OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
80119785 over 5 years ago

This was improvisational, because PSMA did not include data for Macquarie Island.

79402041 over 5 years ago

Disputed was the wrong word on my part then. However, the source PSMA data for the LGAs includes these areas as part of Flinders. Hence why they overlap across the Vic border.

91534475 over 5 years ago

PS. We will not yield to the attacks of the sovereignty of the state of Tasmania by mainlanders! ;)

91534475 over 5 years ago

https://www.theage.com.au/national/states-divided-between-diemen-and-deep-blue-sea-20050120-gdzefu.html

I believe these islets are disputed territory, hence the overlap.

79402041 over 5 years ago

https://www.theage.com.au/national/states-divided-between-diemen-and-deep-blue-sea-20050120-gdzefu.html

I believe these islets are disputed territory, hence the overlap.

62329359 over 7 years ago

Comment should be "Australia maritime boundaries import - territorial waters, NSW/Norfolk Island."

62329060 over 7 years ago

Comment should be "Australia maritime boundaries import - territorial waters, Coral Sea Islands."

60111716 over 7 years ago

I have continued the discussion in the mailing list.
Regards,
Lee

60111716 over 7 years ago

Just to clarify this is CAPAD 2016 data, with names extrapolated from the review.

60111716 over 7 years ago

Oh bugger, I commented on the wrong changeset.
I was explaining my reasoning for the Commonwealth reserves only.

60396980 over 7 years ago

For some reasoning behind the import method, please see my comments below:
changeset/60111716

60111716 over 7 years ago

And just to clarify my methods,

I have not included the zoning of the reserves in my imports for a few reasons:

*It's not in CAPAD! (yet).
*A single marine park is more straightforward for OSM users.
*I am using Wikidata tags which reference the reserve as a whole (this is not a limitation, but mostly because of the following points:)
*I would argue that the zones are not distinct entities of the marine park.
*Easier to import and manage.
Regards,
Lee

60111716 over 7 years ago

G'day Cleary,

I recently began importing the Australian marine parks and noticed that you have made a start as well!

Unfortunately, the CAPAD 2016 data is out of date because new management plans began for almost all commonwealth reserves on the 1st of this month. Most importantly:

*"Commonwealth Marine Reserves" are now called "Marine Parks".
*Outer boundaries are unchanged, but there have been a lot of internal zoning changes (i.e. Sanctuary Zone, etc).

But don't worry, I have already updated your contributions as part of my import progress.

39638161 over 8 years ago

FYI: I have two accounts, "RoundCircle" and "Multi Pass". The former I now use for imports and large scale edits such as this. Cheers.

39638161 over 8 years ago

Hello,
I removed the Tasmanian LGA relations from OpenStreetMap as I was unable to attain appropriate attribution for use in OpenStreetMap. Here is the link to the changeset: changeset/48107126

39834599 over 9 years ago

Wrong comment - meant to say "Update/fix islands in Bass Strait"