Hello Sandalss,
Thank you for your contribution to OpenStreetMap in Oman.
I noticed you added a tag (ref=D320) for some streets.
Here are examples of those roads:
way/284159717
way/746786029
way/506500593
It is not compatible according to our latest document
https://mjla.gov.om/decisions/ar/1071/show/1188
Do you have any sources confirming that? If you do, please share those sources with me.
Regards,
Merna_mahmoud

Hello Sandalss,
Thank you for your contribution to OpenStreetMap in Oman.
I noticed you converted these streets from construction to operation:
"way/1059489017, way/621307533, way/245251156, way/245251160, way/1059489016, way/1059489018, way/1419276637, way/1419276636," knowing that the latest satellite image I have is (Maxar satellite imagery via MGP Pro 2025-09-08). The roads appear to be under construction. Do you have any sources confirming that the streets are operational? If you do, please share those sources with me. If not, please address this issue.
Regards,
Merna_mahmoud

Correction: Source used was Maxar satellite imagery via MGP Pro 2024-08-13

Hello Amineee__,
Thank you for your response
Regards
Merna_mahmoud

Hello Sandalss,
Thank you for your contribution to OpenStreetMap in Oman.
I noticed that you deleted some streets within the Omani border control. It is an acceptable modification, but this deletion resulted in some barriers without streets.
Examples :
node/11384328675
node/11384328881
node/11384329112
Please delete those barriers without streets, there is no need to leave them
Happy to connect with you
Regards,
Merna_mahmoud

Hello Amineee__,
Thank you for your contribution to OpenStreetMap
I noticed that you recently modified the classification of some streets
in this changeset.
changeset/166431859
However, this classification is not suitable for the road network in that area
As a result, our team has updated the classification to highway=primary, which is more appropriate for the road type.
Examples :
way/1387803300
way/1387803301
For this reason, this street was modified
However, I also noticed a more recent change in this changeset.
changeset/166699950
You changed the classification again—this time to highway=primary_link. Additionally, there's still a segment that remains unmodified:
Examples :
way/1387803298
Could you please tell me the reason for this classification change?
Regards,
Merna_mahmoud

Hello Sandalss,
Thank you for your quick response
This is a link to a wiki page that explains how to use the classification for links
see:osm.wiki/Highway_link
Therefore, when the road has branches, it is preferable for them to be of the same classification as the main road, so that the road classifications are consistent with the road network.
Examples :
osm.org/way 333615073
osm.org/way 982878313
osm.org/way 1012680223
While we use links when it is a transition from one street to another (connecting two streets )
Examples :
osm.org/way 982878311
osm.org/way 982878312
For these reasons, all streets were modified, such as the one mentioned above.
Happy to connect with you
Regards,
Merna_mahmoud

Hello Sandalss,
Thank you for your contribution to OpenStreetMap in Oman.
According to our information, the correct way to the road network for the branches for the street shall be of the same road classification, but I noticed you changed the classification of some streets to link
Examples of streets:
way/498352593
way/798968764
way/798968781
Do you have a specific concept to implement in the country?
Regards,
Merna_mahmoud

Hi sandalss,
I already sent a comment for you a few days ago in this changeset: "changeset/164786398", asking you about your source, without any response from you, then we edited these refs based on my available source: "https://mjla.gov.om/decisions/ar/1071/show/1188"
This is the latest version of the Oman Ministry of Transport's magazine regards numbering roads
Best regards
Merna_mahmoud

Hello Sandalss,
Thank you for your contribution to OpenStreetMap in Oman.
I noticed you added a "ref=BE" tag in some sections of the Batinah Expressway.
Here are examples of those roads:
way/617090848
way/565166768
However, this source indicates the road's reference number is "ref=N1": https://mjla.gov.om/decisions/ar/1071/show/1188
If you have a more current source than this document, could you please share it with us?
Regards,
Merna_mahmoud

Hello Sandalss;
Thank you for your quick response and for correcting errors
Regards
Merna_mahmoud

Hello Sandalss;
Thank you for your contribution to OpenStreetMap Oman.
I noticed you added an access tag at the highway=crossing,
For examples:
node/8345751489
node/8345848685
node/8345848583
node/8345891657
node/8345891661
node/8345891660
node/12692882938
node/8638670062
node/8638670061
According to the OSM wiki documentation for highway=crossing, the use of an access tag with this feature is not mentioned or documented as standard practice.
highway=crossing
If you have different information please share that with us, if not please fix that.
Best regards.
Merna_mahmoud

Hello Socks2;
Thank you for contributing to OpenStreetMap in Oman,
I noticed you deleted a gate, and I find that it is shown in all satellite image
node/5636161047
Could you please provide us with the source you used to delete the gate?
Best regards
Merna_mahmoud

Hello numide;
Thank you for sharing this information.
Regards
Merna_mahmoud

Hello numide;
Thank you for contributing to OpenStreetMap in Algeria,
I noticed you converted streets to the operation that's led to some streets becoming floating because it's connected with streets that are under construction
Examples of streets:
way/961245322
way/961245320
Could you please check it and correct it?
Regards
Merna_mahmoud

Hi okainov,
Thank you for your message. I modified it to improve the shape and treat the sharp angel because crossing on slopes
Thank you.
Merna_mahmoud

Correction: Source used was Maxar SecureWatch Imagery 2024-04-12

Thank you.

Hello Nawfal85;
Thank you for bringing my attention, the alley is fixed now.
regards
Merna_mahmoud