Changeset When Comment
191319620

Damn you made it first

181768288

Check these two:

node/2629470610
node/2629470609

181768288

Tuen Yan Street wrongly placed and the KMB stops are all duplicate

190961587

Sorry I mean "opening_hours=*"

190961587

For all "service_hours=*" please just state time when there are no difference between days. Apart from Mo-Su there's also PH (Public Holidays) and SH (School Holidays). Although HK might not have defined exact dates they still apply.

190590143

The bus stops are put too close together. Refer to the TD page and the image

https://www.td.gov.hk/tc/transport_in_hong_kong/land_based_cross_boundary_transport/athp/

185204948

What is the rationale / source of adding "*" in "ref" of special depatures?

157740527

I don't think it's a good idea to reuse a bus route relation on a completely different route.

167871532

I understand you don't like adding "stop" for routes but, please, don't disregard others' effort of doing it entirely.

171661782

Sorry iD forced me to tag way/206804333 to get my edits uploaded.

135267828

@Mateusz Konieczny: This might be a result of following other nodes or ways in the vicinity. Maybe I could have done otherwise and lure the original contributor.

If I had it my way I would always use "bus=yes" or "bus=private"

171004732

But is Shansum an organization qualifying for "landuse=institutional"? I thought it's a commercial organization

171004732

IMHO landuse=amenity is meaningless, at least under OSM terminology. Almost anything on OSM can be considered an amenity one way or another.

I think you should have asked on a general OSM group before making this edit. Or had you already asked but hadn't received any response?

171004732

Vector, They have buildings for holding ashes. Check out https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golders_Green_Crematorium, which does NOT have landuse tag on OSM. I suggest you revert this change.

161583804

Your changed messed up depiction of KMB 5D!

153504633

This change messed up certain buildings along Prince Edward Road. They now look plain and unrealistic on F4Maps demo.

167340590

Hi Kovoschiz,

I commented because I found this user had made two similar changesets, so I would love to see if the Tsing Yi ones were in one changeset while the Kwai Chung ones in the other.

I agree that the user's more recent changes are on the other extreme.

167340590

Although not as serious as cross-continent edits, these two features are still rather far apart with respect to their localities. Both this and changeset/167340586 should be better organized such that they only consist of features close to each other.

158226353

Why do you change the railway= tags? Did you consult anyone else?

149112291

What is way/1154508355? Why is it denoted as a motorway?