OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
163433159 10 months ago

Hello, my colleague AzuisRiver has addressed your comment on changeset/163435257 to keep the conversation in one thread, as it pertains to the same subject. Thanks!

161659139 12 months ago

Hello miroslavuzice87,
I reviewed the road Jirón Cruz del Sur (way/35893589, way/35893577) and made an update here. Thanks for reaching out.

Happy Mapping!

122190083 about 1 year ago

Hello afgb1977,

Thank you for the detailed information regarding classification in Colombia. I appreciate your dedication to improving the data and want to reassure you that my team’s goal is to support and collaborate with the local community. Regarding way/728101150, thank you for adding ground level photographs, but I trust your perspective and the information you’ve shared generally on these types of roads. My intention in the original response was to justify the potential thought process of the inactive editor, Grasmere, in making the change from over two years ago. That said, I am happy to defer to your edits and knowledge here. I will keep your insight regarding classification in rural areas in mind as I edit moving forward and to be sure, I will pass on your insights to the rest of my team. Thanks again for your local knowledge of the area. That is important and very valuable to the map.

Have a nice day!

122190083 about 1 year ago

Our team has been actively engaged in projects in Colombia for several years, and the local community is well-acquainted with our presence. Our Community Lead, Teddy Ahlvin, has introduced himself on Telegram. Our previous Community Lead, Andrew Wiseman, has actively participated in numerous discussions on the Colombia OSM talk list Talk-co, which has been shared among Telegram participants. Additionally, information about our projects can be found on GitHub (https://github.com/osmlab/appledata/issues/43) and the Organized Editing wiki (osm.wiki/Organised_Editing/Activities/Apple). These platforms provide further details on our ongoing projects in Colombia.

Our team is aware of the Colombia/Guide to Mapping you linked and consistently adhere to any local community policies outlined on the wiki. Given the building=house tags (way/1066141249
- way/728101150), the road in question (way/728101150 ) appears to align with the criteria for residential classification as outlined in the local wiki (osm.wiki/ES:Colombia/Gu%C3%ADa_para_mapear).

Since classification can be subjective and interpreted differently by various users, I will defer to your expertise in these cases. Thanks for the feedback!

Best regards,
NewryCanal

122190083 about 1 year ago

Hello afgb1977, The editor Grasmere is no longer on our team so I will address your question on their behalf. The road at way/728101150 was likely reclassified as residential as it accesses settlements and the OSM wiki for highway=track states ”Roads used for access to permanent human settlements or facilities should generally not use this tag” (highway=track). The road at way/708831977 also appears to have settlements along it but I can understand why unclassified would be favorable here, as it represents mixed used roads. I am happy to defer to your edits and knowledge of the area here. Have a nice day!

151051771 over 1 year ago

"Facalderonm,
Thank you for reaching out about this! I agree that there seems to be some disagreement on this road especially compared to the wiki. Our community contact Teddy Alvin (tahlvin@apple.com) will continue the discussion on the Colombia Telegram (https://t.me/osmco) to help get a consensus of this road and other roads in Bogota.

Traducción automática
Facalderonm,
¡Gracias por comunicarte con esto! Estoy de acuerdo en que parece haber cierto desacuerdo en este camino, especialmente en comparación con la wiki. Nuestro contacto comunitario, Teddy Alvin (tahlvin@apple.com), continuará la discusión en Colombia Telegram (https://t.me/osmco) para ayudar a lograr un consenso sobre esta y otras carreteras en Bogotá."