Patrickov's Comments
| Changeset | When | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 191319620 | Damn you made it first |
|
| 181768288 | Check these two: |
|
| 181768288 | Tuen Yan Street wrongly placed and the KMB stops are all duplicate |
|
| 190961587 | Sorry I mean "opening_hours=*" |
|
| 190961587 | For all "service_hours=*" please just state time when there are no difference between days. Apart from Mo-Su there's also PH (Public Holidays) and SH (School Holidays). Although HK might not have defined exact dates they still apply. |
|
| 190590143 | The bus stops are put too close together. Refer to the TD page and the image https://www.td.gov.hk/tc/transport_in_hong_kong/land_based_cross_boundary_transport/athp/ |
|
| 185204948 | What is the rationale / source of adding "*" in "ref" of special depatures? |
|
| 157740527 | I don't think it's a good idea to reuse a bus route relation on a completely different route. |
|
| 167871532 | I understand you don't like adding "stop" for routes but, please, don't disregard others' effort of doing it entirely. |
|
| 171661782 | Sorry iD forced me to tag way/206804333 to get my edits uploaded. |
|
| 135267828 | @Mateusz Konieczny: This might be a result of following other nodes or ways in the vicinity. Maybe I could have done otherwise and lure the original contributor. If I had it my way I would always use "bus=yes" or "bus=private" |
|
| 171004732 | But is Shansum an organization qualifying for "landuse=institutional"? I thought it's a commercial organization |
|
| 171004732 | IMHO landuse=amenity is meaningless, at least under OSM terminology. Almost anything on OSM can be considered an amenity one way or another. I think you should have asked on a general OSM group before making this edit. Or had you already asked but hadn't received any response? |
|
| 171004732 | Vector, They have buildings for holding ashes. Check out https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golders_Green_Crematorium, which does NOT have landuse tag on OSM. I suggest you revert this change. |
|
| 161583804 | Your changed messed up depiction of KMB 5D! |
|
| 153504633 | This change messed up certain buildings along Prince Edward Road. They now look plain and unrealistic on F4Maps demo. |
|
| 167340590 | Hi Kovoschiz, I commented because I found this user had made two similar changesets, so I would love to see if the Tsing Yi ones were in one changeset while the Kwai Chung ones in the other. I agree that the user's more recent changes are on the other extreme. |
|
| 167340590 | Although not as serious as cross-continent edits, these two features are still rather far apart with respect to their localities. Both this and changeset/167340586 should be better organized such that they only consist of features close to each other. |
|
| 158226353 | Why do you change the railway= tags? Did you consult anyone else? |
|
| 149112291 | What is way/1154508355? Why is it denoted as a motorway? |