податоци? Затоа и постојат измени, да се менуваат работите бидејќи се менуваат и работите на терен. И овај воопшто не е сегашен А3. Плански можеби, но дефакто не.

180473139

Also fixes wrong one-way link near Ohrid.

180473139

This is from a recent drive survey.

For reference, green signs for directions are used on highways and require an emergency lane and higher speed limit of 130.

180389488

Само што ова делче не е поврзано со тој пат во Ресен како еден пат, како што е Охрид - Прилеп или Каратманово - Делчево.
Исто така не е дел од патната секција од СЕ на roads.org.mk.

Мојот предлог е да не е означен како primary, туку како uncategorized, а другите поврзувања со А3 да си останат како што се.

180389488

Те молам објасни ми како „главен пат“, кој има пристап само од една селска улица која води до ниви и земјени патишта треба да виде означен како главен пат

180389488

while it can still be part of the planned A3, it definitely shouldn't be set as [highway=primary] as it's not used like it at all as now we have a primary section in the middle of nowhere. And I doubt if it's even in good condition.

179545576

A consistency change, like the other link on the highways

178480658

While this segment might not be on motorway standards, especially the Katlanovo-Veles segment, it's still legally designated as such. And the other way Veles-Katlanovo is definitely a motorway.

This change should be reverted and the other appropriate tags should be used like number of lanes and speed.

163651512

I'm repeating myself, you can check the RAMS Project where any road starts and ends.

R1303 starts at klučka Novo Lagovo
In fact here is whole road segments, from start to end
http://62.77.137.99/roads/files/Sections/RAMS_report-Section__1351.pdf
http://62.77.137.99/roads/files/Sections/RAMS_report-Section__1352.pdf
http://62.77.137.99/roads/files/Sections/RAMS_report-Section__1353.pdf
http://62.77.137.99/roads/files/Sections/RAMS_report-Section__1354.pdf
http://62.77.137.99/roads/files/Sections/RAMS_report-Section__1355.pdf
http://62.77.137.99/roads/files/Sections/RAMS_report-Section__1356.pdf
http://62.77.137.99/roads/files/Sections/RAMS_report-Section__1357.pdf
http://62.77.137.99/roads/files/Sections/RAMS_report-Section__1358.pdf
http://62.77.137.99/roads/files/Sections/RAMS_report-Section__1359.pdf

163651512

Like I said, at start of A3 (klučka Novo Lagovo).
However I mistyped it and corrected it here (however the relation was correct): changeset/163660143

Thank you for making me look at it.

163651512

R1107 starts at Rosoman and ends at R1101
R1101 starts at end of A1
R1303 starts at start of A3.

All this are at the same area (klučka Novo Lagovo)

163651512

My sources are official, you can check them here: https://i.imgur.com/x6qrdsR.png
As well as the links I provided at the top of the comments.

The new expressway is mentioned as A1 thought the news multiple times.

Old signs with old markings (old_ref) still exists thought Macedonia like M5, R501, etc. you can see even today.

163651512

I don't see any source for that. And if "yesterday" was like that but "today" that is changed, the map should also be updated accordingly.

163651512

Sorry, but I don't make the rules. If the government designated those as regional roads, those are regional roads and should be mapped accordingly, even if they don't make sense.

For lanes and width, there are other tags.

163631715

See changeset/163651512

163651512

ENGLISH TRANSALTION:

Here they do not have detailed information about the roads they pass through. This is also from 2011, and the RAMPS project is from 2023. Namely, from the official gazette it says:

- R1101 -> Prilep (connection with A1, A3)-Bitola-Makazi -Tsarev dvor (connection with P1307)

- connection with A1, A3 is at Novo Lagovo

- P1303 Prilep (connection with R1101)-Makedonski Brod-Kicevo (connection with A2)

- R1101 starts at Novo Lagovo

- According to this (wrong) amendment, R1303 starts from A1 and should be R11xx road and not R13xx road which starts from A3.

-P1306 next to RAMPS project from 2023 http://62.77.137.99/roads/files/Sections/RAMS_report-Section__1372.pdf

- P1312 next to RAMPS project from 2023 http://62.77.137.99/roads/files/Sections/RAMS_report-Section__1404.pdf

- More information and details on "State Roads and Road Sections" (RAMPS Project): http://62.77.137.99/roads/index.php?l=mk
- https://i.imgur.com/x6qrdsR.png

163651512

Овде немаат детални информации за патиштата каде поминуваат Исто така ова е од 2011, а RAMPS проектот е од 2023. Имено од службен весник пишува:

- Р1101 -> Прилеп (врска со А1,А3)-Битола-Макази -Царев двор (врска со P1307)
- врска со А1,А3 е кај Ново Лагово

- P1303 Прилеп (врска со Р1101)-Македонски Брод-Кичево (врска со А2)
- Р1101 почнува кај Ново Лагово
- Според оваа (грешна) измена Р1303 почнува од А1 и би требало да биде Р11хх пат а не Р13хх пат кои почнуваат од А3.

-P1306 поред RAMPS проект од 2023 http://62.77.137.99/roads/files/Sections/RAMS_report-Section__1372.pdf

- Р1312 поред RAMPS проект од 2023 http://62.77.137.99/roads/files/Sections/RAMS_report-Section__1404.pdf

- Повеќе информации и детали на „Државни патишта и патни секции“ (RAMPS Project): http://62.77.137.99/roads/index.php?l=mk
- https://i.imgur.com/x6qrdsR.png

163347069

R1101 Start: http://62.77.137.99/roads/files/Sections/RAMS_report-Section__1201.pdf

R1312: http://62.77.137.99/roads/files/Sections/RAMS_report-Section__1404.pdf

R1303 Start: http://62.77.137.99/roads/files/Sections/RAMS_report-Section__1351.pdf
R1303 part: http://62.77.137.99/roads/files/Sections/RAMS_report-Section__1353.pdf