Yes tracing was done manually.

Good day too Roinel. The primary source used for the alignment was esri as strava coverage is limited to a short segment near the national highway.

Wishing you all the best for your thesis! Please let me know if there's anything I could do to assist.

Good evening and welcome to OSM. You removed the shop=furniture tag here but left the name. Was this by accident or does the store not exist anymore?

Good day. Established practice for barangay boundaries is to follow coastlines. There's a legal basis for municipal waters but this jurisdiction does not extend to barangays.

Some of the added barangay boundaries seem to conflict with previously mapped city boundaries, e.g. Pulung Bulu (relation/21044450) has a large overlap with Angeles.

Both the changesets that added Angeles/San Fernando boundary as well as your additions don't mention any sources that were used so it's quite difficult for other mappers to deduce which ones are more accurate.

Could you please review this and fix the overlaps?

Hi and welcome to OpenStreetMap!

When adding stores to the map please only put the actual name of a store in the name field. For personal notes you can use bookmarks as they're not relevant for other map users.

Also please try to use best fitting object category, convenience store for sari-sari stores, bakery for bakeshops and so on.

Lastly, maybe you would like to check out Organic Maps. It's an improved version of Maps.me with many additional features and better tools to add and edit points-of-interest and bookmarks.

Thanks for your edits!

Is this (node/6495312685/history/) a second location of Casa James or did you change name by accident?

I've known the tool but I'm definitely not using it enough. Thanks for the reminder and thanks for your awesome contributions around here!

Maayong hapon and thanks for your contributions to OSM. Please don't add personal notes in the name field as they will be visible for all map users. Maps.me has a bookmark function that can be used instead.

Also here you added two stores at the same location, is this Cagabcabon or Labrada Store? Or are they next to eachother?

Welcome to OSM and thanks for your edits!

Yes, every changeset should have a short explanation of what you did. For example "added barangay boundaries". Please also mention what sources you used (aerial imagery, other maps, local knowledge, survey, etc.). This is important so that other mappers will know the origin of the things that you're mapping. For more details about changeset comments see osm.wiki/Good_changeset_comments

Thanks for fixing this and for your relentless efforts of fixing bad OSM data in general 😄

Good day. Would you mind sharing your reverting workflow? Especially for cases when you notice that affected objects have already been edited in the meantime.

Method seems to have improved since changeset/180762095 as now tags of already conducted repairs are preserved.

But somehow this revert has removed numerous nodes from way member list for no apparent reason, causing several new geometry and connectivity issues.

Place node histories have been restored in changeset/181254779

Good day. Looks like you missed some follow-up edits made after the reverted changeset but before your revert. As a consequence your edit removed numerous lifecycle disused prefixes and check_dates while restoring unnecessary tags that have been previously deleted.

Fixed in changeset/181032160

Welcome to OSM and thanks for your edits!

Indoor mapping is quite complicated, if you plan to do more of it I would recommend having a look at this guide on the OSM wiki: osm.wiki/Simple_Indoor_Tagging

Some basic things to consider:
- highway=footway for outdoor ways, highway=corridor for indoor ways
- name tag is only for actual names, not descriptions
- building parts and rooms that share physical walls should also be connected in OSM

If you would like to get in touch with fellow local mappers, here's a list of channels maintained by the OSM PH community: osm.org/wiki/PH

Accidentally deleted objects restored in changeset/181024216

Good afternoon. Could you please have another look at the name tags of Daang Hari Extension/Open Canal Road? Which of the two names is the current official name for the road?

When editing names please make sure to select all affected segments to avoid name alternating forth and back.

Also if a road has several names then these should be preserved in alt_name/old_name or variants. Right now there are numerous segments that have both name and alt_name set to Open Canal Road while the name Daang Hari Extension was removed by your edits.

It appears that the wiki documention on this issue is a bit inconsistent. While the page for toll only explicitly mentions roads, the page for fee contains this statement:

"toll=* - to indicate that a road, bridge, ferry, or other way is tolled - that you must pay to use it. This key is used instead of fee=*."

According to taginfo there are 3300 occurrences of path + toll but only 1300 for path + fee. Even for footways toll is more commonly used with 1900 occurrences vs. 1600 for fee.

Considering a similar discussion on toll vs. fee for ferry routes (https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/toll-yes-or-fee-yes-for-ferry-routes/119341) it seems that mappers use both tags for different but overlapping purposes. Best way forward might be to improve wiki pages to document both use cases and propose verifiable criteria for differentiation.

Hi Totor. Is it possible that this bridge was added by mistake?

way/1456613967 ?

Here's recent ground-level imagery from this location:
https://www.mapillary.com/app/?lat=10.02742151014101&lng=123.42190968704995&z=19.510770631175262&focus=photo&pKey=1703469860632509

Hi and thanks for your awesome contributions to OSM!

I noticed that you added bicycle=no on several ways around here. Access tags in OSM are intended for legal restrictions.

If it is not forbidden to ride a mountain bike here then more suitable tagging would be to add details like smoothness or sac_scale to indicate how rough or difficult the trails are for bicycles.