SekeRob's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 192218059 | The recommended source tag appears to be IGM- DBSN + the release year. The wiki indicates that DBSN dataset uses also (old) OSM data. Kind of circular. osm.wiki/Italy/DBSN. Anyway the linked article somewhere down says you're OK "On August 11th 2025 the LWG, asked for a clarification specifically on the DBSN case with ticket #2025060310000151, has clarified that DBSN is compatible to be imported in OSM: "
|
|
| 192218059 | Hi, Are these 'carte topografica IGM' datas provided under license compatibility with that of OSM's ODbL? For reference the position of OSM on licensing https://blog.openstreetmap.org/2017/03/17/use-of-cc-by-data/ |
|
| 191929941 | Hi giorgio92 You touched these roads 'under construction' way/1579209778#map=19/41.746085/14.067634. First put on the map in 2018 and gradually deteriorating the roundabouts basically returning to grass in Mapbox 2026. Is this 'under construction'? Think it's time the 'abandoned:highway=construction and abandoned:construction=unclassified' tags are put in place unless this was checked on the ground as real. Then a check_date=yyyy-mm-dd tag needs adding and a note added to explain the status for the next mapper as this keeps being flagged as 'is this finished?'
|
|
| 192146611 | Be advised, your flowline deletions without any motivation have been reverted: See osm.wiki/Tag:waterway%3Dflowline
|
|
| 191833217 | OK, ran an overpass and reverted the affected roundings to their original 1 decimal fraction,.
|
|
| 191941979 | Hi, maxstay tutte giorno 7/7 o maxstay:conditional per parte i giorni? Typo parking=street_side? |
|
| 191991596 | Wrong comment. Added restaurant and updated bar. |
|
| 191833217 | Hey, not implying cairns to add to the elevation. Fine with 'to the decimeter exact' not cm. Did not check what the base was of that decimeter removal. When running a revert accidentally also reverted that decimeter removal. I erroneously annulled that. Should have left it with. Cheers |
|
| 191885695 | Suggest you tone it down with your commentaries. Your view of the world and how it 'should' be is a little different. What I see against 'old sources' is there and can be traced against NEW sources and no doubt I make mistakes. We correct them but NOT delete. Same with tree rows and fences. So be prepared for those that are blind as a bat can still see will put the deleted items back or add appropriated life cycle tags to ensure that the next one does not map it again.
|
|
| 191833217 | Hi, And there assumed this was consensus. Mistakenly reverted 3 of them to fraction, I thought so, and put the rounded back. The person did more of these in the larger area. Also seen the mapper remove peaks that have no name. Claimed they did not exist, Hovering in JOSM at the spots they are elevated points in the surrounding. Can see the exact elevations to 10cm in EOSDIS-Earthdata layer in JOSM. Many peaks seem to be a little off.
Rob |
|
| 191375809 | They do, and so do AUBUC and Abruzzo PAI do, in fact some ditches you deleted are in so plane sight I wonder what imagery use. Anyway, I've reversed your waterway and other deletions. Watch out for those hypothetical hikers as they might fall in unsuspecting. |
|
| 191362149 | Ok if twice on the same binary I stand corrected. Cheers. |
|
| 191362149 | Today saw you removing a stop in Francavilla. The main station Poi is centred with info off rail, ususually a platform and the stop spots are just that with only the name to know which it is and then they are just meters apart, but then the stop spot of a bus is often just meters away from where the shelter, fermata is mapped, so kindly put back compliant with wiki. |
|
| 191362149 | Hi, Why are you removing the stop spots from rails at stations? Seen you doing that several times now. SekeRob |
|
| 191333553 | Head spin... the data links in Josm go to ABDUC :o)) |
|
| 191333553 | Hi dp7, It's a toss up, in fact PAI and Earthdata/Sonny LiDAR agree, but then PAI / AUBUC live by omission. A hard look in fact could have the old way as a fork converging again below. I have restored your version with some smooth.
PS Earthdata and Topo overlay quite well, where Earthdata shows the gradients directly on the imagery (Orto EPSG-32633 alignment) |
|
| 190443002 | OK, thanks for keeping a watchful eye out. Retagged as riding arena. SekeRob |
|
| 190383974 | Outstanding 👍 |
|
| 190246690 | Hi, After your remodeling I see 2 broken u-turn restrictions (what Italian traffic law or signing forbids that anyway other than maybe safe behaviour?) and in Mapbox'26 see 2 missing yield spots for left turns from the SP58 onto the SP57. Probably lane counts need introducing to say which is straight and which right. Also the area is lit given the streetlamp shades. happy mapping
|
|
| 189970797 | Hi, See you're back and alerts going off again. Deleting objects, reducing details, using outdated imagery. DWG been notified. SekeRob |