OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

Changeset When Comment
137450608

Unfortunately, our conversation. It ended in stubbornness. good luck I thought you were full of knowledge, but you had nothing in your pocket. And now you didn’t bring up the resource you’re editing the maps on.
bless you

137450608

My brother, in the fight against ISIS, Khanaqin, Jaloula, Karatapa, Jabara, Kirkuk province, Makhmur district, Sinjar district, Hamdania district, Bartala and Bashiqa. They fell under the control of the Kurdistan Regional Government. But after 2017. The Iraqi government went back to these areas. The political and administrative situation returned to normal.
I currently live in Sulaymaniyah. The current administrative division of the Kurdistan Regional Government and the Iraqi government is as follows.

https://www.cosit.gov.iq/AAS/AAS2012/section_10/1.htm

I don't know why you deny it. What do you get out of this.

Brother, you've been taking my time for two days. I have a job. i'm reading I'm writing. I work on Kurdish Wikipedia. I don't have enough time to worry about your stubbornness. You don't understand me. I better leave OpenStreet Map to you. You modify it as you wish.
goodbye

137450608

How do you know they are not part of Sulaymaniyah? Take me to the source. Promise me I'll do what you say. You give him the source after 2017. You're just saying this on your own.

137450608

hello friend
I searched a lot and asked for a good source in the Iraqi government. I couldn't find any other sources.
I modify the patterns with these two sources. If you are blocking then I am not running in OpenStreetMap.
Search all Iraqi government sites. You only get this administrative division.

https://www.cosit.gov.iq/AAS/section_1.php

https://www.cosit.gov.iq/AAS/AAS2012/section_10/1.htm

You decide, if you return my edits, I won't edit anything.
These two sources belong to the Iraqi government.
thank you

137450608

Now you are not convinced by my edits, what can I do. I am not convinced by your edits either. If you want me to stop editing, I'll leave this website. As long as you get me the right source.
I want to reach a conclusion, but you are preventing me and you have no evidence.
with respect.

137450608

This website doesn't exist. What is this you sent? I don't think you have anything. Send something better. Shame you sent that. Don't make excuses for me anymore. My resources are better. I told you that you can't find an Iraqi site with such things.
Dear friend, I want to serve my country. Don't make excuses for my edits anymore. What I know. Let the citizens of my country benefit from it.

137450608

Your sources did not belong to the Iraqi government. So I'm arguing with you. I want you to give me the right source. But obviously you have nothing, you just make excuses for me. This is not good for you. Please send me a valid source.
Just don't evade my question.

137450608

I feel like you don't know anything about Iraq and the Kurdistan Region. I just wanted to know what source you relied on to insist on your words. I want that resource.
with respect.

137450608

This seems to you that the KRG map is incredible. You want it to be your own word. Otherwise, the maps are unbelievable and in reality they are.
The city of Kufri, the capital of Kufri district. The governor will be appointed by the governor of Sulaimani.
But you know nothing about Article 140 and are just looking at a map from the 1990s. So it's better for me not to work in Open Streetmap. How long have I worked on this site, no one has stopped me and asked for resources like you? It's better for me not to waste my time with you. Because you are deflecting from the truth.
The KRG has existed since the 1990s and is accredited by the Iraqi government and the United Nations. But you don’t want anyone serving on this site. I hope you stop being stubborn. Obviously you have no knowledge of Iraq. You are either an extremist Ba'athist chauvinist or ISIS.
Or you are much smarter than the Iraqi constitution.

137450608

I apologize that these things have not been done since the war against ISIS. It's still a map from the 1990s. But why don't you believe in the KRG's map?

137450608

hello dear
Well, send me a map of Iraqi administrative units or a table of Iraqi administrative units, but let it be new. So that I can work on it.
I think you're an Iraqi.

137450608

Hello sir, you are the only one who has followed my stuff. Search all Iraqi government websites Currently there is no map of Iraq correctly, you do not believe the official website of the Kurdistan Regional Government that the Kurdistan Region is recognized in the Iraqi constitution. So working in such a place is not fun and it is better to leave. How many times have I worked and no one has bothered me like you. I feel like you're a Ba'athist. Until a good person for this website.

137450608

That’s when I decided to give up Open Street Map anymore. I go to Google Maps and start changing. Obviously, we don't feel tired here. My resources and abilities are unbelievable. I have traveled and recorded the whole Kurdistan Region. But unfortunately, you want destroyers, not doers. You are obviously a chauvinist.
thank you

137437508

https://krso.gov.krd/ar/map/أربيل

137437508

https://krso.gov.krd/ar/map/السليمانية/الاداریة

137437508

https://krso.gov.krd/ar/map

137437508

May I ask you where you are from

137437508

hello dear
I want you to understand that in the current situation, this is stated in the Iraqi constitution. It is called (Article 140). The conflict areas divided between the Kurdistan Regional Government and the Iraqi Government. This is the case in Sulaimani, Erbil and Duhok provinces.
The Kurdistan Region is an official region of Iraq. The boundaries are defined. For example, Kufri district belongs to Sulaimani province. However, two districts, Qaratapa and Jabara, belong to Diyala province. Administratively, they no longer belong to Kufri district.

Sir, rest assured that I have not made a mistake in determining the boundaries. I hope you don't block and restore my edits.

137437508

Hello, I hope you understand me. Your first source still won't open. Your second source is any map. Your third source is Google Maps, which is edited like Open Streetmap. Take a look at this table showing the Iraqi administrative units. Kufri district belongs to Sulaimani province. I didn’t make these adjustments on my own.
https://www.cosit.gov.iq/AAS/AAS2012/section_10/1.htm

137437508

Hi LockOnGuy
had narrated my edits,
I live in the Kurdistan Region myself and have expertise in geography and administrative units. I didn’t make those changes on my own. Currently, the maps of Iraq, the Kurdistan Region and the administrative units are as follows. This is an agreement between the two governments of Iraq and the Kurdistan Region. Because these areas are in trouble, the maps are like this for now.
I would like you to read this article:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disputed_territories_of_Northern_Iraq

You are looking at pre-2003 maps. These are wrong for the time being. The borders of the Kurdistan Region that you define belong to the autonomy period.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kurdistan_Region

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kurdistan_Region#/media/File:Kurdistan_governorates_2015.png

https://ckb.wikipedia.org/wiki/ھەرێمی_کوردستان#/media/پەڕگە:Iraqi_Kurdistan_in_Iraq_(de-facto_and_disputed_hatched).svg

https://www.marefa.org/أقضية_محافظة_السليمانية#/media/ملف:Silemani_governorate_2012.png

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sulaymaniyah_Governorate

Take a look at these sources and my edits back to the maps. We can discuss any comments you have. Thanks