SD Mapman's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 189461745 | Hello! For future reference, typically chain stores (Walmart, Safeway, Taco John's, etc.) don't include the city name in the name= field. Thanks! |
|
| 187210368 | Thank you! |
|
| 187210368 | What would be a good translation of way/1548521135? Looking for something to put in the name:en= field. |
|
| 188109614 | The more you know, neat! |
|
| 188109614 | Question about the two forks of the Vermillion River, would they both have the same name:dak and name:lkt tags? Just curious. |
|
| 188851176 | Hello, after reviewing your body of work it seems like you are adding vast fictional freeway networks to the map. This is not good mapping behavior, please desist. |
|
| 188850900 | Hello! I was unaware that there were freeway projects proposed for Aberdeen. Are these actually real projects? If not, please consider osm.wiki/OpenGeofiction as fictional mapping is vandalism and should be removed. |
|
| 188745514 | The City is actually replacing the street blades with ones with directionals on them, the new segments have directionals as well. It wasn't originally supposed to have directionals (know consultant who was involved), but something must have changed at the City |
|
| 188390510 | I tried something here: changeset/188598742 I think we should leave the name on the recreation area for now (unless you want to add the Dakota/Lakota translation for "park" or "recreation area" at the end), since natural=gorge is not well supported. |
|
| 188390510 | Great work! Couple follow-up questions: Would the name for the lake Clear Lake also apply to the town Clear Lake? Should the name for the Dells go on the (currently-unmapped) geographic feature rather than the city-run recreation area? I can map the cliffs and port the name over if needed. |
|
| 188302677 | Hey, just so you're aware, the phone number formatting you edited isn't the accepted formatting (see phone=*#United_States). Just so you're aware for future work. Thanks for adding POIs in the Empire! |
|
| 173817835 | So both of those were when I started adding multilingual names and wasn't really aware of the rules yet. For North Spearfish I found a translator, translated "north", and stuck it on to the name for Spearfish. Kinda forgot about it honestly. Not sure if that would be the best practice for this; you're more of the expert than me if you want to remove it go ahead. Mountain Plains was a transliteration (along with all the others), kind of an inside joke. In my opinion, the Census Bureau made a mistake calling this a CDP (especially just reusing the development name), so I thought having the silly name in as many different languages as possible would be funny. After I put that in, I read the wiki page that says "Transliteration is BAD" but never bothered to remove the multilingual names. These have been removed. |
|
| 187763521 | There's trails up there now? Do they allow runners? |
|
| 186891386 | Made the updates for this. I'll have to run these next time I'm in Brookings, looks interesting |
|
| 186891386 | Eh, Strava is good enough for me. Abbreviations are usually spelled out and normal capitalization rules are followed for future reference. |
|
| 186491986 | Sounds good, if NDOT went through the effort to change the addresses more power to them (wish SD organizations would too...) |
|
| 186491986 | Also would have kept the classifications the same as well, but that's a personal preference. |
|
| 186891386 | Hello! Seems mostly reasonable to me. Does way/1547047158 actually have a signed name? If not the name= field should just be empty. |
|
| 186491986 | then it would be fine to switch them |
|
| 186491986 | Did they update the road names as well? My experience is that if the highway number changes, the road name doesn't (see way/1275022178 and way/9928641 and way/330786276 for example). I would have left the road names as-is even while swapping the highway numbers/relations but if you have sources to the contrary |